Earlier this year, two qualified candidates turned down the opportunity to run Carnegie Museums of Pittsburgh, one of the city’s oldest and largest cultural organizations.
Both candidates, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette has learned, rejected the job, citing concerns with salary and museum governance.
Carnegie Museums of Pittsburgh trustees have the fiduciary responsibility to make decisions while board members at individual museums are advisory.
To find a president, trustees have hired a new executive search firm, KOYA Leadership Partners.
The president’s job has been vacant since February 2018. That’s when Jo Ellen Parker resigned after less than four years on the job. For 2016, Ms. Parker’s base salary, benefits and retirement compensation totaled $395,905, according to the IRS form the museum consortium filed.
Carnegie Museums of Pittsburgh operates an art and natural history museum, the Carnegie Science Center and its satellite Highmark SportsWorks, The Andy Warhol Museum and the 2,200-acre Powder Mill Nature Reserve in Westmoreland County. The museum consortium has an annual budget of $55 million and a little more than 1,000 employees.
William E. Hunt, head of a local real estate company who has chaired the trustee board since June 2014, emailed his comments about the failed search to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
He wrote:
“Some may be inclined to present this as a failure, but I don’t share that sentiment. So far, our search, which began last September, has produced two top candidates, both of whom are successful senior leaders who had not been looking for new opportunities at the time they were recruited by our search firm.
“Unfortunately, neither of these candidates proved to be the right match, although each had expressed enthusiasm for the position and the salary package. In one case it was a mutual decision. In the other, it came down to a very personal decision about where to live and the prospect of leaving an already rewarding leadership position.
“We’re disappointed but in no way discouraged. This is all part of the life cycle of a search: You field candidates and determine if there’s a match. In this case, there wasn’t. But we were really pleased with the response to the position and the quality of the candidates.”
Mr. Hunt also said the original search firm, Boyden Executive Search, which has a Pittsburgh office, was paid for its efforts.
In an email obtained by the Post-Gazette that Mr. Hunt sent to trustees on May 21, Mr. Hunt told trustees and the four museums’ board members why the search committee decided to hire KOYA Leadership Partners, which has offices in six U.S. cities.
“This mid-search change of lanes isn’t entirely unusual. Most executive search firms have their own unique networks that they tap for leads, so it’s often to a client’s benefit to work with more than one firm during the life cycle of a search,” Mr. Hunt wrote.
The search is “time intensive,” Mr. Hunt wrote, and “influenced heavily by the busy schedules of the kinds of senior leaders being recruited for this position. What’s more, many of the candidates may not have been actively looking for a new leadership opportunity before being approached by our search firm. That is precisely why senior management searches like this one can take up to a year or more to produce the right match.”
Besides finding a new president, trustees will eventually search for a new art museum director.
In September 2017, Lynn Zelevansky retired after eight years as art museum director. There were two attempts to hire an art museum director with the help of executive search firm Oppenheim Associates.
The first search for a new art museum director was suspended in April 2018, seven months after Ms. Zelevansky retired. The search resumed in July 2018 and produced a second group of candidates.The job was offered to a candidate, who rejected it partly out of salary concerns, the Post-Gazette has learned.
Eric Crosby, who is the Richard Armstrong Senior curator of modern and contemporary art, is serving as acting director of the art museum.
Additional leadership openings exist at Carnegie Science Center, where Jason C. Brown and Kim Amey are interim leaders. Another key position opened when Louise Lippincott, fine arts curator at the art museum, retired last July.
Marylynne PItz: mpitz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1648 or on Twitter:@mpitzpg






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.