“FREEDOM”
By Sebastian Junger
Simon & Schuster ($25.99)
Sebastian Junger explored the violence of nature in his late-90’s best-seller “A Perfect Storm.’’ More recently, as a war correspondent and documentary filmmaker, he’s examined the violence of man in such works as “War’’ and “Restrepo.’’
His latest book, “Freedom,’’ is a dissertation on one of mankind’s most cherished concepts, and the price humans pay in trading liberty for safety. “The inside joke about freedom … is that you’re always trading obedience to one thing for obedience to another,’’ Mr. Junger says. This is an observation that takes on greater significance with the book’s concluding revelation.
“Freedom’’ revisits a path Mr. Junger first trod in “The Last Patrol.’’ In that 2014 documentary, Mr. Junger and three cohorts – two combat veterans and a war photographer – try to ease back into American society by taking a 400-mile hike from Washington, D.C., to Western Pennsylvania. They venture to Philadelphia and then head west, ending their journey in Fayette County. The trek was broken into stages spread out over year.
Traipsing along railroad tracks and sleeping under overpasses provides a lot of time to think. It gave Mr. Junger and his friends ample opportunity to debate Big Questions like independence, community, duty and sacrifice.
“Freedom’’ is not so much a well-conceived philosophical thesis as a ramble through the brambles. It’s a free association of history, anthropology and sociology as Mr. Junger tries to braid frontier history, boxing strategy, primate behavior, Genghis Khan and the Irish Troubles into a coherent narrative. Mostly he succeeds; occasionally he stumbles. The end result is a provocative if disjointed rumination.
The best parts of the book, the spine of the story, are the vivid and often poetic descriptions of the Western Pennsylvania countryside and the natives Mr. Junger’s party encounters.
The story opens just north of Harrisburg, as Mr. Junger and his crew are about to enter what was once considered no-man’s land, the forests beyond the eastern face of the Allegheny Mountains.
“The Pennsylvania fields lay bare and hard in the cold by there were seams and folds in that country – strips of woods along stream bottom, windbreaks between the cornfields, ridges left for wild hunting – where a man could easily pass the night unnoticed,’’ Mr. Junger writes. “The water was ice cold and filtered through the chert and limestone of the country and tasted as though civilization was still something in the future.’’
A short time later he encounters a man with all of his worldly belongings lashed to the blade of a snow shovel that’s tied to his waist.
“Depending on your perspective,’’ Mr. Junger says, “he was either the freest man in the country or the poorest.’’
Mr. Junger notes that the early Western Pennsylvania settlers were among the freest people in the land of the free. White civilization literally ended at Kittatinny Mountain. The tradeoff for all the freedom-seekers forging westward was the risk of being captured by Indians and being skinned alive or carved into pieces and fed to dogs. But on the bright side: “No government official would ever again tell you what to do,’’ Mr. Junger writes.
A premise the writer advances several times is that nomads and mobile societies like Native American tribes enjoyed the greatest freedom. They also were the most warlike and the poorest.
If income distribution is an accurate barometer of personal freedom, then the United States ranks with the worst in the developed world, Mr. Junger says. Our Gini coefficient, a fairness measure developed by an Italian sociologist, is roughly equivalent to that of Ancient Rome.
Mr. Junger generally avoids taking sides in our ongoing political wars, though he does seem to betray a certain contempt for libertarians and armchair patriots.
“People love to believe they’re free, though, which is hard to achieve in a society that outsourced virtually all of the tasks needed for survival,’’ he writes. “Everyone—including people who vehemently oppose any form of federal government— depend on a sprawling supply chain that can only function with federal oversight, and most of them pay roughly one-third of their income in taxes for the right to participate in this system.
“For most of human history, freedom had to be at least suffered for, if not died for, and that raised its value to something almost sacred. In modern democracies, however, an ethos of public sacrifice is rarely needed because freedom and survival are more or less guaranteed.’’
It’s only while inspecting his battered, bloody feet on the banks of the Youghiogheny River in Connellville that Mr. Junger finally reveals an ulterior motive for this arduous journey: He is trying to escape a painful divorce.
“It was time to go home,’’ Mr. Junger says. “It was time to face my life.’’
Steve Halvonik is a former Post-Gazette reporter and editor who teaches professional writing at Washington and Jefferson College.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.