Henry Holt was a proficient violinist, an educated man and a nobleman who was born in the late 1700s at Woodville Plantation, home to the largest community of enslaved people west of the Allegheny Mountains prior to 1810.

He was a free Black man, according to an affidavit written and signed by Presley Neville, a Pittsburgh burgess at the time who, together with his father John, once owned more enslaved people than anyone in Western Pennsylvania.

“Presley writes that he was born of a family of free parents, and he himself is a free man entitled to all the privileges of any free man,” said Rob Windhorst, vice president of Neville Associates Inc. Presley Neville states that Holt carried himself with “honesty, regularity and temperance. He's a good waiter and a handy and useful servant.”

good research

Advertise with us

Though Holt’s name was nearly lost to history, new research is increasing understanding of Black life in the 18th and 19th centuries.

Holt’s story is part of a broader effort by historians like Windhorst to recover the names and lives of the enslaved people who built and sustained the estate.

Windhorst has accounted for about 80 people so far on the former 1,500-acre property. In 2020, he began uncovering more about the enslaved population, which was at least 10 times that of the white population of the property at the time.

Last month, Windhorst led a program about Woodville’s Black residents at the restored house and 2.5 acres in Collier. Juneteenth visitors received guided tours anchored in the stories of enslaved people who built and managed the property on a daily basis.

“This is a very vibrant, very large community, and it's a critical piece of African American History in Western Pennsylvania that up until now was lost,” he said. “So I'm very excited to be part of all this research and to be sort of pulling it all together.”

Advertise with us

In 1780, Pennsylvania passed the Gradual Abolition Act. This allowed for enslaved people like Jack Walls, born in March of that year at Woodville, to be free by age 28. People born earlier in that same year, however, would be enslaved for life. Any person born after Walls would eventually gain their freedom.

“Anybody that's born of enslaved parents after that, though, is still required to serve ... which is one of the reasons why slavery sort of hangs on in Pennsylvania until the 1840s. In Pennsylvania, it takes a little bit of time for the slavery to work itself out of the system,” Windhorst said.

This act provides an explanation for Henry Holt’s freedom. It is said that Holt’s mother was also part white, and he was considered a trusted servant — he worked in the dining room of the Woodville mansion. Holt would have worn red livery, a suit possibly worn with pride, but it also made him visible if he tried to escape, according to Windhorst.

It was in the late 1700s when John Neville bought his first two enslaved men, Harvey and Joe, in Virginia.

Harvey, Joe, Cato, Harry, Jesse, Lennon, Jack, James and Jacob were among nine men in their 20s who came to Woodville with John Neville. They were all registered to the property by 1782. The nine men built both the nearby Bower Hill house and the Woodville mansion. The door outside the mansion faces the original road between Washington, Pa. and Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

The mansion has been restored to what it looked like in the 18th century. The woodwork stands out for its detail and durability.

“This is all solid cherry,” Windhorst said. There was an abundance of cherry trees during that time, but the wood was painted to look like mahogany.

“They finished this house. That tells me one of them was an undertaker. An undertaker in the 18th century is a builder, somebody that builds houses. You've got a joiner, a carpenter. You've got somebody that was a blacksmith, a glazier and an exquisite painter,” Windhorst said.

“These guys are highly skilled builders and craftsmen. And as you look around this room, I think this is a great example and a tribute to them and their work.”

Though these men built the houses, they may not have stepped inside once they were finished. That was reserved for Holt, who served in the dining room, other servants and possibly Farltex, the cook, if she were delivering food.

Advertise with us

Farltex was also part of the original community of enslaved people. According to Windhorst, she was in her 20s.

Her small dwelling would have been above the kitchen at Bower Hill. She made all the meals that the Neville family ate. Her tools might have included a cast-iron skillet and a Dutch oven. She also had access to a small garden, which was used to raise herbs and Dominique chickens for eggs.

Though Farltex would have been considered property, she had some sovereignty over the kitchen. She worked in the kitchen and larder, a storage room, and did the laundry on Mondays, Windhorst said.

On Juneteenth, the tour began in the larder and moved to the kitchen. Farltex might have had to walk around to the front of the house to deliver food, Windhorst said.

Her work was constant, and her day most likely started around 6 a.m.. The family’s breakfast was at 8 a.m. and dinner was severed at 2:30 p.m. Later on, a light supper was usually served cold using leftovers, according to Windhorst.

Advertise with us

Erin Windhorst, Rob’s wife and a Woodville volunteer, recreated what enslaved people might have eaten during the tour.  Since there is not a documented account of meals for the enslaved people at Woodville, she leans on the expertise of writer and culinary historian Michael W. Twitty as well as personal narratives of enslaved people documented in the 1930s.

On this particular day, she prepared okra, black-eyed peas, duck, trout, tomatoes and a few fruits.

“I love 18th-century cooking, the recipes. Normally I would interpret recipes and food that the Nevilles were being served, which is really fun. Because with them being very wealthy, you get to cook all kinds of stuff,” Erin Windhorst said.

“I find this just as interesting, because the enslaved population from very early on, and as the generations go, adapted to their environments and things that were familiar they worked with and things that weren't familiar they learned,” she said.

What is also learned from Rob Windhorst’s analysis is that in 1794, the Bower Hill house burned down during the Whiskey Rebellion. Nine Black men fought alongside the Nevilles.

Advertise with us

Woodville’s enslaved population was emancipated before 1865, from Neville’s Island, according to Rob Windhorst. By the late 19th century, all enslaved people were emancipated.

“I think we've got a long way to go, but just being able to tell the preliminary story of these folks is important,” he said.