In “Wayward,” the protagonist’s 16-year-old daughter, Ally, is an amateur etymologist who seeks to understand life through the historical derivation and meaning of words. If she was searching, she’d discover that one dictionary defines “wayward” as difficult to control or predict because of unusual or perverse behavior, while another dictionary states that “wayward” means doing only what you want and often changing your behavior in a way that is difficult to control or, similarly, following one's own capricious, wanton, or depraved inclinations.

“WAYWARD”

By Dana Spiotta

Knopf ($27)

Advertise with us

These related definitions of “wayward” also define the various women encountered, Ally included, in Dana Spiotta’s newest novel, “Wayward.” Ally’s grandma, Lily, is nearing the end of her life but resolutely, on her own terms. Ally’s mom, Sam, wrestles with the changes brought on by midlife angst and strives to meet the challenges encountered according to her own inner inclinations, not by following polite societal norms.

Teenage Ally is precariously embarking on womanhood even as her parents separate, initially certain that all paths forward that do not include her mother are the right choices. Even Clara Loomis, the author’s mostly fictional 19th-century suffragette, runs away from home at age 17 and joins a free-love, equality-for-all commune.

If only this novel focused more on these women and their struggles and less on the author’s mini-rants about everything from bodybuilding to modern home design trends. It often feels like there is a fifth woman in this novel, the author herself, sitting directly beside each character and filling what should be their personal space with discourses about midlife crises, the sexuality of teenagers, the architecture of Syracuse and other assorted topics.

The story itself revolves around Sam, fiftyish and going through “the change.” Sam is on a journey to discover her true self as she shakes off fertility, husband, family, employment and various other middle-class trappings. When Sam falls in love with an early 20th-century Arts and Crafts style house designed by the nonfictional, noted architect Ward Wellington Ward, she simultaneously realizes that she is no longer in love with her husband. She buys the house and moves in, abandoning her spouse and child.

Sam would be a more compelling character if the author had only let her alone. But instead, Sam, and to a lesser extent her daughter Ally and other more peripheral characters, are often used as mouthpieces for small lectures on such diverse topics as the shallow, myopic shortcomings of middle-aged bourgeoise women, the shortcomings of libertarianism, and the selfishness of enrolling children in prestigious colleges. While Sam and Ally gain some self-awareness and wisdom by the end of the novel, it’s clouded over by a litany of what feel suspiciously like authorial pet-peeves the reader has to wade through before reaching the conclusion.

Advertise with us

Sam mourns not living with her daughter but doesn’t waste much time trying to decipher what went wrong with the marriage. Husband Matt is barely heard from, and when he is, it’s often in the form of generously providing Sam with whatever she needs at the moment to get her over her next hurdle. Sam’s perversity and 3 a.m. soul searching doesn’t stop her from accepting these spousal demonstrations of kindness and caring even as she informs him that she doesn’t need him, want him and will not listen to any advice proffered. By the end of the novel, a reader could be left wondering if the marital problem is not so much sympathetic hubby as the wayward Sam herself.

Spiotta, a gifted author and a creative writing instructor at Syracuse University, has published several well-received novels, many of which were short-listed for, or the recipient of, various prestigious literature prizes. In “Wayward,” her literary prowess is sometimes on display. Both the teen and middle-age points of view  are often spot-on: Ally complains that everything parents tell you once you’re 13 is a lie; Sam misses the intimacy she and Ally once shared, “comforting her daughter while she could still be comforted before she grew up and they both become, well, uncomfortable.”

“Wayward” can also be read as a love-letter to the city of Syracuse. Whether it’s the detailed descriptions of early morning March snow, with its pink and gold glimmering promise of spring, the detailed relating of the town’s historical importance to both the abolitionist and suffragist movements, or the depictions of the non-fictional original Arts & Crafts homes and buildings scattered throughout the area, many now falling into disrepair, the author’s love for this town is evident.

But it’s not enough. Syracuse may be lovely, and the intertwined lives of the women may be interesting and even thought-provoking, but, ultimately, “Wayward” gets in its own way. More attention to the nuances of the characters inhabiting the novel and less diversionary pontifications, would have been welcomed.

Susan Pearlstein is a Pittsburgh attorney who volunteers at the Carnegie Free Library of Swissvale.