Gerry Dulac: OK kids, we're going to start our chat in just a few minutes so get ready....

Gerry Dulac: All right, here we go....

Bill In LA: The Steelers are now officially the Triple A team of the Dallas Cowboys! How come the Dallas Cowboys can accommodate great young Steelers players and the Steelers can't? Gerry, don't tell me Joey Porter did it to himself, like Kenny Picket and George Pickens! The problem is clearly the Steelers front office, they threw Kenny Pickett under the bus, couldn’t handle Pickens being annoying, and didn't budget for Porter. New general manager please!

Gerry Dulac: OK, then I won't tell you Bill. Can you get by with $27+ million annually?

Advertise with us

Bill In LA: I liked your idea last week to write a book. Why not make it all about your weekly chats? If you call it, “Bill In LA and Me”, I'll make it into a movie!

Gerry Dulac: Hahaha. Well, I know you have the Hollywood connections

Marty: Did Porter stop by Lourdes on his way to Dallas?

Gerry Dulac: They had massage chairs on the flight to Dallas

RJ: Gerry, the play in the Cleveland game that went over Everette’s head for a long gainer has been described as a blunder by the PGH media. It was more a blunder by the safety, who has to rotate to the deepest receiver in a given area. In that, God awful single high they were in on that play that is the Safeties responsibility. It’s obvious the communication aspect in the secondary leaves ALOT to be desired. Your take.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: It wasn't Everette's fault, it was the fault of another young player. But that's going to happen early in the season, especially with young players, especially with a new system that, obviously, isn't sitting well with some veteran players

greg in lewisville, texas: Gerry, So JPJ said he was "disrespected" as a Steeler. Say what??? By his 52 teammates or by Coach Mc and his staff. Then this "guaranteed money" situation. What ever happened to the American work ethic "A days pay for a days work". And in real working world there is pay for performance. Nothing guaranteed for anyone. Every raise and bonus money is tied to your results. Gerry, could you explain in depth what exactly how this works in the sports world. Thank you.

Gerry Dulac: Greg, sorry I can't explain in depth because I don't have the time or space here. Yeah, he was disrespected alright. Shame on the Steelers for offering him $27+ million annually. Such disrespect for a player who's never been to the Pro Bowl, is highly penalized and has just three interceptions in three years. They should be ashamed of themselves.

Bill In LA: Gerry, the best thing about George Pickens and Joey Porter, besides being world class NFL players, was they gave the Steelers a PERSONALITY! All we hear on gameday from the announcers is what a great time McCarthy and Rogers had about 20 years ago. Snoozer! Play Drew Allar now!

Gerry Dulac: Personality? And world-class? I'm pretty certain I asked you this a couple weeks ago, but I'll adapt it a little -- what color are the clouds in your world??

Advertise with us

Martian: GM Gerry. Looking towards the future, draft needs now seem to include QB, DL, OL, DB, ILB, and probably WR.... so almost every position group. How do they prioritize going forward since theres needs all over the place?

Gerry Dulac: My man, it hurts my head to think that far ahead. But I've had enough of the OL and QB is always a possibility, but only if they can get high enough. The others? Flip a coin between CB and DL. Or anything else

Ted Lasso: Gerry, how can the Steelers really improve their blocking and tackling when practices are glorified walk throughs?

Gerry Dulac: That's exactly right.

Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: the Steelers are taking a lot of criticism from fans and media for not signing Porter. Are these critics missing the fundamental irony? How can a team give a lot of guaranteed money to a player whose character is such that he will fake an injury? The fake injury loophole is one of the biggest risks a franchise takes when it guarantees money. Now maybe Porter will win and some desperate owner will overlook this irony and give him what he wants, but AJR II didn't and Jerry Jones isn't rushing to do it.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Pay the man!

Let’s go Mountaineers: Gerry.. why would JPJ pass up 28 million per year with 42 million guaranteed cash in hand today to play out his rookie deal and potentially get franchised tagged? Even if after all that he gets a big deal, he won’t make up all the money he lost playing 2026 on a rookie contract? Please make it make sense

Gerry Dulac: Am I allowed to pay two guys in a row??

Herky Jerky: Is this receiver group any better than last year’s?

Gerry Dulac: I don't think I need to answer that.

Advertise with us

chuck Mac: So let me get this straight...JPJ quit on us and faked injury not to play - then goes to Dallas without a new deal - now he feels "respected" - and everyone in the burgh is Missing? Him ???

Gerry Dulac: So many astute observations this morning! I'm glad some people are paying attention!!

HOF City: Hi Gerry, I believe both sides are at fault with the JPJ saga. We have out tens of millions to Herbig, Washington. So far, Hebig has been a big disappointment. I also believe JPJ was half way out the door when Tomlin left. Him quitting on his teammates is pathetic. As far as JPJ Sr, good riddance.

Gerry Dulac: Add another to a growing list..!

Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: A lot of player friendly media members often say: "why should a player honor a contract when the owners don't?" I would be almost certain that NFL contracts stipulate that a player has to make the roster to earn a future salary. That is certainly spelled out so when a team cuts a player before his deal expires they are in fact following the contract. When the Steelers cut Joey Porter Sr and didn't pay out the last year of his deal, like it or not, they were legally within their explicit rights to do so. When Porter Jr was faking an injury, he was not. Am I wrong for thinking of it this way?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: The Steelers paid JPJ for three games while he was out with his "injury." And when a player gets cut, oh well, that's what happens. You don't get paid for that year's salary, though I will point up they probably have already banked a whole bunch of money with signing bonuses and such, depending on the player

Silent Bob: Hi Gerry - Is there any way you can explain how the best draft pick by far from 2023 is gone – and 3 other picks from the same draft – backups who have made between zero and marginal contributions this year – are now under huge, multi-year contracts? I don’t like how JPJ handled this at all but seems like Kahn got this complete backwards.

Gerry Dulac: I wouldn't call Benton, Washington and Herbig marginal backups, any more than I would call Porter the "best draft pick by far" from 2023.

Eric in TX: Does the Steelers front office view the JPJ situation/result as a mistake or failure? I have a hard time seeing this being how they wanted it to play out. I would love to hear, with hindsight, how they would have done things differently and what that would be.

Gerry Dulac: They view it as terribly unfortunate, that a player they like, both personally and professionally, would resort to such tactics and not accept a deal that would've made him the seventh highest-paid CB in the league, when he's lucky if he's a top 10 CB.

Advertise with us

Josh: Good morning Gerry! I understand not giving up a ton of information for competitive advantage, but is there a reason why McCarthy doesn’t give a rundown on injuries after a game or in his Monday press conference? If reporters don’t ask, he doesn’t divulge anything.

Gerry Dulac: He does it differently than Tomlin, like a lot of things. I don't think he's being protective or sneaky, any more than Tomlin was always vague about a player's injury and rarely gave an update we see from other coaches. If we ask, he says...to some extent

Tim: The highest honor in football that Joey Porter Sr will ever receive was when the Steelers put him in their hall of honor. Key word honor. He tore that apart with his usual loud mouth and antics that we remember all too well. Act with class, Joey. Perfect fit for the Porters to go to the look at me Cowboys. Good luck in Jerry world.

Gerry Dulac: What he said.

Chris Frye: Final thought on JOJ’s “business decision”. He was offered $28M/year in August with $28M per year (not guaranteed year 2+) for likely 3 more years. He went to Dallas and is not getting an extension, same as here. Next year, Dallas likely cannot pay both JPJ and Pickens so they likely try to sign Pickens long term if they can, and franchise Porter at likely something less than $28M. This time next year, assuming 10% RoR for simplicity, Porter could have had approximately $30M minus approximately $5M, or $25M in hand - he sacrificed $25M in year one and may not exceed the $28M/year until year 3 of a theoretical new contract. Assuming in either scenario he plays the same, it is difficult to see how he ever makes up the lost $25M. The Steelers made a business decision, Porter made a bad financial decision.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: You have the numbers a little wrong. It was slightly more than $27 million annually and his salary this year was $3.9 million, but still he is walking away without about $23 million this year. And you never recover lost money. But your final comment was spot on.

Josh: Understandably the GM of teams are not required to talk during the season, but why couldn’t Khan come out and speak on the JPJ situation instead of having his new head coach get peppered with questions, especially after the trade went through?

Gerry Dulac: They are not required to not talk, they just choose to do so. Hey, that's part of being a highly paid head coach. He can handle it

Pittfan: Hi Gerry. Every year I hope for a Steelers losing season so that they can restock through the draft. Yet I find myself happy about a win and upset with a loss. Will it take a losing season for the Steelers to add better talent or can they do it other ways?

Gerry Dulac: I don't know what you are going to do if they have a losing season for the first time in 24 years. I really don't think you are going to root for that, judging from your reactions post-win or loss

Advertise with us

B. Sure: My theory on JPJ is that his entire privileged life he's been told he's the best athlete by coaches jock sniffing his dad, who, along with Tomlin, used to scream at opposing high school players for some reason. His athletic prowess was unchallenged until it came time for a 2nd NFL contract. For the 1st time in his life he was told he was NOT the very best and he and his daddy could not handle the truth. Over some delusional hurt feelings he was willing to burn it down and JPsr has divorced his own legacy because he, too, was insulted. JPJ could have been a legend and feel good story for a hometown son of a steelers legend but foolish pride won out.

Gerry Dulac: I agree with some of what you said, but not the part about becoming a Steelers "legend." Greene, Bradshaw, Franco, Lambert, Blount, Ham, Swann, Webster, Polamalu, Woodson. They are Steelers legends.

Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: did you see the video of Queen's "effort" (if you can call it that) on a couple of the Browns big runs? When McCarthy was talking about cleaning up the house was he referring to things like this? Do the Cowboys need an ILB who can't/won't tackle?

Gerry Dulac: When McCarthy used that expression, he was talking about things such as tackling, penalties, execution -- the little things that derail drives and lose games. He wasn't referring to anything specific because there were a lot of items in that "house."

mrbill1031: Gerry I noticed that your NFL Weekly Picks have moved from Sunday morning back to Thursday morning last week. Will this continue as i need all the help I can get in my pick em league and my picks have to be in by 3:00 on Thursday afternoon. Thanks!

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: That happened because the Steelers were playing on Thursday night. I assume they will go back to Sunday. Not my decision.

Tim: Secondly, other than Rod Woodson, a nfl hall of famer, name one Steeler who left the Steelers and had success. Joey Jr will never be confused w Rod, nor will he ever be fitted for a gold jacket.

Gerry Dulac: Alan Faneca for a year with the Jets. Otherwise, you are correct

TinySteelerFan: Hi Gerry! Has Tomlin leaving exposed something inherently outdated in their organizational process? Drafting has not been good enough to field an elite team. Their negotiation strategy has been exposed again with the JPJr situation. Was Tomlin covering a lot of cracks, that the transition to a new coach is now exposing?

Gerry Dulac: That's a good thought, but I don't think it's correct. And there is nothing wrong with their negotiating strategy. It's usually because there is something wrong with the player and the agent giving him advice.

Advertise with us

BeaverFallsKid: Hello Gerry. Change management like moving from HCMT to HCMM can be difficult. That being said, for the secondary and the offensive line in particular, with both groups having terrible communication problems, I am wondering if too many Steelers players simply lack the ability to learn the playbook adequately? "Communication problems" is a nice way of saying one or more players on any given play did not understand the assignment. Intellectual firepower can often make up for inadequate athletic ability but athletic ability rarely makes up for lack of understanding. In recent years, are the Steelers acquiring players with the football IQ they need to succeed?

Gerry Dulac: I'm glad to see some people understand the true meaning behind "communication problems." And that's one of the things McCarthy is big on -- the intelligent/mental part of the game. That's what he stressed in training camp more than physicality.

Wiscoken: A lot of discussion around how the Steeler front office mismanaged the JPJ situation. If their position was that JPJ was not a top 5 CB, but more in the 10 - 15 range, did they really mismanage, or is this simply one where there was a difference of opinion in value? The Steelers may prove to have under-estimated his value, but seems many are jumping to a conclusion that they are the ones that mismanaged this... in my mind, it's too early to make that call.

Gerry Dulac: Yes. JPJ and his agent over-valued his worth, to the tune of turning down $27+ million. And please don't anyone tell me about guaranteed money. If Porter accepts $27+ million, the Steelers aren't going to cut him one year later, which means he effectively is guaranteed two years to the tune of $54+ million. So let's say they wanted a three-year guarantee. Would you guarantee him $81+ million?? For a guy who's never been to a Pro Bowl, is highly penalized and has just three picks (notice how I keep emphasizing that)? I've said this before -- I like Joey, the Steelers like Joey. He's a really good player. But, c'mon. Was it a good business decision to give TJ Watt his monster deal with more than $100 million guaranteed? Maybe not. But he's T.J. Watt. He at least earned it/deserved it. Does anyone really think the Steelers should have just thrown everything away for JPJ when what they offered was beyond fair??

Gary: is the nfl reconsidering the Paris game

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: No, why?

Franco: If the steelers won the game against Cleveland, everyone would be talking how good the comeback was. They are 2-2. The sky is not falling.

Gerry Dulac: Thank you

Ryan: Gerry what do you think about the play of Robert Spears Jennings and Jaylen Warren vs Cleveland i think they both looked good and i think spears Jennings should get some more playing time this week

Gerry Dulac: Yes they did and yes he will

Advertise with us

SMP: It is my understanding that teams are required to keep more cash on hand for guaranteed money. Do you think this is the reason Steelers continue to only guarantee first year new contracts. If so, it appears bad habit or indication of being cheap. What do you think is the reason.

Gerry Dulac: Look at all the recent signings -- Boswell, Herbig, Washington and Benton -- and tell me if that makes them look cheap?

Nick: In the end - the steelers drafted 2 great talents, but traded them away for what feels like low value and are back to square one on those positions. Dunking on owner/GM isnt helpful- neither is blaming this all on player greed. Do you believe leadership is self aware and courageous enough to make the necessary changes to people/process/culture to improve?

Gerry Dulac: I would be careful who you are calling "great," and, in case you're not paying attention, I think that's exactly what they displayed in making those decisions to get rid of those "great" players. That is leadership, the tough, difficult kind. It's not let's give everyone a trophy

Martian: Regarding JPJ - If I heard correctly, he had the same agent that several other players "faked" injuries for to get new contracts. Do GMs refuse to draft/sign/do business with players based on their agents? If not, might be time to

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I'm sure some do...and should.

Peter: Is a potential trade of Alex Highsmith on the table if the Steelers stumble through October? If not, how about March?

Gerry Dulac: I doubt the Steelers are going to keep three highly-paid OLBs next season. But that is the plan this season.

The Truth: What ever happened to moving guys like Watt and Highsmith this year? Watt has been stapled to the same side every snap. It would be nice to try to confuse the opposing offense a bit no?

Gerry Dulac: It sure sounded good to those who believed it would happen. It might have even sounded good to Watt at the time. They do it from time to time, but you haven't noticed because it hasn't made a difference

The Truth: why do the Steelers generally not guarantee money after the first year in their contracts? It reeks of nothing but cheapness from Art

Gerry Dulac: It's the way they do business and it has worked to their advantage, in case you haven't checked all their success. Name the last "star" player they let go because they didn't want to pay him?? You can't

SteelersGuy: Morning Gerry! Are we in danger of having the bottom fall out of the team over the next few years? They don't seem to have enough solid young players to build around, and certainly no franchise QB. If they keep drafting in the middle to late first round, can they get one? Big Ben pick was after a losing season after all.

Gerry Dulac: People think that every year after a loss. I think it's going to be OK. Let's give it 6-7-8 more games

Todd: Hi Gerry, thanks for hosting the chat. Regarding the Joey Porter Junior conclusion, An easy complaint is that they agreed with other players this summer, that perhaps didn’t have the same on field value as a starting “top” NFL cornerback. One Common explanation is that the cap is going to continue to rise and even though a contract for a player like Benton, may seem a bit high now, it’s gonna look like a good deal later. If - with a capital I - That point of view is accurate (deals agreed on now look better in a few few years, which is genuinely true for all NFL contracts, The highest paid player is only that until the next guy signs His record deal) do you know why they didn’t take that approach with Joey Porter Jr? Any deal they would’ve signed this summer would likely look really good in the next few years when top Cornerbacks make even more? Was it just the guaranteed money? Their penchant for restructuring deals to create cap Room down the road? Egos? Bad advice? All the above?

Gerry Dulac: Todd, I commend your thoughts and you are right. But I don't think it is always prudent to "project" when doing a current contract. The Steelers reward players for what they have done almost as much for what they still think they can do. And I think $27+ million annually more than says the Steelers liked what JPJ has done and what they think he would still do. Apparently, he didn't think so.

mrbill1031: Isnt that the job of a porter moving suitcases from place to place?

Gerry Dulac: Haha

BeaverFallsKid: There is plenty of season left and the Steelers may make a run at the playoffs. However, it seems AR2 and the Khan artist may soon need to abandon their "win now" strategy. I am not suggesting they take a dive.... that's abhorrent. But the manifestation of "win now" seems haphazard. Out with Gainwell. Out with Pickens, in with DKM (the same guy with less talent). Out with Jones. Out with Porter. Playing Dowdle too much (when he's healthy). Can the Steelers win with a roster of "volunteers instead of hostages," or do they have a responsibility to keep, develop and pay the truly talented?

Gerry Dulac: Nobody has a responsibility to pay the truly talented, as you call them, when they are divise elements in the locker room. Don't always believe all that crap about players saying they support each other when it comes to contract holdups. That is true up to a point. But eventually that "point" is subject to change

Gerry Dulac: OK kids, that's all the time we have today. Thanx for all the JPJ questions. Hopefully, we've all had enough.