Full disclosure: I’m not a wine person. I don’t come from wine people. I don’t like the taste or the smell of it, and wine hangovers are the worst I have experienced. Maybe that’s because, like many people from my background, the first wine I drank was “whatever’s the cheapest thing at the grocery store.” I think, though, there’s also a cultural connotation that causes many people to instinctively think of wine drinkers as snooty elitists looking down on the rest of us.
At first glance, Michelle Wildgen’s newest novel, “Wine People,” seems designed to appeal to foodies, to “wine people,” to New Yorkers and New Yorker readers. Ms. Wildgen, after all, edited a food writing anthology and was a writer for the New York Times Book Review and the executive editor for the literary journal “Tin House.” Her first novel, 2006’s “You’re Not You,” later a movie of the same name, was about a classical pianist.
It’s the kind of resume and book title that could reasonably lead anyone not already familiar with Ms. Wildgen’s writing to expect elitism, the type of writing that’s more fun for the think-pieces it inspires than it is fun to read.
But from the first line of “Wine People,“ Ms. Wildgen shows that she’s aware of what readers might expect from the book, and she draws us in with self-aware humor: “There’s a secret we ‘wine people’ know,” the novel’s epigraph states, “and it is that everyone else hates us.”
Then we’re off, jumping into chapters that alternate between the perspectives of the two main characters — one woman, from a wealthy family within the wine business, trying to find her own path and prove she can succeed apart from her family; another woman, from more modest means, trying to find security and prove she belongs in a culture that often, to her as to me, seems foreign, self-important and exclusive.
As the novel develops, the two women become friends, compete in a “Succession”-like battle for their company’s future and develop expertise in an industry that is portrayed as an overwhelming system filled with a vast collection of flawed but fascinating individuals.
Ms. Wildgen noted when I interviewed her recently, “I love writing about people who are competent. I love writing about people who dig in hard on something, because it’s a quality I admire — and so that’s one of my favorite things about both of them: There’s no accidental nature to their expertise. It’s something that they absolutely pursued.”
There’s a pattern in the story’s character development: Minor character exposes major character’s flaw, and that exposure inspires the major character to change. Later, that major character encounters the same flaw in a minor character, but that minor character doesn’t change, and that lack of change makes the major character reconsider what they want. The pattern means the plot moves forward consistently, but never too mechanically or predictably.
Ms. Wildgen’s characters often reconsider their locations. The vineyards and corporate offices are well-drawn, and as settings shift throughout the book, the characters reevaluate how they relate to their surroundings.
“When I realized that setting is actually so much more than landscape, that it’s customs and manners and food and religion and economy and all that stuff, then I was like, Well now I’m fascinated by it,” Ms. Wildgen said to me. “Because it’s the human interaction with a place and how it shapes us and how we shape it.” That shows throughout the novel.
“Wine People” is a well-crafted, well-researched, thoroughly enjoyable and occasionally touching read, even for those who, like me, approach wine and the culture around it with a skepticism that verges on hostility. The main characters are complex without being unapproachable; the minor characters are well-drawn and offer hints of internal lives beyond the demands of the plot. The writing is emotionally honest, especially when the characters are lying to each other or to themselves.
It occurs to me that this book would pair perfectly with a warm summer afternoon, a comfortable chair on a porch — and a cold beer.
Michael Hodges writes poems, fiction, and reviews. Their first published book was “An Idea of Feathers.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.