“THE ONCE AND FUTURE WITCHES”

By Alix E. Harrow

Redhook ($28)

The Oxford Dictionary defines ‘supernatural’ as “…a manifestation or event attributed to some force beyond scientific understanding or the laws of nature.” As a culture, we are obsessed with the supernatural, whether it’s Doctor Strange, Harry Potter, Sookie Stackhouse, or any of the thousands of other manifestations we readily consume.

Advertise with us

Hugo Award-winning Author Alix E. Harrow has added to this ever-growing magical universe in her most recent novel, “The Once and Future Witches.” She tells the tale of three sisters, embittered and separated by an evil father, who reunite and attempt to create a better world for themselves and all womankind.

The year is 1893, complete with electricity and ragtime! Suffragists hold seemingly futile rallies; impoverished women toil in sweatshops; slavery is barely in the country’s rear-view mirror. The sisters – James Juniper, a wild maiden accused of murder, Agnes Amaranth, a pregnant mother-to-be who refuses to marry the child’s father, and Beatrice Belladonna, a librarian who conducts secret research into magical folktales and folkways, yearn for witchcraft-inspired power.

The novel inhabits a slightly altered universe. The Eastwood sisters (not to be confused with Updike’s Eastwick witches) find each other in New Salem, built near the ashes of the abandoned Old Salem, where witches burned one hundred years earlier. The Sisters Grimm, not the Brothers, collected old-world folktales which are really code for magic spells, if you know where and how to look. The suffragists are led by Susan Bee and Cady Stone. The sisters join up, seeking to gain control of their lives and circumstances through witchcraft, voting rights, or any other method at hand. The Eastwood sisters, like all women at that time, are nobodies. But they intend to become somebodies.

Along the way, there are adventures and magic. Good and evil are precariously poised against each other and nothing is ever quite as it appears to be.

Like many a fable, there are underlying themes and issues. The sisters can use their power simply for power’s sake, or to extract revenge, or to conquer an enemy. But is that good enough?

Advertise with us

Not according to Ms. Harrow, who intends for her witches “to restore the rights and powers of womankind." The Eastwood sisters represent every woman who wants what she can’t have. A woman doesn’t have to be born a witch or have special powers. She only needs to have a strong enough will – with this she can learn the words and the ways to empower herself and control her own destiny.

Some readers may be put off by this moralizing, while others may actively embrace it. Either way, once the point of self-actualization is made, reworking it every few chapters may be redundant.

“The Once and Future Witches” also has a pacing problem. Fables require a beginning, a middle and an end, usually in fairly short order. Hundreds of pages of middle, where the witches acquire power, fret about how to use it, lose power, get caught, escape, acquire more power… a reader could grow weary.

Despite these flaws, the novel is charming and well-written. Ms. Harrow has an ear for harmonious phrases. Country-born Juniper, in a city for the first time, yearns for the natural beauty she’s left behind. Scampering home from a late-night rendezvous, she detects a stillness to the air that reminds her of the mountainside just before dawn “in that silent second after the night-creatures have bedded down but before the morning-birds have started up.”

The author provides insightful descriptions. Bella delves into books about the Salem witch trials and how to turn lowly herbs into medicinal balms. No one pays her any attention. “If she were a scholar, she might refer to her notes as research, might imagine it typed and bound on a library shelf, discussed in university halls, but she isn’t and it won’t be.”

Advertise with us

There is sisterly rivalry and cheeky humor. Agnes interrupts her sister’s speech “on the grounds that it’s boring and no one cares.”

The first sentence of the book sets the tone: “There’s no such thing as witches, but there used to be.” Readers who enjoy a little morality mixed into a somewhat lengthy fable about magical powers lost and found should be entertained, if not entranced, by “The Once and Future Witches.

Susan Pearlstein is a Pittsburgh attorney who volunteers at the Carnegie Free Library of Swissvale.