Isle McElroy’s “People Collide” transported me back to the college lecture hall where I first learned of Judith Butler’s theory of performativity.
I was once again a 21-year-old interrogating how to define “woman” and “man,” and whether those are the only categories available. The turning point of my understanding of gender was reading Simone de Beauvoir’s seminal work “The Second Sex,” in which she writes, “One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman.”
After reading “People Collide,” I can only suspect that McElroy has a similar conception of gender. Of course, none of the feminist literature I read in college featured a body-swap plotline a la Freaky Friday. Thankfully, McElroy’s novel rectifies this mistake.
A quick introduction: Eli and Elizabeth, our newlywed protagonists, live in a tiny apartment in Bulgaria. Elizabeth, a rising star in the literary world, is teaching English on a prestigious government-funded fellowship. Dedicated, self-confident and talented, Elizabeth is who every young writer aspires to be.
Eli, on the other hand, finds himself lacking in comparison to his wife. Like Elizabeth, he is a writer, but unlike Elizabeth, he has less natural aptitude and has yet to be published. He also exhibits extreme self-esteem issues.
Opposites attract, I guess. The culmination of their diametrically opposed love affair is their wedding: They got married so that Eli could live in Bulgaria with Elizabeth while she is on her assignment.
Then, of course, the body swap. Eli wakes up, gets dressed, speaks with some friends and heads to meet Elizabeth at her job. However, everyone seems to be treating him strangely. It is not until Elizabeth’s boss yells at him for being late does he begin to realize something is amiss. Inexplicably, Eli goes an entire chapter without noticing that he is not, in fact, in his own body.
With Elizabeth — presumably in Eli’s body — nowhere to be found, Eli is in the unenviable position of contacting both his and Elizabeth’s families. Does Eli know his wife well enough to fool her parents? To act as though she is reacting to her husband’s disappearance? Somewhat irrelevant.
With the assumption (read: hope) that they will one day return to their original bodies, the primary concern on Eli’s mind is the caretaking of his wife’s body.
Through long internal diatribes on how to touch, look at, bathe and move in Elizabeth’s body, McElroy allows Eli to become more likable, depicting him as the doting, loving husband. He is gentle, treating her body as something borrowed, something that must be cherished and respected.
These musings from Eli, which take up a significant portion of the first section of the book and return sparingly in later sections, are my favorite parts. The pure affection he has for her here is striking and led me to reevaluate my criteria for romantic partners: Would my partner be willing and able to manage the upkeep of my body if we were swapped?
In the wake of dealing with the heartbreak of his and Elizabeth’s parents, Eli sets out to follow up on a lead about Elizabeth’s whereabouts. He tracks her down to Paris, and after a game of cat-and-mouse and a remarkably steamy tryst in a museum bathroom, he convinces her to return home with him.
Once the couple is reunited, McElroy pulls apart the emotional threads of not being at home in one’s body. Elizabeth adores moving through the world in a man’s body, unafraid and unbothered, and relishes the sexuality of being quite literally inside the man she is attracted to. Eli, while far more hesitant about being the caretaker of Elizabeth’s body, has discovered the joy of being perceived as a woman.
Being nonbinary myself, I am delighted to see gender nuances translated so beautifully onto the page by a nonbinary author.
I would be remiss if I didn’t mention that this novel has a niche audience. It is suitable for those who enjoy a mystery but won’t be put off by some unexplained magical elements, love flawed and somewhat unlikable characters, and won’t be annoyed by a myriad of unanswered questions — including the question of why the author included a largely unnecessary mass shooting event as a plot point.
If your ideal Sunday afternoon, like mine, involves pondering the intricacies of the mind/body dichotomy through the lens of fantastical narratives, then there is nobody better to spend it with than Eli and Elizabeth.
Nina Richner, a literary assistant at Howard Morhaim Literary Agency, lives in Brooklyn with their dog, cat and partner.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.