The score was tied and the stage was set when West Virginia quarterback JT Daniels took the snap.

The first Backyard Brawl since 2011 had lived up to the hype and its name. After 57 minutes of big hits and back-and-forth momentum swings, Daniels appeared poised to make his WVU debut a memorable one.

As he scanned the field with just under three minutes remaining and a chance to lead the Mountaineers to the go-ahead score, Daniels found his favorite target, receiver Bryce Ford-Wheaton, on a stop route near midfield. Already, that tandem had connected for a pair of touchdown passes.

But this time? The perfect spiral deflected off Ford-Wheaton’s hands — and right to Pitt defensive back M.J. Devonshire. He returned it 56 yards for the game-winning touchdown as Pitt downed the Mountaineers 38-31.

Advertise with us

“If I throw Bryce a thousand stop routes, that might happen once,” Daniels said. “It’s unlucky. It’s a fluke thing that happened. To me, it’s like, next play. Let’s go out and score.”

Daniels put the ball almost exactly where he wanted, and instead of a first down to inch the Mountaineers closer to the winner, he watched the opposing defensive back race into the end zone. Yet, showing a measure of poise, he shrugged off the stunning turn of events.

“After the play, I said, ‘Who cares?” Daniels said. “It makes the story cooler.”

While Daniels fell one completion short of that comeback narrative (more on that later), the sequence and the response in some ways allowed Daniels to reintroduce himself to a new fan base.

See, Daniels’ college football career arc has largely mirrored the way Thursday unfolded, as a promising prospect who hasn’t gotten many breaks continued to roll with the punches.

Advertise with us

Five years, three universities and one ACL injury ago, Daniels was considered a can’t-miss, five-star standout who virtually every recruiting service deemed one of the top players in the country. He doubled his high school courseload in order to graduate from Santa Ana, Calif.’s Mater Dei High School in just three years. Then, after reclassifying into the 2018 recruiting class, Daniels joined USC a year earlier than anticipated and won the starting job almost instantly.

His path to the NFL appeared to be on the fast track, as he became just the second USC true freshman to earn the starting gig.

But after a 5-7 rookie campaign with a mix of growing pains and promise, the hits started coming. The second quarter of his second college season, Daniels tore his ACL. That set off a wave of changes.

He transferred to Georgia, led the Bulldogs to the Peach Bowl, lost the starting job (in part due to another injury) and then re-entered the transfer portal.

He walked into the Pitt-WVU rivalry game as a fifth-year junior on his third team. With two years of eligibility remaining, he is now a college football nomad looking for QB1 status and a fresh start.

Advertise with us

In his first game as a Mountaineer, Daniels posted a solid — but not necessarily spectacular — stat line. He completed 23 of 39 passes for 214 yards and two touchdowns to go along with a 1-yard rushing TD. The chemistry he showed earlier in the game with Ford-Wheaton and the fortitude to step up in the pocket behind a shaky offensive line was something to build on.

“Here's the thing I love about JT: He's got an even keel,” WVU coach Neal Brown said. “The moment wasn't too big for him. He competed. ... I was proud of him. I thought he stood in the pocket and delivered the ball.”

While the first 57 minutes were relatively promising, the final gasp and his post-game comments may have been the biggest reasons for optimism. Faced with 75 yards to go and a seven-point deficit, the quarterback led the Mountaineers within the fringe of the red zone. Then, on a desperation 4th-and-16, his pass came within inches of connecting with Reese Smith.

It’s the first time Daniels lost a game as a starter since Nov. 23, 2018.

Asked what he hopes WVU fans learned about him, Daniels responded: “I'm going to give it everything I've got, no matter what it is. No matter what the situation is.

Advertise with us

“I’m really [expletive] proud of this team, to be honest with you,” he continued. “Of all the things you can fix on a week-to-week basis, execution is one of them. Culture and a team of fighters? You can’t fix that. This team can fight. There’s a lot I’m very optimistic about.”

Depending how you want to look at it, the same can be said of Daniels.

Mike DeFabo: mdefabo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @MikeDeFabo