When a building receives a historic designation, the image that most often comes to mind is one of art deco or Victorian design, or perhaps even older.
Yet the site of the former Mellon National Bank on Penn Avenue in East Liberty, which was nominated for historic preservation earlier this year, breaks that mold: The building was completed just 52 years ago.
Built during the urban renewal effort in East Liberty, the building is an example of functionalist or new traditionalist design, according to Justin Greenawalt, president of the East Liberty Valley Historical Society. The most prominent — and unusual — feature of the building is the “sawtooth” elevation on its southwest side facing Centre Avenue.
“It’s got a lot of fantastic qualities to it,” Mr. Greenawalt said. “It has been difficult to convince people that something built in 1970 should be considered historic, but given its history and its unique design we strongly felt the building was worth historic designation.”
One of the entities that is not convinced is the owner’s representative, Citizens Bank, which is opposing the historic designation now before Pittsburgh City Council.
Councilman Bobby Wilson introduced the historic designation Tuesday. Mr. Wilson said that at this week’s council meeting, there will be a motion for the bill to be held for a public hearing.
Read More
Originally designed by Liff, Justh and Chetlin Architects and Engineers, the building was used as an office by Mellon National Bank up until 2001, when Citizens Bank acquired Mellon’s consumer banking operations.
Citizens closed the branch in early 2020, Mr. Greenawalt said, and the building has been vacant since.
While the building is owned by a limited liability company based in Arizona, Citizens has essentially been given license to make decisions on the future of the site, he said.
Mr. Greenawalt said that based on designs provided by the company during a community meeting last July, Citizens hopes to raze the building with the goal of building a new, smaller office in its place.
But in doing so, he said, it would be a disservice to the East Liberty community. The site is one of the few remaining architectural examples of the urban renewal era, when hundreds of homes and businesses in the neighborhood were leveled in the name of building new roads and high rise housing.
Despite the upheaval and pain that the urban renewal projects caused, Mr. Greenawalt said, the era is second only to the coming of railroads in terms of importance to East Liberty’s architectural history.
“History isn’t all sunshine and rainbows,” he said. “If we erase this site and just say it was indicative of the failure of urban renewal [in the mid-20th century], we’re effectively erasing 70 years of this neighborhood. We shouldn’t be selectively editing this city’s history just because it didn’t turn out the way we hoped.”
Mr. Greenawalt said Citizens has done little to include the community in its plans for the site. He said Citizens filed for a demolition permit for the building in early 2020 and that a July meeting was the only time the company publicly presented its designs.
Because the company has not appeared to take community recommendations into account in its designs for the building, Mr. Greenawalt described the public meeting as the company just “checking off a box.”
Citizens spokesperson Bennett Griesmer issued this response:
“Citizens is committed to serving its customers in Pittsburgh and throughout Western Pennsylvania. Citizens has been providing banking services to the East Liberty community for many years. We are thrilled to be a part of the community and are eager to resume banking services as soon as possible.
“During the many public hearings over the last year and during conversations with various community groups including Preservation Pittsburgh, we’ve explained that the current building is in poor condition and no longer fit for purpose. We have engaged with the community throughout this process and have revised our site plan based on direct feedback. We look forward to continuing this work with the city of Pittsburgh and local community groups to build a new space in this location to help us best serve the East Liberty community for many years to come.”
Mr. Greenawalt said that if any lesson from the urban renewal era should be retained, it’s that East Liberty residents should not allow people who do not live in the neighborhood to make decisions that will affect the community for decades to come.
“My ultimate point is that you have a faceless, land-owning company in Arizona and a corporate entity [i.e., Citizens Bank] based in Rhode Island making decisions on what East Liberty is going to look like for the next century,” he said.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.