Robert Windhorst watched a daily barn raising as he drove by on Washington Pike in Collier,

Each day he passed on his way home from work, Amish carpenters had finished another step in reconstructing an early 1800s barn at Woodville, a historic estate built in 1774 on Chartiers Creek.

“Their speed was amazing. The first day I saw roof trusses. The next day they were covered with boards. By the fourth day, the roof was done,” said Windhorst, board vice president of Neville House Associates.

The nonprofit that maintains and operates this historic property is only its sixth owner. The first, John Neville and his son, Presley, may have also marveled at the speed with which barns, stables, chicken coops and even this house were built on the family’s 1,500-acre Chartiers Valley plantation.

Advertise with us

The wooden structures were primarily built while the Nevilles were away fighting in the American Revolution, John as a colonel, Presley as Lafayette’s aide de camp. And if Windhorst’s research is correct, the buildings were mostly the work of Black craftsmen who were the Presleys’ slaves.

The history buff from Ingram believes that about 80 of the 100 people who lived and worked at Woodville and Bower Hill, the larger farm on the other side of Chartiers Creek, were enslaved individuals. By 1790, John Neville owned the most slaves in Allegheny County, followed by his son, Presley, and son-in-law, Isaac Craig.

Windhorst knows the first names of some of those enslaved here and is sharing his research with students at the University of Pittsburgh. Understanding the history of Woodville and the people who lived here over the last 225 years “is what keeps me coming back,” said Windhorst, a volunteer for over 30 years.

It’s also what inspired past NHA president Robert Eckle and others to raise $300,000 to buy, disassemble, transport and put back together an 1810 barn owned by the Seranko family of Latrobe.

“It had been in the family for over 200 years. This wonderful architectural piece of history would have been torn down,” Windhorst said.

Advertise with us

In spring 2021, the barn was carefully dismantled, its pieces tagged and numbered, and transported to cleared land behind the Neville House, where its chestnut, oak and locust timbers became the spine of a 54- by 40-foot barn and a smaller log cabin.

Last summer, Woodville property manager Dan Ragaller worked with an Amish crew from Smicksburg, Pa., to build the barn and cabin using mostly hand tools.

“They worked from 7 a.m till 3 or 4 p.m every day. They did an incredible job,” Windhorst said.

Both structures were dedicated earlier this year and used for candle making and other demonstrations when Woodville opened for the season April 3. On May 7, a Mother’s Day Tea is scheduled from 2 to 4 p.m. in the house’s parlor. Reserve your ticket, $10, by Sunday evening at woodville-experience.org.

Susan W.H. Smith, the site’s director since February, says she learns something new about Woodville and its residents nearly every day. She’s amazed by connections with not only the Whiskey Rebellion of 1794 but also colonial Virginia, the Revolutionary War and early iron and steel production in Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

“When you start digging through its history, there are all these little spindles connected to everything,” said Smith, who has a master’s degree in anthropology.

Smith is still learning about the Presleys and the other families that owned Woodville, all connected by marriage, and the women who helped preserve its history. The Cowans, Wrenshalls and Faucets celebrated weddings in this historic house, and the 1786 nuptials of Abraham Kirkpatrick and Mary Ann Oldham, John Neville’s close friend and sister-in-law, respectively, was the first wedding covered in the Pittsburgh Gazette, a predecessor of the Post-Gazette.

Eight years later, Kirkpatrick was alongside John Neville when local farmers and distillers torched Bower Hill to protest a new federal tax on whiskey (Neville was the tax collector).

The flames of the Whiskey Rebellion did not reach Woodville, but they seared the Neville name and contributed to the family’s financial downfall.

Like most of America’s founding fathers, the Nevilles were Federalists who believed in business, big banks and a strong federal government. They lost favor and the 1800 presidential election to Thomas Jefferson’s Democratic-Republicans, but their principles carried the day.

Advertise with us

“Federalists lost the battle but won the war,” Windhorst said.

Tell that to the Nevilles.

John’s wife Winnie died three years after the Whiskey Rebellion and he moved to Pittsburgh, then to what is now known as Neville Island, where he died in 1803.

Presley and his wife Nancy lived in Pittsburgh and at Woodville, but he preferred land speculation to raising wheat, rye and livestock. He struggled to pay his debts and those of his father for the rest of his life.

Eliza Kirkpatrick – daughter of Abraham and Mary Ann – was Woodville’s next bride in 1810, when she wed Christopher Cowan, an Irish immigrant and early Pittsburgh iron baron who was among the first to give his employees a day off on the Fourth of July..

Advertise with us

Four years after the wedding, Cowan bought Woodville from a bank and retired to the life of a.gentleman farmer. The Nevilles, meanwhile, moved to Ohio, named a town after themselves and died in debt, Presley in 1818 and Nancy in 1839.

The Cowans’ eldest daughter, Mary Ann, was the next Woodville bride to become its owner. She married John Fletcher Wrenshall in the house in 1832 and moved in after her father – Lord Cowan to his neighbors – died in 1835.

Her husband, a businessman with an office in Downtown’s Burke Building, rented the land to farmers. After his death in 1862, Mary Ann and their son William farmed its nearly 2 acres.

William’s daughter, Mary Bennington Wrenshall, was the last Woodville bride to run the place. She married banker Joseph Fauset there in 1923 and carefully preserved the house and its history until her death in 1973. Pittsburgh History & Landmarks Foundation bought Woodville in 1976 and transferred the historic house and its nearly 2 acres to Neville House Associates in 2007.

“It’s a National Historic Landmark with so many more stories to tell,” Smith said.

Kevin Kirkland: kkirkland@post-gazette.com.