Western Civilization is the only culture in human history whose music has developed polyphony and harmony: the combination of two or more independent lines or melodies in a way that produces pleasant (or in some cases, unpleasant but desired) effects.

In all non-Western music, there may be more than one voice or instrument performing at the same time, but the additional performers will either be producing variants of the original melody, or a percussive rhythmic accompaniment to that melody. Western music has also developed the most complex and specific written notation among world cultures.

In “Musical Revolutions,” writer and pianist Stuart Isacoff sets out to describe “moments in music history when things dramatically changed” ... and “which forever altered Western culture.” He includes classical and jazz but admits he felt compelled to skip rock because “it deserves a more knowledgeable observer than myself.” He also completely ignores rap and hip-hop.

“MUSICAL REVOLUTIONS: HOW THE SOUNDS OF THE WESTERN WORLD CHANGED”

Advertise with us

By Stuart Isacoff

Knopf ($20)

In Isacoff’s narration, the earliest revolutionary moment is the invention of musical notation by an Italian monk in the 11th century. His most recent events are the inclusion of women in classical music – first as performers, then conductors and finally composers – and the assimilation of Western classical music by Asian countries.

The author is very selective and arbitrary. Chapters concentrate on the rise of polyphony in the Middle Ages, the seminal work of Johann Sebastian Bach and the Bach family, 19th-century virtuosity (embodied by composer-pianist Franz Liszt and the violinist Paganini), the “alchemy of sound” from the Impressionists to electronic music, noise and the use of silence as exemplified by John Cage. Of great significance too, is Schoenberg’s erasure of long-held distinctions between consonance and dissonance, arriving approximately at the same time as jazz and bebop, and the unexpected phenomenon of modern minimalism (which the author dubs “process music”).

It's inevitable that some significant aspects of music history get slighted in all this. Beethoven, whom Isacoff grants to be “the musical figure who comes most readily in mind when the term ‘revolutionary’ is uttered,” is oddly relegated to having been an outgrowth of J. S. Bach’s second surviving son, Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach.

Advertise with us

Mozart is given some status in the opera chapter, but Handel gets short shrift, and Wagner is mentioned only incidentally. The influence of Wagner’s tonal ambiguity in “Tristan and Isolde” on Schoenberg’s development of atonality and 12-tone technique is barely acknowledged. Wagner’s “Ring of the Nibelung” – arguably the single most revolutionary work in the classical repertory – is not discussed at all. On the other hand, the respected but relatively minor American composer Morton Feldman emerges, in the author’s purview, as a “musical icon.”

Jazz is given quite thorough treatment, with three succinct, informative chapters that seem to fire Isacoff’s imagination and inspire some of his best writing. The origins of jazz in the United States, its export to France via American soldiers in World War I, institutional racism and the advent of jazz in the musical mainstream are traced with lively lucidity.

Miles Davis – a genuine icon – is powerfully drawn: “His horn playing could shake the earth with sudden ferocious torrents of notes or break your heart with a simple, confessional lament.” Davis’ replacement of bebop with “cool jazz,” according to the author, “turned the jazz world upside down” with his 1959 album “Kind of Blue,” the best-selling jazz album of all time.

In sum, this book is a subjective, oversimplified history of Western music from a quirky point of view, aimed at the layman music lover, for whom most technical elements are reduced to their simplest denominator. This book won’t prepare you for a doctoral exam in musicology, but it should provide some fascinating anecdotes, along with entertaining hours that will send you to YouTube or the local library to sample some of the works Isacoff considers to be his most treasured musical landmarks.

Robert Croan is a former classical music writer and senior editor for the Post-Gazette.