In my fiction writing classroom, we often consider whether a main character needs to be likeable or relatable. In their new novel, “Our Hideous Progeny,” the author C. E. McGill at first successfully pulls off both likeability and relatability for their main character (and narrator) Mary Frankenstein. But then they keep at it, trying to convince readers that Mary is admirable. This almost sinks the novel.

As you probably guessed from that last name, yes, this is indeed a book set in a world where Victor Frankenstein (Mary’s great-uncle, as it turns out) had, some years back, engineered a bunch of body parts into a living, breathing humanoid monster. An amateur scientist herself, Mary is married to Henry, a paleontologist. Henry’s constantly annoyed that his arch-rival completely misunderstands how dinosaurs looked and moved, and would love to teach that guy a lesson. Since Henry is depicted as a sullen dolt who gambles away all of the couple’s money while Mary mourns the death of their newborn, it’s a little hard to buy that he’s the one person in all of England who understands paleontology, but okay. A smart woman in a terrible marriage at least makes Mary likeable and relatable.

After his debts force them into exile at his family home in Scotland, Mary rediscovers Dr. Frankenstein’s notes on his experiment and suddenly the duo have a project: building and bringing to life a dinosaur, which will certainly teach Henry’s archrival a thing or two. Once the project gets going, a visiting fellow scientist/​frenemy and Henry’s sister also get involved, collecting dead fish parts and figuring out how yeast can bring animals back to life.

I have to give credit to Mx. McGill: seeing the plot typed out like that makes it seem ridiculous, but the book reads very well. The author is adept at conveying the Victorian era, and when the creature is finally brought to life, my attention was rapt: I couldn’t help picturing the later-period photographs supposedly of the Loch Ness monster. Like them, the book successfully creates a haunting image of a lone animal out of its correct time, a potent metaphor for Mary’s own situation.

Advertise with us

But Mary herself doesn’t quite work. For one thing, Mx. McGill asks too much more of her: she’s to be a scientific genius, and a childless mother, wracked with grief. A feminist who clearly sees that she’s settled for a deeply flawed and incompetent man but also a woman of her time who will not stand up to him (nor to the frenemy, who assaulted her years before). Mary is also queer, which should be an exciting choice but just leads to a lot of fervent hand-holding with Henry’s sister. Mary’s mentor is a person of color, who has little to do in the book, except to demonstrate that Mary holds no prejudice.

That’s a lot of identity-signaling as is, but the step truly too far is that Mary’s decision to follow in her uncle’s footsteps is an act of hubris that goes stunningly unpunished. You’ll recall that in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, the novel ends with the doctor’s death before he can kill his Creature, and the Creature’s vow to die, too, setting itself adrift on an ice floe in the Arctic. How else could the story wrap up, really?

The uneasy subtext in “Our Hideous Progeny” is that Mary should be celebrated for what her great-uncle was punished for, just because of her identity and role in society. It’s an odd choice, ultimately making her unlikeable, unadmirable and frankly a little terrifying.

There’s a popular saying these days, which I will render for this family newspaper as “mess around and find out.” Mary does plenty of messing around. But I closed the novel wondering why Mx. McGill never had her find out.

Shannon Reed is teaching assistant professor of creative writing at Pitt and the author of ”Why Did I Get a B? And Other Mysteries We’re Discussing in the Faculty Lounge.”