In the two years since police murdered George Floyd, Americans have argued about policing a lot. Now a former Pittsburgh Police chief who was considered a reformer weighs in.

Robert W. McNeilly Jr.’s book “The Blue Continuum” is promisingly subtitled “A Police Chief’s Perspective on What’s Wrong with Policing Today and How to Fix It.” But while the book offers useful insights, it ignores key aspects of the current policing debate.

“THE BLUE CONTINUUM”

By Robert W. McNeilly, Jr.

Advertise with us

Word Association ($22)

McNeilly served as chief from 1996 to 2006. The book’s title references his personal taxonomy of six types of officers ranging from “sky blue” (hard-working, ethical, self-motivated) to “midnight blue,” a ”sinister 1-2 percent” who shouldn’t be on the force at all.

Most officers, he writes, fall between those extremes, including the 20% responsible for most disciplinary problems and citizen complaints. McNeilly’s advice boils down to: Have good policies, do good training and discipline cops who break the rules.

A section in which he summarizes the “good, bad and ugly” of his time as a lieutenant encapsulates his philosophy in his cut-and-dried prose style. The good resulted from conscientious, trained and experienced police supervisors laboring to ensure the department had responsible and effective policy, training, supervision and discipline. The bad was lack of or insufficient policy, training, supervision and discipline. The ugly was corrupt police officers and the department’s failure to take meaningful action to weed those officers out.

The book provides a catalog of reasons change is so difficult in police departments. Many are political: A well-intentioned chief, McNeilly writes, can only succeed if backed by a strong mayor. And even then, officers with political connections might get assignments they shouldn’t, or avoid discipline. McNeilly also lambastes police-union leaders he found unscrupulous, and obstacles to reform. (Like many reform chiefs, McNeilly was the target of a union no-confidence vote.)

Advertise with us

For much of his own early tenure as chief, the bureau operated under a U.S. Department of Justice consent decree – federal oversight that continued until the bureau reformed its policies and practices. McNeilly viewed the consent decree as an opportunity, and writes that his reforms – from computerizing the bureau and creating new training regimes to firing corrupt officers – had benefits that included steep declines in police-related lawsuits and legal payouts.

Such fixes are welcome. However, today, when critics clamor for fundamental changes in policing – especially as it pertains to the policing of Black and brown people – McNeilly’s proposals seem merely a blueprint for a tidier version of the policing we already have.

For instance, while he briefly limns the uproar over policing that followed Floyd’s murder, it’s only to note that departments nationally then began to pursue reforms like those the consent decree required here.

More notably, McNeilly fails to grapple with ideas like the now widely discussed suggestion that armed police aren’t the best way to handle things like minor traffic infractions and mental-health calls.

Moreover, while he several times references University of Pittsburgh law professor and law enforcement expert David A. Harris, McNeilly neglects to engage with key components of Harris’ work (illuminated in writings like his 2020 book “A City Divided”).

Advertise with us

There’s nothing in “Blue Continuum” about implicit bias – the baked-in racism that plagues police forces at least as much as it does society as a whole. There’s nothing about the decades of the militarization of police forces with training and equipment that can turn them into virtual occupying armies, nor about what Harris calls the “warrior mentality” into which police are trained and acculturated, which frames every encounter with a civilian as potentially deadly (though such deadly encounters are in fact very rare).

In other words, if the problems of policing go deeper than the cops who are overtime hogs that McNeilly describes, or who are merely lazy, or even deeply corrupt, the solutions must go deeper than better training and supervision.

To put it another way, if the behavior of armed officers, and their accountability for it, are as dependent as McNeilly says on the changeable policies of individual chiefs and mayors, is there not something wrong with the system as a whole?

If McNeilly has thoughts on these crucial matters, we don’t, unfortunately, learn them in “The Blue Continuum.”

Bill O’Driscoll is a Pittsburgh-based journalist and arts reporter for 90.5 WESA-FM.