Gerry Dulac: OK kids, let's get our chat started.....

Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: what is the next move at edge/OLB? They can't really keep all three can they?

Gerry Dulac: I've been told they're not planning any. That doesn't mean some team could call them, thinking they might want to unload someone, and a deal materialize. I'm not saying that's happening or anything like that, but you never know in this league how deals develop.

Bill In LA: Do you sense the same bias against rookies under McCarthy or are thongs changing?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Bill, I don't think they wear those things

Bill In LA: Honestly say if no Mike Tomlin in Pittsburgh is a breath of very fresh air.

Gerry Dulac: And here I thought it was the San Diego-like weather we've been having.

Tim Z: Hey Gerry so glad you’re continuing these chats. You are my number one go to guy for credible information with the Steelers and have been for a long time in your opinion now that we did the Herbig extension which player becomes more tradable, Watt or Highsmith?

Gerry Dulac: Thanx man. Well because you asked, I'd say 56. But, to that point, 56 was the better player last season.

Advertise with us

Eric Witt: Morning! Might we see a position switch for one of the OLB or possibly more with all 3 on the field?

Gerry Dulac: I think you will see more of all 3 on the field at the same time. Herbig specialty is rushing the passer. He's an edge rusher. That's why he was paid like one.

Tim Z: Gerry Now that the schedule has been released, what three-game span would you deem to be the toughest throughout the season?

Gerry Dulac: I would say that six-game stretch, starting from Nov. 22 in Philadelphia through Dec. 27 vs Carolina is the toughest

Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: The Browns gave Garrett $40m a year and got a sack record and then a massive haul in trade capital that sets them up incredibly well for the "great QB draft of 2027" right as Watson's deal comes off the books. The Steelers gave Watt $41m and got 7 sacks and a $64m remaining liability. If handling 30ish year old edge rusher contracts were a game is this similar to 1989's opener, Browns 51 - Steelers 0?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Ba-dum!

Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: great article last week about the cap. I am glad someone in Steeler media land is paying attention to it. The cap situation suddenly looks dire with Porter still to sign. I still don't see how Ramsey fits in at his huge salary as he failed as a free safety last year at critical moments. He is not a "one helmet guy". Any chance he is traded or released?

Gerry Dulac: I was checking after Herbig's deal and was told there is no urgency to dump a high-priced player. We shall see. That being said, I don't think it would be Ramsey.

Tim Zwis: Hey Gerry could you use your influence with the powers to be (haha) for the 2027 season for the Steelers to play in Munich during Oktoberfest?? My last name gives it away doesn’t it?

Gerry Dulac: You overestimate my influence. But a Germany trip would be great. It's only a matter of time.

Advertise with us

Richard Coastal Bend: Good morning Gerry, why have the steelers allowed Darnell Washington to balloon up in weight, he looks slow and lumbering for a tight end. When drafted I remember him being described with pretty good speed for a man his size.

Gerry Dulac: He looks the same weight and with the same movement as he always has. Now, that's not exactly Pat Freiermuth movement, but nothing really has changed. I actually thought last year was the best he's looked since coming here

Josh: Good morning Gerry. Herbig got his deal which is good, but it doesn’t officially kick in until the 2027 season correct? So to everyone calling for the Steelers to trade Watt or Highsmith right now, there’s really no need to and they can reevaluate after this season on the edge rusher plan, or am I wrong?

Gerry Dulac: It's a new five-year contract, not an extension, so any type of signing bonus starts counting against the cap now

G Money: I've always thought C Heyward was way overrated. A nice career, but nowhere near the dominant player you all make him out to be. But aside from that, he's been an awful captain of the highest paid and most underperforming Defense in league. Now he "holds in", has the podcast, zero leadership and 1 playoff win in 14 years. Has some stats but never shows up big in big games. Heck in the playoffs they gave up 300 yards rushing! What say you.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I say you sound like someone who is not a big fan of a four-time first-team All-Pro.

Mike D: Do they trade Highsmith now?

Gerry Dulac: That's not the plan

Mass Fan: What can we expect with ARod having history with McCarthy as far as the offense goes. Especially with the improved WR room. Still quick throws due to his age/mobility and the questions on the OL? Or gunslinger here we come.

Gerry Dulac: Let's hope it's a little more of the latter.

Advertise with us

TooTall21: Gerry, I’m interested in your opinion of the Myles Garrett trade. Seems to me, that getting Verse in addition to the 3 draft picks was a great deal for the Browns. Would you have considered that a good deal for the Steelers if they could have made that deal for either Watt or Highsmith?

Gerry Dulac: Honestly, I thought the Browns would get two No. 1s, but I guess that's why they got Verse in the exchange. And yes I would have!!

Josh: Are we seeing a new way the office of the Steelers operates by getting these extensions done earlier than they usually do? Or is this just a product of having more than a few extensions to do this year and they’re getting a jump on them?

Gerry Dulac: It's also a by-product of a much larger salary cap. Still, Boz, Rodgers, Herbig? And at least one more to come? Whew.

Alan in Bama: Good morning Gerry, it’s week six, Rodgers is 2-4 or injured. Who’s the quarterback going into week 7?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: To quote Bill Cowher, I don't deal in what-ifs

Brian: Is there some package being installed on D that puts Watt, Highsmith, and Herbig all on the field at the same time for more of the game or do you anticipate someone being traded?

Gerry Dulac: That's part of the plan. But it you paid attention, they did some of that last year, too, with all 3 on the field at the same.

Rich in C Bus: Morning Gerry in your opinion what turn of events would make the Steelers a strong playoff contender this year, and conversely what also would shipwreck the season?

Gerry Dulac: They are the defending division champ and, I believe, better equipped than last season. So I think they are a strong playoff contender. But, if you mean a strong Super Bowl contender, I'm not going to go that far. Not until I see a playoff victory. Till then, that's the best that can be anticipated.

Advertise with us

Jim Bow Dean: Last season Rodgers had one of quickest releases and lowest average depth of target in the league. Everyone says he was afraid to get hit, and I’m sure there’s some truth to that, but isn’t most of that on Tomlin? The Steelers have been throwing quick and short since 2019 across four different coordinators and eight different QBs. Tomlin was the one constant.

Gerry Dulac: Just about all of that is on Tomlin and the way he wants to play. And that's get directed to Arthur Smith. Rodgers is not afraid to get hit -- he's a tough dude. But the Steelers were not wanting him to get hit if they could prevent it.

Rich in C Bus: Yaya Black to nose tackle! Should have happened a year ago!

Gerry Dulac: I'll tell them. That's a big man

Rich in C Bus: Gerry the coaching jumps off the page to me this year from previous ones….just my imagination?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Not at all

Josh: Do you get the sense of any regret within the Steelers organization on the deal they have TJ before last season? I say this knowing he garners a lot of attention which helps free up the likes of Highsmith and Herbig. But he’s still being paid handsomely to be the game wrecker he’s supposed to be.

Gerry Dulac: Regret will only come into play if he has another season like last year and not like the previous ones where he was one of the most dominant players in the league. That being said, the Steelers were aware when they gave Watt his huge deal that it might have been a risky business decision.

The Eman: With what Cleveland was able to get for Garrett, what do you think would be the trade value for Watt or Highsmith?

Gerry Dulac: I think the ship has sailed to get a No. 1 pick for Watt now. Highsmith would command less, but probably at least a third-round pick and another.

Advertise with us

Paid by the Ger: Good morning, Mr. Gerry, are the Steelers likely to trade 90 or 56? Or are they going to roll with a very highly-paid olb group?

Gerry Dulac: I think they are going to roll for now. Again, let's not forget, they want to win NOW! And they're making sure they are positioned to do so.

Danny Noonan: if you could play any golf course this summer in the United States what course would it be and why?

Gerry Dulac: Augusta National. Because it's Augusta National. Here's a secret (don't tell anyone): I've already played it. And with the same Sunday pins.

Tom in TN: Gerry, Porter gets a new deal now that Herbig is done but for how much and were does that leave the cap?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: There are 77 CBs in the league who have a higher average salary than Porter. 77!! That's not going to remain that way. Nor should it.

Rich in C Bus: Gerry I still the the timing and way that Mike T left is suspicious. Is it possible that Art told him that he would “run it back” one more year but wasn’t going to extend him, and Tomlin was offended? The parting doesn’t seem as amicable as advertised!

Gerry Dulac: Not at all. Mike Tomlin thought it was time to step away. I didn't disagree with him.

Rich in C Bus: Given what the Browns got for Myles and taking into account what has transpired in the recent past, did the Steelers miss a golden opportunity to trade TJ two years back?

Gerry Dulac: Uh...well....yeah. But easy for us to say in retrospect

Advertise with us

Lou: Hey Gerry. Is the Herbig deal too much for a backup player? Or is this a signal some other big change is imminent this or next season?

Gerry Dulac: I think it's the equivalent of the Bat Signal

SteelerMark: Mr D. So glad you and the team are still working for us! Question or thought-Back in time when Vrable was w us he was a converted DE. He didn’t work at nfl DE and was so so at olb so we let him go. The pats saw a football player and used him all over. Maybe our new d coordinator does the same w Herbig. We know Tomlin was not creative like that. What do you think?

Gerry Dulac: I think you might be on to something. They didn't pay Herbig to have him lead the band at halftime

Geo: Which expensive edge rusher goes ?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: As of right now, none

Steeltown: Gerry, now that Herbig is signed, and I hear a lot of talk about trading Highsmith, I think that would be a mistake. He has a very team friendly contract and is in his prime. He also was producing better than Watt. The Steelers should have traded him last year, but I still think the best move is to trade him while they can get something for him? Thoughts?

Gerry Dulac: That is always the balance GMs try to strike -- when to trade while there is still some value. You are right about one thing -- 56 played better than 90 last season. Don't worry, the Steelers know that

BeaverFallsKid: Hi Gerry. Happy for Herbig. Analysts talk about how great he is in pass rush but not as strong against the run. Understanding edge guys get paid for sacks and pressure, how do you rate his run defense and pass coverage skills?

Gerry Dulac: They rarely ask their OLBs to cover, or, at least, that was the case in the old defense. So not fair to evaluate their pass-coverage ability. And, yes, they do pay them to get sacks

Advertise with us

Big Steel: The trade of Miles Garrett is intriguing. The Brown's invested in their future. I'm intrigued by their evolving Roster and future.The Steelers continue to have a culture that emphasizes loyalty! The Roster is like Groundhog's Day. Playoff contenders with a chance to win in the first round. Hence the question---At what point do you tweak the culture of loyaty and commit to a rebuild that can win big and have a serious playoff run?

Gerry Dulac: 18 of the previous 21 drafted players made the team. The only three who didn't went on IR. Aaron Rodgers. Jalen Ramsey. Patrick Queen. Jamel Dean. Rico Dowdle. Trades for DK Metcalf and Michael Pittman. I would call that more than a tweak.

Dave in SC: Gary thanks for the chats I always look forward to them. Congratulations to Nick on his new contract that is well deserved, am I correct in assuming that this contract doesn’t effect this year’s salary cap but takes effect in the 2027 season

Gerry Dulac: The pro-rated portion of his signing bonus will count against this year's cap

Chill Dave: Hi Gerry, I know a lot of people think the Steelers have to trade Watt or Highsmith b/c of the Herbig signing, but isn't it more likely that they keep the most important position in a Steelers defense strong and rotate the three of them?

Gerry Dulac: Yes it is.

Bill in PA: With the Herbig extension what is your best guess on what happens next; TJ restructure/trade, Highsmith trade, or play out this year with all 3 and trade/release/restructure TJ next year?

Gerry Dulac: All 3 this year

Retire21: By no means do they need another quarterback but the Steelers are linked in some places as a candidate for the guy available in the supplemental draft….. have the Steelers ever taken anybody in the supplemental draft? What’s the word on this guy?

Gerry Dulac: I don't think that's on their radar.

Dj: will either Watt or Highsmith be traded? One will have to and will it be prior to this season or after? I would trade watt given his production and cap hit/age

Gerry Dulac: That seems to be a popular sentiment. Doesn't mean the Steelers share it

Jersey Danno: Gerry, were the Steelers in talks with Herbig’s people before the Garrett trade or was the trade the impetus to get him locked up.

Gerry Dulac: The Garrett trade has nothing to do with it

Seeler4Life: Benton odd man out for contract extension?

Gerry Dulac: Not necessarily. Porter, Benton and Darnell Washington all remain possibilities.

Seeler4Life: Best landing spot from Alex Highsmith?

Gerry Dulac: I'd say OLB

Retire21: Lots of teams building or planning to build new stadiums, even ones that have newer ones now. I doubt the Pirates would build a new one … what about the Steelers. Lease is up a few years.?

Gerry Dulac: I really can't see a new stadium. Maybe a refurbished one.

Seeler4Life: MT HOF coach?

Gerry Dulac: Probably, but as a HOF selector, I can tell you the voting process makes it harder every year. Look at Belichick. MT's total wins though make it hard to keep him out.

Seeler4Life: Rams number 1 SB contender?

Gerry Dulac: They're right up there.

Seeler4Life: Which of these M. Bryant (WR), Shazier, Bell, AB, Killer Bees are the greatest what if/s?

Gerry Dulac: Several aren't even what-ifs -- Shazier, AB, Bell. There are what-weres. Martavis Bryant might be the greatest what-if

Spjack: Hi Gerry! Haven’t submitted a question to you since the Devin Bush fiasco! Wow! What do you think of the Nick Herbig contract? Unexpected to say the least? Btw I pushed for Bush, you tried to talk me down . Kudos!

Gerry Dulac: It's a whopper of a deal for a guy who is technically considered a backup.

Silent Bob: Hello Gerry - There can't be many teams with a better WR 1-2 tandem than Metfalf and Pittman, can there? Do you think there are more than 3 or 4 teams with a better top tandem? It's taken a few years but it seems Khan has turned the team's most glaring weakness into a strength.

Gerry Dulac: It's a good tandem. Not going to call it better than Chase-Higgins in Cincy. Jefferson-Addison in Minnesota? But it's a good one

Mike C: Gerry, you’re the reason that I still subscribe to the PG. so glad it’s still alive. With the Steeler performance

Mike C: Hit return. Sorry. With the performances of the past few years, do we really have a bona Fide “star” on the roster anymore? Maybe TJ

Gerry Dulac: Cam is still at the top of his game. Rodgers has some of the biggest star power in the league, even though he's not the player he was. TJ is TJ, but he needs to start playing more like the old TJ

itsallmoot: I keep seeing people talk about the need to "see what we have" with WH and/or DA or we'll go into next year in the same boat. Forget the argument that ownership wants to win every year: more importantly, so do the players. They only get so many shots at this. I think it was Alan Faneca who summarized his feeling on the Maddox vs Roethlisberger situation with something like "who wantts to play with someone right out of college". Players want to win now! As much as we get sick of the AR drama, he's the best chance for them to win so accept it and move on. Thoughts?

Gerry Dulac: Pay the man!

Rich in C Bus: Rogers in a more QB friendly system and a big upgrade in WR position….am I crazy to think that with some injury luck the Steelers could surprise people this year?

Gerry Dulac: Not at all

NY Steeler: Good morning. Other than the obvious conclusion that the Steelers wanted to keep Herbig, what could/do you reasonably conclude this significant signing of a "backup" means for the future of starters Watt and Highsmith?

Gerry Dulac: I think it means one of them will be moving on at some point

Steeler Joe: Hey, Gerry. Genuinely surprised by the blockbuster deal for Nick Herbig. Not sure it's a bad deal, but ... it's a risky one. So ... does that suggest that Highsmith might be the odd man out in the long run?

Gerry Dulac: Someone will be, I would assume. Hey, any deal is risky. But it is a BIG one

Gerry Dulac: OK kids, time to get on the field. Gotta go. Thanx for the questions.