“Fate is for pretty, privileged rich people with time to waste,” says 24-year-old Lizzie, the protagonist of “Love at First Set,” Jennifer Dugan’s new sapphic romance. “It’s not for me.”

Instead, Lizzie puts her stock in the gym, where she is a front desk manager who dreams of someday owning an inclusive, accessible place of her own. At gyms, people have control: weights, reps, routines, goals. “It was simple and reassuring during a childhood that was anything but.”

Ceaseless chaos with her mom undergirds Lizzie’s resistance to truly connecting with herself and others, including her best friend. James is a 28-year-old personal trainer and the son of the owners of the chain of gyms where he and Lizzie work. He’s forever falling in love with men on first dates, whereas Lizzie enjoys a “good time, not a long time.”

The story begins when James asks Lizzie to be his date to his sister Cara’s wedding. He tells Lizzie she’ll be able to use the trip to impress his wealthy and villainous parents so they’ll make her general manager of their chain’s new location — a job Lizzie desperately wants and is dragging her feet on applying for.

Advertise with us

Three drinks deep at the open bar before the rehearsal dinner, however, she all but holds them hostage to (terribly) pitch her business ideas before running away in mortification.

Enter the time-honored tradition of drunk women hyping sad women they don’t know in bathrooms. Lizzie is immediately taken by a beautiful, puffy-eyed woman who knows she should end her relationship but can’t bring herself to. Lizzie affirms that she deserves more than a lukewarm romance and shouldn’t settle. It’s not until they’re parting ways that Lizzie learns the woman is Cara, the bride-to-be. By the next morning, the wedding is off.

A new kind of chaos ensues.

The novel, Ms. Dugan’s first for adults after five for young adults, derives its tension from the characters refusing to speak truth out of habit, in addition to James and Lizzie swearing each other to assorted secrecies. “If our messages got any more mixed,” Lizzie says of Cara, “they’d be tie-dye.” Indeed. More than once, I, not one to hold back, yelled, “Oh, my God, just be honest already!”

At the book’s best, especially in the first 60 pages, even treadmill time melts away (my highest praise). Lizzie and James share solid banter. Lizzie is charmingly awkward, and Cara’s unexpected flirtatiousness is sheer joy. The tender moments as they fall in love? Yes, please. The sex scene I had to text to my girlfriend? Double yes, please.

Advertise with us

“Set” falters as Lizzie’s socioeconomic and personal insecurities overtake her internal life; the banter and humorous moments all but disappear. The story also suffers frustrating motivations that aren’t true to the characters (and are eventually abandoned).

The novel ultimately lands in the most disappointing category: a fine-to-good book whose potential is as clear as its detriments. The kind of book that, with a strong revision, could become good-to-great.

Even though Lizzie’s character-evolving revelation is just this side of unearned, it’s still pleasing that she got there. So, too, the quintessential happily ever after. I wanted Lizzie, Cara and James to have the ending they deserved; I just wish they had the whole book they deserved, too.

Amy Whipple is a part-time writer and part-time church secretary.