Fiction is one of our most basic and most misunderstood art forms. For most, the idea of lying out on a sandy beach or curled up on the couch at home with a good book sounds lovely. Yet, what makes a book “good?” Is it the substance, the ease with which readers can navigate the story or, possibly, the challenge of not just finishing a complex narrative, but taking deeper meaning away from it? “To Paradise,” the novel by Hanya Yanagihara, who is appearing at Carnegie Music Hall in Oakland on Monday, May 8th, is definitely one of the latter.
“To Paradise” is the 2022 follow-up to Ms. Yanagihara’s breakthrough 2015 novel “A Little Life,” which was a rave-reviewed bestseller, despite its dubious and, arguably, reckless message about suicide and depression. Instead of serving up a more palatable story for readers, Ms. Yanagihara seemingly sought to craft a difficult and nebulous tale that spans three centuries focused on a single townhouse in Washington Square, New York. And she succeeded.
“To Paradise” is three books in one. The first takes place in 1893, an alternate history where the Union won the “the War of Rebellion,” but the Confederate states seceded anyway. The second takes place in 1993 during the height of the AIDS epidemic in an America that seems indistinguishable from the world as it was. The third, the longest book-within-the-book, takes place in 2093 as America descended into an authoritarian hellscape after a series of pandemics. The characters in each section all share the same names, along with the same New York townhouse. It’s a choice any aspiring novelist would be chided for, as the names can cause readers more than a little confusion. In fact, the entirety of “To Paradise” seems designed to make it a “difficult” book.
While there is no shortage of trauma in “To Paradise,” it’s the world that bears the brunt of it, born from the feeling there are “more interesting” stories happening in Ms. Yanagihara’s world than the ones she shares with readers. Like everything in this novel, the choice feels deliberate. Ms. Yanagihara isn’t out to “frustrate” readers, but “To Paradise” is meant to challenge them.
At first glance, the ending of each book in “To Paradise” is a stone-cold bummer. The fate of characters readers got to know is left open, save for the fact that their pursuit of their own “paradise” proves fruitless. The world of 2093 is painted as the result of trying to achieve a kind of Star Trek-like utopia but ends up looking more like the Empire from that other “Star” feature film franchise. Where those stories offer simple answers to moral questions, “To Paradise” eschews any simplicity for a larger aspiration that stands in contrast to the message in “A Little Life”: nothing is ever completely hopeless.
Difficult as the novel may be, it’s not an unpleasant read. Ms. Yanagihara’s prose remains rich and lively as ever. Name confusion doesn’t last long, as each character is dynamic and alive on the page.
If readers do some of their own “work” to connect the dots the novel lays out, the resulting picture may surprise them. Perhaps that’s why the book is so named? Utopia is an admirable goal, but it’s the journey to paradise where anything worth reading about happens.
Joshua M. Patton is a father, veteran, and Senior Writer for Comic Book Resources and the author of the comics-inspired short story collection “Tales of Adventure & Fantasy — Book 1.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.