
Emma Santoro, 14, eagerly took the soccer field in early May, about two months after sustaining a concussion playing in a basketball tournament.
It had been her fifth concussion. But after following a different, more active treatment regimen than before — one that had included rest, dark rooms and no reading or schoolwork — Emma was back to doing what she loves more quickly than in the past.
She credits her quick return to contact sports to the UPMC Concussion Program and clinical neuropsychologist Michael “Micky” Collins’s approach, which differed significantly from the traditional protocol she had previously followed.
Emma’s mother, Ashely Santoro, recalled Collins saying that, if Emma was willing to put in the work, “He could get her back [to sports] safely.”
His treatment included targeted physical therapy, medication and behavioral changes, such as exercise, proper diet, no naps during the day and being around crowds and loud noise. For Emma, it made all the difference.
“I’m still a bundle of nerves watching her, but she does seem stronger,” her mom said.
The UPMC Sports Medicine Concussion Program was the first of its kind when it was established 25 years ago, and it continues to be a pioneer in concussion treatment and research. The hospital system estimates that up to 4 million concussions occur in the U.S. — more than 1 million of which affect children and adolescents.
The program is led by Collins, who was there for its founding in 2000, and Anthony Kontos, who joined the program in 2010. Both received their doctorates from Michigan State University and worked on research studies together during their time there.
Collins credits the late Freddie Fu, the world-renowned orthopedic surgeon and sports medicine pioneer, for his vision of having a concussion program in every orthopaedic and sports medicine department, and for bringing him to Pittsburgh to lead UPMC’s.

In 1999, the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) had published Collins’s paper on the relationship between concussions and neuropsychological performance of student athletes. The study provided foundational evidence that baseline neuropsychological testing is critical for accurately tracking cognitive deficits and managing sports-related concussions. The paper challenged older guidelines that relied solely on visible markers, such as loss of consciousness.
Fu would say, Collins recalled, “We look at sports injuries of knees as having different treatment protocols. Why not concussions?” Collins recalled.
One of the early goals of the program was to manage concussions like any other sports injury. When Collins arrived in Pittsburgh, there were only vague guidelines to determine if a patient had a concussion. There was no objective way to measure their level of confusion or other symptoms. “We weren’t far away from, ‘How many fingers am I holding up?’’’
Together with neuropsychologist Mark Lovell — a coauthor on Collins’ 1999 paper — and neurosurgeon Joseph Maroon, Collins developed a computerized neurocognitive testing tool, ImPACT (Immediate Post-Concussion Assessment and Cognitive Testing), to evaluate the impact of concussions.
Individuals are given a baseline assessment of verbal and visual memory, processing speed, reaction time, attention/concentration and symptoms (headache, dizziness, etc.), which is compared to another assessment after a suspected concussion. The difference in the assessments helps determine a treatment plan, and when it’s safe to return to the sport.
According to Collins, the Steelers were the first NFL team to do baseline testing, and Pittsburgh was the first city to do baseline testing for high school and college athletes.
One of Collins’ earliest challenges was the usual treatment for concussions: rest. “The more we rested patients, the worse the outcomes were,” he said.
Fu had long advocated an active approach to orthopaedic injuries, through physical therapy and exercise. With his mentor’s support, Collins began pushing for similar treatment for concussions. Instead of resting in a dark room, he urged his patients to get up early, exercise, read and work on a computer. All these activities were designed to reset the inner-ear vestibular system that helps to regulate balance. Soon, Collins began to see improvement and concluded that more aggressive treatment led to better outcomes.
The arrival of Kontos in 2010 coincided with the foundation of the Concussion Research Lab, which is dedicated to the study, assessment and treatment of mild traumatic brain injuries and sports-related concussions.
Its research over years has been funded by some $55 million in grants, resulting in more than 500 peer-reviewed papers that have been cited more than 20,000 times in articles.
While many know that playing contact sports, suffering previous concussions and a lack of safety equipment can increase the risk of a concussion, the Concussion Lab’s research showed that personal and biological factors can also play a part. Gender, age, anxiety or depression, susceptibility to motion sickness, learning disabilities and ADHD all can increase susceptibility to concussions and lengthen recovery time.
Kontos and Collins’s research has shown there are different types of concussions: anxiety/mood, cognitive, vestibular, post-traumatic headache/migraine, ocular and cervical. Each calls for a slightly different treatment regimen.
Rarely does a person have only one type of concussion, Kontos said. He explained that, in the early 2000s, assessment focused primarily on symptoms, cognitive impairment and balance. After 2010, there was a shift toward vestibular and ocular systems. “The profile model allows us to differentiate the type of concussion and attack it with treatment,” Kontos said.
Depending on the type of concussion, treatment may include exercise, behavioral management, regular sleep without naps, vestibular exercises and medication for anxiety, he said.
Behavioral management is now the foundation of treatment for any concussion, Kontos said. “The research has shown that behavioral management has had a very positive effect on patients’ recovery. We didn’t expect it to be that strong,” he said. Treatment starts with good sleep, a balanced diet and physical exertion. From there, medical professionals can add targeted treatment.
Collins and Kontos believe there remains much to be learned about concussions. “We want to match what we learn from science to what’s working clinically for the patient,” Kontos said. “Everything from what treatment is working, how often, how intense and does it impact progress.”

Since Collins arrived at UPMC 26 years ago, he has seen the number of patients, who come from around the world, in the Concussion Program grow to 18,000-20,000 a year.
“I’m very proud of what we’ve been able to do,” Collins said. “If you bring me a concussion, I can get the person back to the things they love to do.”
Currently, Collins and Kontos are looking at concussions as they relate to geriatric patients and also women’s health. “Our older people do better than some of our athletes,” Collins said.
One such case was a mother and daughter, Carol Cardone, 80, and Dawn Lewis, 61, who were involved in a rear-end vehicle collision. Neither knew they had a concussion and each contacted Collins separately, at the recommendation of their chiropractor. Both were treated at UPMC and released in less than two months of treatment. Cardone was released after two weeks.
In the future, they are looking to measure differences in blood and saliva in an attempt to connect biological changes in blood flow in the brain to symptoms. “We’ve used evidence to drive a clinical approach to patients by challenging paradigms out there, like rest and quiet, and we will continue to do so,” Kontos said.
“Concussion is a treatable injury,” Collins said. “If you treat it, you can mitigate problems down the road. If you get an injury, get evaluated by a specialist so that you can get the right treatment. It’s never been safer to play sports or to even have a concussion, because of the advances.”
The six different types of concussions
Concussions are not simple, static categories but rather clinical types grouped by symptom clusters. Here are the six clinical types of concussions, per UPMC Sports Medicine.
Vestibular: Inner ear based. Causes balance issues, vertigo, dizziness and trouble with motor or spatial orientation
Ocular-motor: Affects eye tracking, teaming and focus, leading to blurred vision, double vision or eye strain
Post-traumatic migraine: Involves severe headaches, nausea and intense sensitivity to light or noise
Cognitive: Relates to brain fog, slowed processing speed, memory difficulties and trouble concentrating
Anxiety-mood: Involves emotional shifts like irritability, sadness, nervousness, or feeling overwhelmed
Cervical: Relates to neck pain or whiplash symptoms from the impact mimic or worsen concussion signs
Abby Kirkland (abbykirkland77@gmail.com) is a freelance writer living in Mt. Lebanon.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.