He’s the kind of man who claims he can recognize someone who once milked cows, and has a story to tell about it. Many of us have known the old codger in the diner who liked to make unexpected claims about his life and then tell a story about them to explain how they made sense.
He is the famous, and famously eccentric, German filmmaker Werner Herzog, in his “Every Man for Himself and God Against All: A Memoir,” probably best known for his documentary “Grizzly Man.” As a child in a very poor family in a very rural part of Bavaria, to which his mother had fled with her two boys during World War II, he’d had to milk their cow.
During a meeting with NASA astronauts reluctant to act in a science fiction film he was making, he said “that in the course of my work with actors and faces I could often sense some of the things that lay beneath.” He told the pilot that he looked like a man who knew how to milk a cow. The man was so pleased to be recognized for this skill that he convinced the other astronauts to act in the movie.
Mr. Herzog was there because he’d broken into the grounds of the Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Pasadena. And got away with it. He went up the door, and the guards caught him, but a physicist walking by just then recognized him, knew a higher-up in D.C. to call, who turned out to know Mr. Herzog’s films and ordered the guards to “let the madman in with his camera.”
His whole life seems to have gone like that. Things work out. He started filming by stealing a camera from the Munich Institute, because he found himself in the storage room during a rare time when no one else was there. He could rationalize the theft, in a way he explains much of his life. “It felt to me more like appropriation than theft, or to put it differently, I was exercising a natural right to put the camera to its intended use.”
Mr. Herzog has a Pittsburgh connection. He spent much of a year in the city at 22 or 23, when as a promising film student he got a scholarship to Duquesne, which he did not like, but met a family he very much did. With the Franklins of Fox Chapel, “I got to know some of the best and deepest things about America,” though he doesn’t say what they are. Working on documentaries at WQED, characteristically not telling the station he didn’t have a work permit, he learned to admire Americans’ “pragmatic optimism.” He then hid in Mexico to avoid being deported.
You can read the story online in an excerpt from the book called “The Mysteries of Pittsburgh,” published in The New Yorker.
Readers may know him as the villain Zek in the Tom Cruise movie “Jack Reacher,” which was filmed in Pittsburgh. The filmmakers seemed to have thought Americans would accept his German accent as a Russian one. He looked for the Franklins, but couldn’t find them.
As far as I have been able to find, people who know Mr. Herzog or his work don’t know exactly how true his stories are. They feel true, speaking as someone who’s had to investigate people’s stories. That is, as true as memoirs tend to be, with the rough spots sanded down and the drama and the pathos heightened to make better stories.
Werner Herzog, now 81, is that rare creature, an artist who fits our romantic ideal of an artist: someone who does what he wants and makes what he wants to make, and doesn’t care what anyone thinks about him or his work. And because he’s so gifted, and so persistent, and so brave (would you have broken into a secure NASA facility?), he’s made a life of it. And a very entertaining book, in the diner-codger mode.
David Mills is the associate editorial page editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.