Let’s never do this Backyard Brawl thing again. I mean, why would we want this kind of fun in a college football game?
Why would anyone want a week’s worth of hype both nationally and locally, followed by an entire day of activity and energy on the North Shore, finished by a record-breaking crowd at Acrisure Stadium?
A game filled with six lead changes, multiple game-changing big plays, a blocked punt, a pick-6, targeting calls, lots of big hits, a big drive to tie the game, a defensive stand to end the game and a stadium as loud as it has been on any Sunday and fuller than it has ever been.
This game had it all — including a semicontroversial play at the goal line on West Virginia’s last gasp effort at the end of the game — so, yeah, let’s not do this for another decade because it just doesn’t live up to the hype.
That is probably the best part of it all, actually, because as impossible as it seems, the renewal of the Backyard Brawl actually lived up to — and may have exceeded — all of that hype leading up to the game.
Quite often, we get pumped up only to get let down by these big games, but this one delivered and gave everyone who bought ticket their money’s worth. It was especially sweet for the Pitt fans in attendance, as they seem to be getting comfortable with this newfound penchant for winning big games.
Read More
Pitt won the game 38-31, but the difference in the game was a ball that bounced off the hands of West Virginia receiver Bryce Ford-Wheaton’s hands and into the hands of M.J. Devonshire.
The play, which came with less than 3 minutes left in a tied game, should have put WVU at Pitt’s 45 with a 1st-and-10, but instead, Devonshire caught the deflection and returned it all the way for a touchdown.
But hey, why not take another decade before we play this game again? Honestly, having had to be without the Backyard Brawl for a decade, we all forgot just how much fun and how special this rivalry is and can be.
And sitting among the 70,622 in attendance watching it, I was also reminded just how idiotic it is that this series was stopped in the first place. These two teams need each other. They need this rivalry, and their fans deserve this rivalry, as it brings out the best in all involved.
I mean, I get it. Those Pitt-Georgia Tech and Pitt-Wake Forest games are as thrilling as those West Virginia-Kansas and West Virginia-Texas Tech games. Must-see TV, but with all due respect, they aren’t anywhere close to these Pitt-West Virginia games.
As for the actual game Thursday, the Mountaineers clearly didn’t buy any of the pregame stuff about how much of an underdog they were. The Mountaineers came out fast and aggressive on both sides of the ball and dominated most of the first quarter and finally cashed in on a 10-yard touchdown by Ford-Wheaton.
This game was billed as a battle between two former USC quarterbacks, as both Pitt’s Kedon Slovis and West Virginia’s JT Daniels played for the Trojans before transferring. Slovis came straight to Pitt. Daniels made a stop at Georgia in between USC and West Virginia. Both put on a show in their own way Thursday.
Daniels, especially, was impressive, as he made big throw after throw despite being under some duress most of the night. The hostile environment didn’t get to him, and neither did the Panthers’ defense, as he completed 23 of 40 passes for 214 yards and 2 touchdowns.
Slovis was in a really tough spot because he is the unfortunate guy who is stepping into the shoes of one of the best quarterbacks in Pitt history.
Kenny Pickett took Pitt to heights last season the Panthers hadn’t been to in at least 40 years. He became a legend by leading the Panthers to an ACC championship. He finished third in the Heisman race, and just in case that wasn’t enough, he was the first-round pick of the Steelers.
Pickett was the ultimate leader, the emotional heart and soul of the Panthers, and he had that flair for the dramatic and clutch play at the most important times of games.
I couldn’t help thinking at several points in Thursday’s game that while Slovis may be a more polished passer, he doesn’t have Pickett’s “it” factor, and the Panthers will suffer as a result.
Of course, just as I thought these things, Slovis took the Panthers right down the field on a seven-play, 92-yard touchdown drive to tie the game at 31-31 with 3:41 to play.
The thing that is abundantly clear after Thursday’s game about both quarterbacks is, much like the game, they are worthy of the hype. West Virginia had a lot of questions facing them coming into the season, but Daniels answered many of them Thursday night.
Daniels is tough. He can make all the passes, and he will give the Mountaineers a chance to win every week. He was victimized by a dropped pass that became a pick-6, but that interception was 100% on the receiver and not at all his fault.
Slovis was shaky early, but he was big time when the Panthers needed him to be, and that — clutch play and leadership when it matters — was one thing Panthers fans feared they wouldn’t be able to replace once Pickett graduated.
Thursday’s Backyard Brawl delivered and delivered in a big way. That can be rare at times these days, but quite frankly, it isn’t rare in this rivalry, as these games far more often than not deliver the goods.
This was a perfect reminder why this needs to be an annual event until the end of time.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @paulzeise



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.