Most old Pittsburgh banks are cathedrals of earning with massive columns and hushed, marble-lined interiors that lend a formal air to financial transactions.

Richard Beatty Mellon, the banker and industrialist, continued that approach when Mellon Bank opened its Downtown headquarters in 1924 on Smithfield Street. The gray granite structure, supported by interior marble columns, fit his mantra of “quality without showmanship.”

By 1965, Mellon Bank remained obsessed with quality but its architectural language had become modern.  Employees in its building supervision department teamed with architects, creating a unique collection of innovative neighborhood branches that featured tall windows, warmly decorated interiors flooded by natural light and, in some cases, glazed emerald-green brick exteriors — a subtle form of branding.

“Banking at mid-century had a different vibe. In the modern era, banking offered the possibility of transparency,” said Brittany Reilly, a member of  the Pittsburgh Modern Committee at Preservation Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

Ms. Reilly and her colleagues are researching local architecture between 1945 and 1979 so people can understand how Pittsburgh reinvented itself after World War II and the role Mellon Bank played in that transformation.

A former Mellon Bank branch at 6112 Penn Ave. in East Liberty was built in the 1960s in corporate modern style. When it was targeted for demolition, some called for it to be designated a historic landmark and preserved. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

An excellent example of its “corporate modern” style is the former Mellon Bank branch in East Liberty. Citizens Bank wants to demolish the vacant building — which is owned by Vereit, a real estate company based in Phoenix, Ariz.— and build a small branch and surface parking lot. On that same triangular plot bounded by Penn Avenue, Centre Avenue and Sheridan Square, a competing bank, Chase, plans to demolish a CVS at 6100 Penn Ave. to build a drive-through branch.

Earlier this year, the city’s historic review commission and planning commission approved the Pittsburgh Modern Committee’s request to designate the former Mellon Bank branch a historic landmark. Those rulings halted Citizens’ internal demolition work at 6112 Penn Ave.

City Council will decide the building’s fate. If Kai Gutschow had his way, it would remain standing.

“It has a beautiful patina to it. It sparkles. We should not be tearing down perfectly good buildings. We should be reusing, recycling, repurposing and, if necessary, remodeling. To build anything new is to make the climate worse,” said Mr. Gutschow, an associate professor who teaches architectural modernism at Carnegie Mellon University.

Advertise with us

Opened in 1970, the bank, “memorializes the era in which urban planners decided that they had to improve East Liberty by turning it into an island with a circle around it,” he said.

The building occupies a prime location.

“This is the entrance to East Liberty, or at least it was at one point. It’s seen by a lot of people. All those brand-new apartment centers across the street could use a day-care center or a nice bakery,” Mr. Gutschow said, suggesting other uses for the building.

Another option, he said, is making it a museum that shows urban planners’ disastrous attempt to revive East Liberty’s commercial district by making it a pedestrian mall isolated by a ring road called Penn Circle.  Urban renewal became “urban removal” of buildings and poor people, he said.

A Mellon Bank branch built around the same time as the East Liberty branch still stands in Squirrel Hill. It’s now a Citizens Bank. Another former Mellon Bank branch is slated to open in the heart of Lawrenceville in September. After renovations, it will have an Oliver’s Donuts, a ground-floor restaurant with the building’s original 12-foot-high ceilings and space for nine small businesses.

Advertise with us

Brian Mendelssohn of Botero Development said he renovated the interior but left much of the building’s signature architectural details intact, uncovering all of the 10 original windows.

“I had to see past the Citizens Bank aesthetic,” he said.

A vacant former Mellon Bank branch on upper Fifth Avenue in Uptown also has the signature glazed green brick that “allowed you to recognize it as a Mellon Bank branch without heavy signage,” Ms. Reilly said.

The drive-thru windows at a former Mellon Bank building at 1425 Fifth Ave. in Uptown. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Starting in 1950, Pittsburgh’s Downtown skyline began to change radically.

“If you begin at the Point, you won’t make it very far before you find yourself appreciating a montage of modern architecture,” Ms. Reilly said, citing the portal bridge as a frame for Gateway Center, a complex of 10 buildings built on 25 acres between 1950 and 1969.

Advertise with us

Justin Greenawalt, president of the East Liberty Valley Historical Society, said the former Mellon Bank branch in East Liberty meets the threshold for National Register of Historic Places status. “It is one of the few buildings from this era that remains intact. This building is 51 years old.”

The daring Squirrel Hill branch that Mellon Bank built, now a Citizens, is circular with barrel arches and topped by a continuously poured concrete dome.

“This period in architecture — we’re really pushing the envelope. Pittsburgh was trying to reinvent itself and slough off the smoky city moniker,” Mr. Greenawalt said.

In East Liberty, the Mellon Bank branch’s Penn Avenue facade employed classical architectural language in a new way with tall pillars of glazed green brick.

“The front of the building is perfectly symmetrical,” Mr. Greenawalt said. “It looks like an arcade with columns flanked by these book-ending piers. The architects designed this so that the Penn Avenue-facing facade was meant to be viewed on foot. You can walk past it. You can appreciate it.”

Advertise with us

By contrast, the building’s Centre Avenue side features a symmetrical sawtooth pattern that matches the street’s busy rhythm, allows for lots of natural light and, “shields the offices from automobile noise. That was the part of the building that held administrative offices,” he said.

Now a Citizens Bank, this branch at 1801 Murray Ave. in Squirrel Hill was built by Mellon Bank in 1965. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“If we are to demolish this building, we are effectively saying that the last 70 years in East Liberty don’t matter. But they do. They absolutely do. Demolishing something that has been there for 50 years is not being neighborly,” Mr. Greenawalt said.

Bennett Griesmer, a spokesman for Citizens Financial Group, said the bank’s representatives met with East Liberty groups last July to hear comments on its proposed design for the new bank branch and revised its plans.

“We have engaged with the community throughout this process and have revised our site plan based on direct feedback. We look forward to continuing this work with the city of Pittsburgh and local community groups to build a new space in this location to help us best serve the East Liberty community for many years to come,” Mr. Griesmer said.

Marylynne Pitz: mpitz@post-gazette.com or on Twitter:@mpitzpg 

Correction, June 27, 2021: An earlier version of this story gave an incorrect name for the owner of the former Mellon Bank branch in East Liberty. The owner of the property is Vereit, a real estate company based in Phoenix, Ariz. Citizens' Bank is a tenant of Vereit. The spelling of Brian Mendelssohn’s name has also been corrected.