For decades, the Republican Party has sought to make it harder for U.S. citizens to vote, although it’s more accurate to say that the GOP wants to make it harder for certain kinds of citizens to vote. (To be fair, this was a project of the Democratic Party until well into the 20th century).
“UNTIL JUSTICE BE DONE”
By Kate Masur
W.W. Norton & Co. ($32)
Until the Civil Rights Acts of 1964, one’s access to the ballot depended in large part on the predilections and prejudices of local and state politicians. With that landmark law, the federal government asserted that it had the last word on the matter. But civil rights encompass much more than the franchise. For the entirety of its history, as two timely new books show, America’s changing concepts of civil rights and voting played out in the lives and on the bodies of one particular group of people: African Americans.
Kate Masur’s “Until Justice Be Done” looks at “America’s first civil rights movement,” or the antebellum struggle to secure rights of citizenship for Black Americans. Voting was secondary to freedom itself.
In most Southern states, as a matter of law all Black people were assumed to be enslaved: When taken into custody, they had to prove they were free. Such “proof,” though, often lay only in an easily lost, destroyed or stolen certificate. (One reason Southerners forbade Black literacy was the worry that they could forge documents.) Many free Black people found themselves sold back into slavery because they could not produce proof of their freedom.
“THE AGE OF ACRIMONY”
By Jon Grinspan
Bloomsbury Publishing ($30)
After the uprisings of Denmark Vesey and Nat Turner, slave states cracked down on sailors, the freest group of Black people. Black seamen arriving in Charleston had to be reported to the local sheriff, who could, and often did, put them in jail until their vessel left port. If their captain didn’t pick them up, they were sold into slavery. The “South Carolina Negro Seamen Act” served as a model for other states, but also, as Masur shows, inflamed Northern abolitionism.
At issue was the concept of “citizenship” nowhere defined in the Constitution. Was a Black mariner from New Bedford a citizen of Massachusetts, and if so did his freedom flow from that state’s protection? Or, when in South Carolina, did that state’s insistence that no “Negro” could be a citizen prevail? And did he have any rights derived from the U.S. Constitution?
Nor was it just the South. Many Northern states, from Indiana to Oregon, instituted “black codes” that prevented African Americans from voting, testifying, owning property or even residing in the state.
The 1857 Dred Scott decision briefly settled the matter, at least as far as the law went, ruling that African Americans “have no rights which the white man is bound to respect.” The 14th Amendment and Civil Rights Act of 1866, passed in the wake of the Civil War, attempted to ensure that all (male) citizens were treated equally under the law, but the 1873 Slaughterhouse decision reinstated the principle that “the most important privileges and immunities of citizenship remained under state, not federal, authority.” The new boss looked very much like the old boss.
Jon Grinspan’s “The Age of Acrimony” takes up the topic of voting where Masur leaves off. The 1870s, Grinspan shows, weren’t just the era in which Black Americans began to participate in elections. It was where America became far more “democratic” than it ever had before.
Quite simply, far more people began to vote in the late 19th-century, cresting with the 1876 Presidential election in which 82% of eligible voters turned out.
But as today’s Republicans would surely point out, more participation didn’t mean better participation. On Election Day parties, not the government, provided whiskey and color-coded ballots that almost automatically registered a straight party-line vote. Political machines turned uninformed voters out in massive numbers, and the “corrupt bargain” concluding the 1876 election, as well as social and racial unrest across the nation, proved to many elite writers that “America’s experiment in popular self-government had failed.”
The corrupt bargain also meant that the new Black vote in the South would be nullified or eliminated. A million Southern Black voters cast ballots in 1877. Just to take one state, changes in election laws and state constitutions (in addition to racial terrorism) over the next 20 years shrunk Black voter rolls in Mississippi from 147,000 in 1880 to 9,000 after 1890. And just like today, the vote suppressors piously pointed to the need to protect “election integrity.”
The Progressive reforms of the 1890s-1910s, Grinspan argues, regularized politics and put elections much more under government control. And they were cleaner. “Educational” flyers and pamphlets, not raucous rallies, became the dominant (if more impersonal) means for candidates to communicate. For the first time, ballots were actually secret, and those ballots prioritized individual candidates, not party slates.
The result? Turnout crashed, and by 1924 it was below 50%. “Together,” Grinspan concludes, “all the reforms built a new culture of efficient and individual voting, which discouraged voters just enough to get many to stay home.”
Turnout in the 2020 election was the highest in a century, partly due to a tribalized political environment resembling that of the 1880s. Donald Trump, with his rallies and appeal to the “low-information voter,” is a throwback to the politicians of that era. Yet his party, like the high-minded reformers of the late 19th century, is bent on limiting democracy, particularly for Black voters, as a survival strategy. Will it work? Masur and Grinspan’s books both suggest that it just might.
Greg Barnhisel is professor of English at Duquesne University.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.