In May, Christie’s will lead its marquee New York sales week with an auction of an Andy Warhol Marilyn silkscreen carrying an estimate in the region of $200 million.
If the 1964 work, “Shot Sage Blue Marilyn” sells for that amount, it will be the most expensive 20th century painting to ever sell at auction, according to Christie’s.
“This is one of the most iconic paintings of our time,” said Alex Rotter, the chairman of 20th and 21st century art at Christie’s. “It’s always been a coveted painting, and it’s always been an icon.”
He likened the work to the Mona Lisa, Botticelli’s “The Birth of Venus” and Picasso’s “Les Demoiselles d’Avignon.”
The silk-screen — striking for its bright blue eye shadow, yellow hair and red lips — is based on a promotional photo from the actress’s film “Niagara,” part of a Warhol series of “Shot Marilyn” portraits. (The series is so titled because, in 1964, a woman walked into Warhol’s Factory studio in New York City and with a pistol shot a hole through the stack of four Marilyn paintings.)
Warhol, the Pittsburgh-born pop artist, churned out about 8,000 paintings and sculptures between 1952 and his death in 1987. His images of celebrities have become staples of 20th-century art sales, averaging about 200 works a year. They’ve become a bellwether for the $11 billion-plus art market.
The artwork is being consigned by the Thomas and Doris Ammann Foundation in Zurich. Thomas was one of the most influential dealer/collectors of the 1980s, selling modern and Impressionist art to billionaires including Gianni Agnelli and Ronald Lauder. After he died of what was understood to be AIDS-related complications in 1993 at the age of 43 (his family officially listed the cause of death as cancer), his sister Doris took over the gallery and ran it until her death last year.
Proceeds from the sale will go, in their entirety, to the foundation, which is devoted to healthcare and educational programs for children.
Mr. Rotter said that the painting is not guaranteed, meaning that Christie’s didn’t commit to the work selling for a fixed price in advance of the sale; that means that if no buyers show up with a spare $200 million to spend, the work could go unsold.
“The foundation didn’t feel that a guarantee was necessary,” Mr. Rotter said, adding that there’s the possibility that between now and the May sale, a so-called third-party guarantor could step in and effectively agree to buy the painting for a minimum price before the auction. (In that situation, if the sale price is higher than the guaranteed price, the third-party guarantor would usually receive a cut of the proceeds.)
Given the precarity of the sale, and the fact that the Warhol market has periodically sagged during the past decade, the $200 million estimate could be a tall order.
But Mr. Rotter said that the price tag has precedent. He cited the reported (although not confirmed) $250 million sale of an orange Warhol from the same series to Citadel’s Ken Griffin in 2018, and said that “there have been private sales of Warhols over $100 million.”
The auction record for a Warhol is $104.5 million for his “Silver Car Crash (Double Disaster),” in 2013.
The $200 million estimate, Mr. Rotter said, “is based on market information that told me that this is roughly the price-setting expectation, but also it obviously has something to do with the consignor, who agreed to that base valuation.” On the one hand, Mr. Rotter said, “at auction you wish you could estimate everything at $1 to $2 and let everyone decide, but it’s not realistic.”
The Warhol in question is one of a coveted series of five paintings of Monroe, each on a different-colored background. One work from the series became a poster-child for tax avoidance schemes, when in 2008 the Chicago collector Stefan Edlis sold a turquoise Marilyn to hedge fund manager Steve Cohen for $80 million; Mr. Edlis avoided nearly $20 million in taxes by rolling the taxable proceeds of the sale into more art purchases.
This time around, Mr. Rotter speculated, bidders could primarily come from America and Asia. “It can go anywhere, but if you ask me now to make a guess, and I’d say America or Asia. Or the Middle East for that matter,” he said.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.