
Concussions are indiscriminate, impacting athletes and non-athletes alike — and each requiring their own individualized rehabilitation plans.
Emma Santoro
Emma Santoro, 14, was playing her third basketball game of a tournament in Monroeville in March. She went up for a layup, was fouled and came down on her head. She lay on the court motionless.
Her mother, Ashley Santoro, was sitting in the stands watching. “I thought, ‘Oh my God, not again,’” she said.
It was Emma’s fifth concussion in several years; the previous one had been just eight weeks earlier.
“But this one was different,” her mom recalled.
Emma, now a freshman at Woodland Hills High School in Churchill, was unconscious for at least a minute. Someone called for an ambulance.
After regaining consciousness, Emma’s eyes began to roll back in her head, and she appeared to be having a seizure. She was transported to UPMC Children’s Hospital in Lawrenceville, where she was examined by a doctor and given a CT scan. The scan did not show trauma to the brain, so the teen athlete was discharged with orders to follow up with a concussion doctor.
The next day, she called the doctor who had treated Emma’s previous concussions and was told Emma should follow the same protocol — dark room, relax, no phone and take supplements.
“This is her fifth concussion and they are getting worse,” Santoro wondered. “Do I tell her she can’t play sports anymore?”
After a week, Emma was still not feeling well. She called UPMC and made an appointment with Michael “Micky” Collins, clinical director of the UPMC Sports Medicine Concussion Program.
Emma had never had a baseline cognitive screening for a concussion, so that was something Collins immediately ordered.
“He found things that were correlated to concussions that blew me away,” Santoro said.
For instance, Emma had complained of digestive and GI issues for the last year — issues, Collins explained, that can often be related to concussions.
“He looked at Emma and said, ‘How important are sports to you?’”
Emma replied, “They are everything.”
Collins told her that it wouldn’t be easy, but if she followed his instructions exactly, she could safely return to the basketball court.
“That’s what a mother wants to hear,” Santoro said.
Collins started by giving Emma “homework”: be in loud environments, go to dances, wake up early and work out before school, attend classes as usual and return to practice — but avoiding contact drills. And: “No naps!”
In addition, Collins prescribed physical therapy four times a week, to work on vestibular issues, including balance and dizziness. Emma also was sent to a psychiatrist, who prescribed short-term antidepressants that would help in resetting her nervous system.
A month later, Emma retook a cognitive test, and the results were startling. After six weeks, she was released from physical therapy and, by early May, she was playing soccer.
“This time I felt like I was reborn,” Emma said. “I felt different. It taught me that hard work and determination can get you anywhere.”
Her mother gets choked up when she talks about Collins.
“The hope and tough love he gave Emma was amazing,” she said. “In between the years of concussions, she was tired, unmotivated and disorganized. He rode her butt, but he got her back. He told us that Emma’s therapy needed to be uncomfortable, not intolerable.”
At Woodland Hills, Emma plans to continue playing soccer and basketball. Her soccer coach said she looks like a different player, with better balance and more focus.
Collins had said that he couldn’t prevent Emma from being injured again, but he could make her stronger. And that’s fine with her mother, who is now committed to spreading the word that there is new treatment for people with concussions — and her daughter is proof that it works.
Dawn Lewis and Carole Cardone
Dawn Lewis, 61, of South Park was riding in a car with her mother, Carol Cardone, 80, when their vehicle was rear-ended in a multi-car wreck.
Cardone, also a South Park resident, was driving, and said her head hit the steering wheel. She was treated at the scene, while Lewis was transported to the hospital with head trauma and whiplash, where she was treated and released.
Shortly after, Cardone went to see her chiropractor to see if he could help with the residual effects of the accident. It was there while treating her that the chiropractor told her that he thought she should be evaluated for a concussion. He recommended that she get an appointment with Mickey Collins at the UPMC Sports Medicine Concussion Program, who diagnosed her with a vestibular concussion.
“I never thought I had a concussion,” Cardone said. “But looking back, I was off balance, I had headaches, but what was really strange is that I was having trouble sleeping, which I never do. He said trouble sleeping is a symptom of a concussion.”
Collins prescribed exertion therapy for Cardone, and she worked with a physical therapist for about two weeks. She walked forward and backward and did step ups on a bench. All the exercises were designed to “reset” her vestibular system.
“At first I had to hold onto the railing when I was stepping up, but soon I didn’t,” Cardone said.
As with Emma, Collins gave her exercises to do at home, and instructions to get up one hour earlier than usual and walk for 45 minutes.
By the second week, Cardone noticed a big improvement in her ability to do the exercises.
“My balance was better, and I wasn’t lightheaded,” she said, noting that she was released after two weeks of therapy.
“Our older people often do better than our younger people,” Collins said. “Those who are between 60 and 80 get better faster than those between 40 and 60.”
Since being discharged, Cardone has been feeling great.
“It’s a good thing we went to Dr. Collins, because it could have been so much worse. He really helped me.”
Dawn Lewis did not see Collins until a month after the accident. Her neck was extremely painful, she had shoulder pain from where the seatbelt had held her in place, endured bad headaches and found herself getting annoyed with people around her.
“It was hard for me to be in crowds, and sometimes just two people talking would make me crazy,” Lewis said.
Her chiropractor recommended that she get evaluated for a concussion, so she too made an appointment with Collins.
“I honestly thought I was going to walk out of there fine, but that wasn’t the case.”
Collins recommended physical therapy, similar to what Cardone was prescribed.
“He told me to watch TV, read, get up early, be active — all the things that aren’t what you typically expect when you have a concussion,” Lewis said.
Unlike her mother, Lewis didn’t start to feel better until about six weeks later.
“I found myself wondering if I’d ever improve, but once I started improving, things moved quickly,” she said.
In mid-August, Lewis was released from treatment. She still has neck pain and is being treated by her chiropractor, but her headaches are gone.
She wants others to know this: “If you’re in an accident, fall and hit your head, get yourself checked out. You don’t know what will happen if you let it go.”
Abby Kirkland (abbykirkland77@gmail.com) is a freelance writer living in Mt. Lebanon.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.