Poverty looks different here than it does in other countries, and we have more of it than any other advanced democracy. In “Poverty, by America,” Matthew Desmond explains why, and more importantly, how we can change it.

Assuming that we want to change it, anyway. I asked Mr. Desmond for his response to critics who might say that poverty is the price we pay for the levels of economic prosperity we enjoy.

“That’s something only a rich person could say,” he began before turning to the data: how historically and statistically we can prove that poverty is not a necessary evil of economic dynamism. As he shared with me over the phone, “the biggest myth about poverty is that we have to live with it.”

This illustrates the greatest strength of Mr. Desmond’s work: a sound foundation, blueprinted in extensive citations. Almost 30% of the text is devoted to the Notes section. In a world where much of the criticism of government aid to the poor is based on anecdotes instead of evidence, every claim of Mr. Desmond’s that neither welfare nor food stamps, neither single mothers nor immigrants are to blame for poverty is backed up by studies that the ardent reader could check themselves, if so inclined.

Advertise with us

Calls to action cover a wide range, from the more abstract, like building empathy for those stuck in the cycle of poverty, to the specific and actionable, like attending local zoning meetings or voting with your wallet. Mr. Desmond believes the latter is a great way for the newly anointed poverty abolitionist to get their foot in the door. Consumer activism is a first step that tells businesses what we care about. While some critics see it as performative or distracting from the larger picture, there’s no denying that it can still make a big difference, with little investment of time or money. As an example: a beer drinker can lean toward Miller or Rolling Rock because they are union-made. It’s that simple.

Where I predict many will clash with Mr. Desmond’s ideas is in the call to sacrifice. Willingly forgoing some level of private opulence to alleviate public squalor is covered in a chapter called, “How we buy opportunity.” The idea is that despite popular rhetoric, abolishing poverty is not a win-win: If abolishing poverty also helped the rich get richer, then it would already be done.

That said, it is not the working class or blue-collar families who would or should bear this cross. Do our nurses and steel workers clock out and go home to private opulence? No. When we talk about making sacrifices, we’re not looking at the neighbors who may be above the poverty line but are far from rich. We’re looking at the modern day Andrew Carnegies and Henry Clay Fricks, who lived in mansions wallpapered with velvet while their employees lived in patch houses. It’s not about raising your taxes; it’s about empowering the IRS to hold tax criminals accountable.

I hope people will read this book and see the ways that antagonism is sown between working class and poor folks, and understand that this orchestrated division is designed to distract us.

The biggest reason poverty is different in America than in Italy, Switzerland, the Netherlands and elsewhere is that we don’t invest as much in the public sector as other countries. According to Mr. Desmond, this one example — allowing the IRS to hold the rich accountable for the taxes they owe — could end poverty in America. The book puts forth many more, and reveals much faith in the American people to choose the right path, if they are offered it.

Advertise with us

The myth that poverty is inevitable is a “weirdly anti-American myth,” because we are such a bombastic and unsatisfied people. When things aren’t working, we seek change. We can reach the “freer, healthier, more dynamic” ideals that we are collectively pining for through poverty abolition. I implore you to read the book, and to come out to hear Mr. Desmond speak, to learn more about how.

Kaitlyn Shirey is an engineer and writer from Westmoreland County.