As a cardiologist, Henrietta Afari has seen it repeatedly: female patients arriving at the emergency department with nausea, fatigue, shortness of breath or sudden weakness, instead of chest pain. Often, before hospitalization, these patients don’t realize they are in the middle of a cardiac event.

It underscores the need for women to receive cardiac care tailored to every life stage.

“Heart disease is a leading cause of death in women, yet it is very under-recognized, undertreated and understudied,” said Afari, a doctor at UPMC Magee-Womens Heart Program and Mercy Heart and Vascular Institute. “Part of the reason why this becomes especially important is because there are some nuanced changes — or differences — in the way heart disease can sometimes manifest in women compared to men.”

Despite that risk, only 44% of women consider heart disease their greatest health threat, even though about 45% of women ages 20 and older live with some form of cardiovascular disease, according to the American Heart Association. Those gaps contribute to worse outcomes across a woman’s lifespan, as cardiovascular risk, symptoms and treatment needs change from early adulthood and pregnancy through midlife and menopause — highlighting the importance of customizing care for women at every stage of life.

Advertise with us

A growing concern

For decades, women were largely excluded from the cardiac research used to develop diagnostic and treatment guidelines, said Katie Berlacher, a cardiologist at the UPMC Magee-Womens Heart Program. According to the AHA, heart disease in women was not meaningfully studied until the mid-1980s.

“For years, [women] were excluded because of menstrual cycles, hormone irregularities, pregnancy or possible pregnancy,” said Berlacher. “It really has just been the past 15 to 20 years that we've slowly seen the National Institute of Health mandate to include women — and research really trying to include women.”

The consequences of that delay are still unfolding. Between 1995 and 2014, the annual rate of heart attack hospitalizations increased among women ages 35-54, while it declined among men in the same age group, per the AHA.

Henrietta Afari is a cardiologist at Magee-Womens Heart Program and Mercy Heart and Vascular Institute. (Courtesy UPMC)

Outcomes are also worse for women. Afari said across conditions such as coronary artery disease, stroke and heart failure, women tend to fare more poorly than men. One AHA study found that women are more than twice as likely as men to die after a heart attack.

Afari said that these statistics emphasize the need for clinicians to pay closer attention to cardiovascular symptoms in women.

Advertise with us

“When women present with heart disease, we know from our understanding that they present at least a decade later than men, which has to do with delayed recognition and referral,” said Afari. “When they do present, they tend to have more medical conditions by the time they're diagnosed.”

Presentation differences

Afari said that women who are experiencing a cardiac event often feel symptoms in slightly different ways than men.

A study published in Circulation in 2003 found that approximately 30% of female participants reported chest discomfort, which is considered a hallmark symptom in men. About 60% of women experienced shortness of breath; 55% experienced weakness and 43% fatigue. In addition to heart attacks, Alfari said that there are “heart attack syndromes” — spontaneous coronary artery dissection and microvascular dysfunction — that are more commonly seen in women.

In SCAD, an immediate tear or disruption occurs in the inner lining of the blood vessels that feed the heart. The average age of presentation is late 30s to mid-40s, with 90% of patients women, often with hormonal risk factors. Alfari said SCAD can look like a heart attack — and if clinicians and patients are unaware, it can be dismissed.

MVD — often harder to diagnose — involves decreased blood flow to the heart through tiny vessels that current technology cannot detect. Additionally, these conditions are often mistaken for minor issues because women may not have typical cardiovascular risk factors such as diabetes, high cholesterol or smoking.

Advertise with us

“When you have a woman in her 30s presenting with chest pain who doesn't have any of those risk factors, the pretest probability that this is a heart attack is low. It's based on how we're taught in medical school,” said Afari. “However, we do know that not only is our world changing and our risk profiles changing, but also there are unique risk profiles that can occur in women that can make it such that a 30-year-old woman who does not have any other traditional risk factors can still present with a heart attack.”

Changing cardiac needs

Cardiac care needs change across pregnancy and early adulthood, midlife and menopause, said Berlacher, who also noted this is an ongoing area of research.

During pregnancy, conditions such as gestational hypertension and preeclampsia — marked by high blood pressure — and gestational diabetes increase cardiovascular risk. About 50% of women who have hypertensive disorders of pregnancy develop chronic hypertension within the first few years after pregnancy, further increasing their risk for heart disease later in life, Berlacher said.

And decreasing estrogen during menopause affects heart health as well, said Belechar. Estrogen improves vascular health by relaxing blood vessels and maintaining favorable cholesterol levels.

“Estrogen helps in a favorable standpoint for your cholesterol,” said Berlacher. “When you have estrogen, you have higher good cholesterol — or your high density lipoprotein (HDL) — and you tend to have slightly lower low density lipoprotein (LDL), which is your bad cholesterol.”

Advertise with us

When estrogen levels drop, LDL increases and HDL decreases, along with a decline in vascular health. Other menopausal symptoms can also affect heart health, Berlacher said.

“Menopausal symptoms are very hard for many patients to tolerate — fatigue, sleep deprivation, hot night sweats and all of the vasomotor symptoms can lead to changes in heart rate and blood pressure that are unfavorable to cardiovascular health.”

Menopause can also affect the behaviors an individual may do to help her cardiovascular health, such as exercise, Berlacher said.

“If you're sleep-deprived and constantly having hot flashes — oftentimes in the middle of day or the evening — you're much less likely to want to exercise, which is really beneficial for you from a cardiovascular standpoint.”

Assessing and personalizing care

From remote blood pressure monitoring to multidisciplinary care conferences, Berlacher and Afari pointed to programs designed to adapt to women’s biology and lived experiences rather than a one-size-fits-all approach.

Advertise with us

“When I meet a woman in my clinic and ask about cardiovascular risk, I go all the way back to puberty,” said Afari. “We know conditions like polycystic ovary syndrome and endometriosis can have an impact on cardiovascular risk, even into adulthood.”

Afari said she also asks about pregnancy-related factors, autoimmune diseases, infertility or fertility treatments and psychosocial stressors, such as caregiver burden, mental health and trauma — all of which can affect risk assessment.

Berlacher said customizing care means considering life stages — from menarche to preconception, pregnancy, postpartum, menopause and beyond.

For high-risk pregnancies, UPMC hosts large multidisciplinary case conferences involving obstetrics, cardiology, neurology and other specialities. Flexible care also extends beyond the clinic. The postpartum hypertension program at UPMC Magee-Womens Hospital offers remote blood pressure monitoring for women with high blood pressure in pregnancy. Patients submit readings from home, and clinicians intervene if numbers rise.

“I'm really proud of the individualized medicine that we provide for women specifically here in our program, because we have many experts who are trained not only in women's health but also in the kind of specifics of cardiovascular disease in women,” said Berlacher.

Advertise with us

“It’s connecting the dots across the decades instead of just treating each phase in isolation, because truly, they’re all connected,” Afari said.

Ava Dzurenda (ava.dzurenda@gmail.com) is a science writer and exercise physiologist based in White Oak.