In many ways, William Evans and Omar Holman’s “Black Nerd Problems” is a testament to how far American popular culture has come with regard to both minority and niche communities.
“BLACK NERD PROBLEMS: ESSAYS”
By William Evans and Omar Holmon
Simon and Schuster ($27)
In 2021, we live in a world where a book can wholeheartedly embrace the intersection of blackness and nerdiness without disparaging either one. However, in many ways the book’s strength may be its greatest weakness as well. By attempting to make the text accessible to readers outside of the black nerd community, Evans and Holman are sadly sometimes forced to undercut the power of their own message.
“Black Nerd Problems” is unapologetically nerdy and unapologetically Black. The eclectic collection of essays — culled from the website of the same name — explores “nerd” topics ranging from popular film franchises including Avengers and Star Wars to video games like Super Mario Cart and Grand Theft Auto and their connection to the African American world. References to common nerd icons like “Game of Thrones,” Dragonball Z and the X-men are freely mixed with specifically black cultural references like “What’s Happening?,” Pusha T and Myra Monkhouse.
Read More
As a Black man myself, I appreciated the choice to not over explain the Black references. Doing so would have made them seem less culturally significant than their white counterparts. If a reader is unfamiliar with an allusion, they can either look it up, pick it up in context… or not! Holman and Evans clearly don’t really care. They won’t explain Batman either, and to assume Bruce Wayne is more important than Dwayne Wayne would be to privilege white popular culture over black, something they actively resist.
Similarly, the majority of the text is purposefully written in African American Vernacular English (AAVE), sometimes called Ebonics. For the most part Evans and Holman, both poets by training, do a masterful job of presenting this dialect as natural rather than forced. While some readers (particularly white ones) might at first be put off by the unfamiliar terminology, verbiage, phonetic spelling, the occasional usage of the n-word, and the quite liberal usage of the f-word, the slang is consistent enough that it typically feels quite organic. Like the choice to use black cultural references, the usage of AAVE goes a long way towards normalizing the Black experience as equal to the white “standard.”
The critiques of nerd and Black culture are used as allegories and touchstones to bring the readers into Evans and Holman’s takes on everything from fatherhood and family life, to the COVID-19 pandemic, to the murder of George Floyd, to the history of Henrietta Lacks. Each essay approaches its subject matter by relating it specifically to African American culture; comic books, TV shows and animated cartoons are connected to the authors’ real-life experiences with black history, cultural identity, politics, family and heritage, news and world events, systemic racism and even intracommunity prejudice and colorism.
However, the more serious topics are perhaps where the book sees some trouble. When addressing particular somber subjects — like the death of Breonna Taylor — Evans and Holman suspend the usage of AAVE and revert to Standard Written English (SWE) or White English. In effect, the authors code-switch, a process well-known to most Black Americans, when they feel that it is imperative that white readers understand their message. A missed reference to Myra Monkhouse is OK; a misunderstanding of Breonna Taylor is not. While this does lend gravitas to the subjects that Holman and Evan reserve SWE for, it has the unfortunate side-effect of trivializing the predominantly AAVE segments of the rest of the book. It can leave the impression that “if this were really important, it would have been written white.”
That said, overall, the collection is not only entertaining but thoughtful. It distinguishes itself by maintaining journalistic integrity while also illustrating that cultural criticism is not limited to the academic elite or even the pigmentally light. Evans and Holman did not invent the conversational style presented in “Black Nerd Problems.” These discussions have been happening in barbershops for as long as there has been hair and clippers. What they have done is packaged a selection of the pop cultural discourse the African-American community has always engaged in and made it accessible to all. The hope would be that outsiders will engage with it.
Christopher “Mav” Maverick is a scholar and adjunct instructor of composition, literature and culture studies. He is the host of the VoxPopcast podcast found at www.voxpopcast.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.