More books like “Vigilance” must be written so figures like William Still can claim their proper place in history. At their best, books about race — and, particularly, slavery — are necessary and enlightening. They counter forces bent on whitewashing this country’s checkered, bloody heritage.
Thanks are due Andrew K. Diemer, the Towson University assistant professor whose new book gives Still the prominence this entrepreneur of liberation deserves as an agent of social change from the 1840s to the start of the 20th century.
“VIGILANCE: THE LIFE OF WILLIAM STILL, FATHER OF THE UNDERGROUND RAILROAD”
By Andrew K. Diemer
Knopf ($30)
Diemer’s exhaustive biography is a salutary, challenging read. It tells of a free man born in 1821 to former slaves who, by dint of hard work and high self-regard, becomes a key mover in the Underground Railroad, a prominent businessman in Philadelphia and a political force. While not as well-known as Black icons Frederick Douglass and Harriet Tubman or the fiery white abolitionist John Brown, Still was highly effective on various levels.
Douglass helped fugitives escape to Canada; Tubman’s “almost superhuman courage” enabled her to travel “into the lion’s den to rescue friends and family”; and Still was a kind of bridge, a connector—and, as such, of lower profile.
“Still’s work, ordinary as it might sometimes seem, linked together these two and countless more like them, in a vast abolitionist web, aiding hundreds of desperate fugitives from slavery,” Diemer writes.
The book begins with the reunion of Still and Peter Freedman, his long-lost brother. How they found each other after slavery separated them from their parents and each other sets the stage for the rest of this singular story.
While its backbone is the life of one man, “Vigilance” is a history of Still’s times. Diemer contextualizes his subject’s endeavors with great depth, acumen and research. The notes, bibliography and index take up nearly 100 pages.
A man of impeccable work ethic and off-putting haughtiness, Still taught himself how to read and write, became a clerk, and by the 1850s, as chairman of the Philadelphia Vigilance Committee, was instrumental in abolitionism, then a new industry.
One of 18 children, he also was a devoted family man who, in his later years, gave several of his similarly industrious children work as agents for his autobiography. After the Civil War, he ventured into real estate and made a fortune in the coal business. He became a prominent, if controversial, member of Black Philadelphia society.
Diemer’s book teems with incidents, like one in 1848 that forced the slave couple Ellen and William Craft into elaborate disguise for their flight from the slave state of Georgia to the free territory of Philadelphia.
Ellen was “almost white,” William wrote, so she could pass for “an ailing planter,” traveling with her slave (William) to seek medical care. Ellen dressed as a man, put her right arm in a sling so she wouldn’t have to write in hotel registration books, and wrapped her face “as if she had a bad toothache in order to conceal her lack of a beard.” The Crafts made it.
The next year, Still helped Henry Brown, a free man separated from his slave family. Brown ended up shipping himself north as dry goods — in a box.
Diemer also provides insight into the political parties of the times, when, at least through Reconstruction, Republicans were more identified with abolitionism, Democrats more with slavery. Lincoln figures prominently in Still’s political considerations. Still was an independent thinker.
I like this book in retrospect more than I did while reading it. I wanted more color, more personality, and the details Diemer crammed into the narrative occasionally got in the way of the drama inherent to its material. Despite those caveats, “Vigilance” is an impressive, heartfelt work.
Carlo Wolff is a writer from Cleveland.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.