Summers in Latrobe almost always made for good entertainment under Mike Tomlin. His Steelers training camps were known to be physical.

From goal-line drills to 1-on-1 battles, there was the constant sound of pads popping.

That, however, was not the case this August during Mike McCarthy’s first camp at coach.

Early in camp, my Post-Gazette colleague Chris Carter and I watched part of a practice together. Both of us mentioned it felt like a midweek workout in the regular season. Without live tackling, for example, there was a lack of intensity and physicality just about every day at Saint Vincent College.

Advertise with us

I initially viewed this to be different but not necessarily a problem.

McCarthy is an offensive coach. It made sense his practices were more focused on nailing down the new playbook rather than attempting to separate the men from the boys.

But while the Steelers offense has flashed more potential over the past few weeks than it had in previous years, I’m starting to question if the team’s biggest flaws can be attributed to McCarthy’s philosophy on training camp.

Four weeks into the season, I think it’s fair to say this Steelers team — now 2-2 after a bunch of missed tackles contributed to another loss in Cleveland on Thursday night — can go through stretches where it looks a bit soft.

It starts in the trenches. Pass protection was an issue in three of the four games. The defensive line has been inconsistent, as well. For as much draft capital that’s been invested into these two areas of the roster, you’d expect better results. But perhaps preparation has played a factor into what we’ve seen so far.

Advertise with us

The same can be said when it comes to tackling. The Steelers missed numerous tackles in closed spaces Thursday, allowing a Browns ball-carrier to turn a small gain into a large one. On Jaleel McLaughlin’s 28-yard touchdown run, the diminutive back bounced off of two Steelers as if they were tackling dummies.

It shows in other areas, too, such as contested-catch situations for Steelers receivers or blitz pickups by running backs.

Make no mistake — I’m not suggesting this Steelers roster has a toughness issue. But right now, they seem to lack the ability to play physical football consistently for four quarters. I think that is a big reason why the Steelers are 2-2.

McCarthy’s camp might deserve part of the blame — or maybe I’m way off.

Fans, however, should hope I am right about this one. Why? Because if that is the case, then the Steelers are simply behind the 8 ball and it’s something that can be fixed as the year goes on. There are plenty of games remaining.

Advertise with us

But if the issues we witnessed in Thursday’s 27-24 loss in Cleveland continue to surface, this will be a question that carries more and more relevance.

Four-down territory

First down: That opening drive was perfect

For the second straight game, the Steelers had a phenomenal opening drive.

Their first possession in the Week 3 win against Cincinnati was quick, taking just four plays to reach the end zone. Thursday’s was the complete opposite. It was a 17-play drive, the longest any Steelers team has delivered since 1978.

The Steelers killed 9:48 worth of game clock and capped off the drive with a Roman Wilson touchdown. Their offensive attack was perfectly balanced, with the Steelers running the ball eight times and dropping back to pass nine. It was another masterful exhibition of game-planning by McCarthy and his staff.

Advertise with us

But unlike last Sunday, that excellence wasn’t sustained throughout the rest of the first half. Rodgers’ interception early in the second quarter flipped momentum and threw the Steelers offense out of rhythm until the fourth quarter.

Second down: The Browns kept the door open

While the Browns did enough to win, they certainly gave the Steelers plenty of opportunities to battle back. Cleveland was remarkably undisciplined, committing 14 penalties for 88 yards. It also turned the ball over twice, matching Pittsburgh’s total, thanks to Rodgers’ interception on the game’s final play.

Against the Bengals last weekend, the Steelers made the most of their opponent’s mistakes. Two fourth-down gaffes by the Bengals led to 10 points for the Steelers, ultimately making the difference. This time, they weren’t so lucky.

The main example here is when T.J. Watt tallied a strip sack with just under five minutes remaining in the third quarter. The Steelers, down 21-10, took over near midfield. But Rodgers was sacked on third down, leading to a punt.

Advertise with us

Had the Steelers gotten points on that drive — especially seven or eight — the Steelers might be 3-1 and in first place in the AFC North this morning.

Third down: Rodgers needs to be better

Rodgers made a few nice passes late to help the Steelers rally back to tie up the score. But Thursday was far from his best game. He missed too many open men, displayed shaky pocket awareness and took three sacks on third down.

His mobility isn’t close to what it once was, which is to be expected for any quarterback still playing at age 42. But if the pass protection remains this inconsistent, something else must be figured out.

Speaking of figuring things out ... let’s just say the communication between Rodgers and McCarthy looked a little off at times during the game.

Advertise with us

Prime Video’s streaming broadcast caught the two barking at each other a few times, including clear obscenities being exchanged. This was addressed after the loss.

“I think what’s said on the field, the way I grew up in this game, usually stays on the field,” McCarthy said. “That’s not the case today. I understand that. But any negative communication on my part, I wish I wouldn’t use those words.”

Fourth down: The frustration on D was noticeable

Rodgers and McCarthy weren’t the only ones in black and gold who were frustrated Thursday. Steelers defenders were also visibly perturbed, both on the broadcast and in the locker room.

After the second of three Browns touchdown drives in the second quarter, Jalen Ramsey and Patrick Queen had a passionate discussion on the sidelines, while Watt asked for a headset to talk with the coaches up in the press box.

Advertise with us

After the loss, Ramsey sat at his locker and had a long talk with defensive coordinator Patrick Graham. Their chat lasted more than 10 minutes, perhaps displaying how determined the Steelers defense is to get back on the same page.

Most Valuable Player

DK Metcalf

I’ve been wondering when we would see him look like a No. 1 receiver. He did when it mattered most Thursday. He was the Steelers’ best offensive player in the fourth quarter. He finished with five receptions for 115 yards. It was his first triple-digit receiving effort since the Baltimore game on Dec. 7, 2025.

Least Valuable Player

Chris Boswell

Boswell missed a field goal for the third time this season. He has only one perfect performance so far. His first two misses in 2026 were both from 50-plus yards. Thursday’s miss came from 48. I don’t think it’s time to panic, but I am again willing to suggest Boswell might no longer be the weapon he once was.

Advertise with us

Quote of the week

Ramsey offered some interesting words on the Joey Porter Jr. situation following the loss.

“I was in that situation before and I know it can leave a sour taste in people’s mouths, especially fans,” Ramsey said. “But the only thing I can say is that Joey loves Pittsburgh. Joey loves this team, but business is business.

“The Steelers chose which route they wanted to go, as well. It’s not all on Joey. I know it’s easy for people to want to be mad at Joey or whatever the case may be. But it’s a business decision. It happens, and everybody moves on.”

One question

Who is the Steelers’ top cornerback?

With Porter off to Dallas and Jamel Dean leaving Thursday’s game due to injury, the Steelers will likely be forced to lean on younger, less experienced cornerbacks to pick up the slack. Their schedule doesn’t feature any elite passers in the next few weeks, but it’s a challenge to monitor nonetheless.

Advertise with us

One prediction

Expect another bounce-back win

Similar to what happened after their previous road loss, I expect the Steelers to respond well in Week 5. They’ve looked their best at home. I’m predicting their first two-score victory of the McCarthy era against the Indianapolis Colts.