The Carnegie Science Center opens its new, PPG Science Center Pavilion on the North Shore in June. This fall, the Carnegie International, a major contemporary art show, opens at Carnegie Museum of Art in Oakland. An exhibition featuring Andy Warhol’s early career in advertising starts this month at the North Shore museum devoted to his work.

To a visitor, all may appear to be running smoothly at Carnegie Museums. Behind the scenes, however, staff and trustees are managing turnover in key leadership positions. That’s because the Carnegie is searching for its fourth president in seven years.

Whoever leads the organization, which has a $55 million annual budget and 1,061 employees, will oversee an art museum, a natural history museum, a science center and and its satellite Highmark SportsWorks, The Andy Warhol Museum and the 2,200-acre Powder Mill Nature Reserve in Westmoreland County.

Jo Ellen Parker, who became president in August 2014, left on Feb. 2 with four months remaining on her contract. Her predecessor, David Hillenbrand, returned as interim president in January 2013 once John Wetenhall ended a 17-month stint in November 2012.

Advertise with us
Jo Ellen Parker (Bob Donaldson / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

In addition, Carnegie Museum of Art needs a new director. Last September, Lynn Zelevansky ended her eight-year tenure after she turned 70. Louise Lippincott, fine arts curator for 27 years, leaves July 1. Catherine Evans, the museum’s chief curator, and Sarah Minnaert, director of exhibitions, are leading the art museum.

The search for a new president comes while more than a dozen other major museums — including Fayette County’s Fallingwater and the Westmoreland Museum of American Art in Greensburg — are looking for new leaders. Simultaneously, the museum group seeks new funds to support an operation that one former director believes has expanded faster than its endowment has grown.

“I’m chagrined that an institution that I love appears to be in such turmoil,” said Bill DeWalt, who was director of Carnegie Museum of Natural History from 2001 to 2007.

The museum consortium, Mr. DeWalt said, “hasn’t had the kind of fundraising it needs to allow it to create new initiatives and be the kind of leader that it once was. There’s a pattern of really abrupt changes among the museum leaders and the president’s office.”

To help Ms. Parker, who came here after serving as president of Sweet Briar College, the board hired an executive coach whose goal was to strengthen the 10th president’s effectiveness. For 2016, Ms. Parker’s base salary, benefits and retirement compensation totaled $395,905, according to the IRS form the museums filed for that calendar year.

Advertise with us

Mr. DeWalt, former president of the Musical Instrument Museum in Phoenix, Ariz., believes the Carnegie’s current endowment of $346,129,000 is insufficient to support the cost of operating the consortium. The goal should be $500 million, he said.

“Every institution at the Carnegie is under financial pressure and they’ve got to step up the game. You’ve got an endowment that was sufficient for two museums and it’s not anywhere close to being sufficient for four,” Mr. DeWalt said.

Bill Hunt, board chairman since 2014, acknowledged the turnover. “We are disappointed in the shorter tenure on the presidents’ side,” he said, adding that trustees are reviewing the president’s role and responsibilities before hiring a new search firm.

Mr.  Hunt, however, emphasizes recent successes.

“We did raise the $43 million for the science center,” Mr. Hunt said, which covers enhanced STEM programming, the Science Pavilion, which opens June 16, and conversion of its Omnimax theater into the improved Rangos Giant Cinema.  He added that $2 million of that money will create an endowment for the new science center wing.

Advertise with us

The Carnegie Museums also has seen an increase in visitors.

“We had over a million visitors in the four museums last year,” Mr. Hunt said, noting that that is the highest number of visitors the four museums have recorded since 2007, the year the new Dinosaur Hall opened, which tripled the exhibit space of this popular area at the natural history museum.

An endowment’s ups and downs Carnegie Museums of Pittsburgh’s endowment 2006-17 In millions

Created with Highstock 6.0.7$276.5$276.5$306.6$306.6$205.3$205.3$257.2$257.2$279.9$279.9$263.3$263.3$289.8$289.8$320.6$320.6$318$318$297.7$297.7$305.9$305.9$346.1$346.1Endowment value200620082010201220142016$0$100$200$300$400Post-Gazette

*2017 is unaudited and preliminary as of March 14, 2018
Source: Carnegie Museums of Pittsburgh

Advertise with us

Rapid growth

When it was founded by Andrew Carnegie in 1895, the Oakland complex consisted of a fine art gallery, a natural history museum, a public library and music hall. The library remains physically connected to the Oakland complex but it has a separate director and funding sources.

The museum consortium, Mr. DeWalt said, “has never recovered from its addition of the Science Center and the Warhol in the 1990s that created ongoing structural and financial problems. Bringing it back will require a leader with an expansive, creative vision — and especially one who is able to articulate that vision in a way that attracts the resources necessary to again make it a world-class institution.”

Ms. Parker, the last president, set four goals: financial sustainability; diversity and inclusion; digital sophistication and collaboration.

A key financial goal is reducing a $1.2 million deficit at Carnegie Museum of Natural History. For the next several years, Mr. Hunt said, the museum plans to reduce that deficit at the rate of $200,000 each year. The plan is to eliminate it by 2020.

Advertise with us

Betsy Momich, a museums spokewoman, said that each year, Carnegie Museums draws 5.5 percent of a three-year rolling average market value of the nonprofit’s invested endowment, part of which is used to support the annual operating expenses of the four museums.

“This draw is based on industry standards for sound endowment management. Separate from this, roughly 40 percent of our endowment is used to meet the intent of the restrictions that the donors placed on those funds, which are separate from museum operations and support things like art acquisitions and specific program costs,” Ms. Momich said.

The natural history museum’s deficit is internally imposed and based on its annual operating expenses, Ms. Momich said. The cost of maintaining large collections and conducting scientific research while funding for that research has declined has affected the bottom lines of many natural history museums.

“But as a whole, Carnegie Museums has reflected a surplus for the last several years. And the Museum of Natural History is on plan to eliminate its operating deficit by 2020,” Ms. Momich added..

Among several sources, the Carnegie Museums receives funding from the Allegheny Regional Asset District, which distributes half of the money derived from a 1 percent county sales tax to support local libraries, parks and recreation, sports and civic facilities. Last year, the museums promised to be more transparent in its budgeting so that there will be “a better overall understanding of the financial pressures facing Carnegie Museums.”

Advertise with us

Last year, Carnegie Museums asked the RAD board for $3.3 million for operating expenses and $750,000 to replace all 168 windows at The Andy Warhol Museum, a Beaux-Arts style, seven-story structure built in 1911.

The RAD board gave the museums $3.2 million for its operating budget and awarded a $250,000 capital grant toward the Warhol windows.

Carnegie trustees are building a deferred maintenance fund and have raised $5.3 million in the past three years, Mr. Hunt said, adding that the board hopes to increase that fund to $10 million. He added that previous leaders had not set aside money to maintain museum buildings, which opened in 1895.

“The success of this effort is due in large part to our ability to achieve efficiency savings that we, in turn, are investing annually into this deferred maintenance fund,” Ms. Momich said. In one year, the four museums reduced energy usage by 21.5 percent and water consumption by 17 percent. The money saved goes into the deferred maintenance fund, she added.

Currently, the museums have two professional fundraisers, one a veteran and the other a newcomer. In a Feb. 6 email, Mr. Hunt announced that Dolly Ellenberg, longtime vice president for development, would take a new job rather than retiring, as planned, in March.

Advertise with us

“As part of our interim leadership planning, Dolly Ellenberg has agreed to postpone her retirement for a while longer and assist us during the CMP leadership transition period,” Mr. Hunt wrote.

Marcia Crawley, who is Ms. Ellenberg’s successor, joined the staff in January. She raised money for the Detroit Institute of Arts in Michigan before arriving here.

Regarding the overall endowment, David Donahoe, former executive director of RAD for 20 years, agrees with Mr. DeWalt.

“He’s right, in this sense,” said Mr. Donahoe, referring to the need for a larger endowment. “If you are unable to raise your admission or grow your contribution level, then you have to find an alternate source of revenue and that can be an endowment.”

Endowment earnings are important Mr. Donahoe said, because, “When the endowment average drops, the amount of money you can draw drops, too.”

Advertise with us

Competing for talent

For trustees, finding a new president is always a challenge but this year, competition for quality candidates will be fierce. At least a dozen museums are searching for new leaders, including four New York venues — the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the American Folk Art Museum, the Bronx Museum of the Arts and the Queens Museum.  Others are the Wexner Center for the Arts in Columbus, Ohio; the Walker Art Center in Minneapolis; the Kemper Museum of Contemporary Art in Kansas City, Mo.; the North Carolina Museum of Art; the Taos Art Museum in New Mexico; and the brand new $41 million Institute for Contemporary Art in Richmond, Va.

Kevin Hiles, executive vice president and chief operating officer, leads the transition team, which includes directors of The Andy Warhol Museum, the natural history museum and the Carnegie Science Center’s co-directors.

Mr. Hunt remains optimistic.

“This isn’t a search for a museum director; it’s a search for the president of a legendary institution that’s been part of the fabric of Pittsburgh for 120-plus years. Here, a president has the opportunity to work with four diverse, dynamic museums that are cultural anchors in the Pittsburgh community and leaders in their respective areas of museum study and focus,” he said.

Advertise with us

Marylynne Pitz at mpitz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1648 or on Twitter:@mpitzpg.

Correction made 5 p.m. April 8: David Donahoe was RAD’s executive director for 20 years. An earlier version of this story contained an incorrect figure.