Welcome to Brian Batko's Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com.
Sean M: Hello Brian. Hope you are catching up on your sleep post-draft. What does Allar’s selection mean relative to Will Howard? And Rudolph? Seems to me that if McCarthy was really impressed with him, then he would not take Allar. It is probably really difficult to train/groom two rookies (essentially) to be starting QBs in the NFL from a time standpoint alone. And you cannot place either one on the practice squad as they will likely be poached by other teams. Is there any way the Steelers go into the season with Rodgers, Howard and Allar only in their QB room? Would they ever keep four signal callers on the active roster?
Brian: On the contrary, Sean, the late nights of draft weekend have just sent me into a downward spiral of staying up past a reasonable bedtime. But I’ll get back on track soon.
Here’s how I view the quarterback situation now for the Steelers: Drew Allar is a third-round rookie, so he’ll be on scholarship regardless, and probably as the No. 3. If Will Howard looks even remotely capable, then it’s farewell to Mason Rudolph.
But if Howard struggles mightily, then the door is cracked for Rudolph to stick around as the backup. In that scenario, Howard gets cut. That happens all the time to sixth-round picks, particularly when a new coaching staff takes over.
I know you’re thinking, “But they love Will Howard!” Yes, I’m sure they do. He’s an easy guy to like. But they love Howard so much that they just invested a premium pick in Allar. How many times do the Steelers need to remind us we should put more stock into what they do than what they say?
Read More
Now, of course, they can all be part of the equation if a certain someone hangs up his cleats. Speaking of which ...
Joe Z: BB, I really believe it’s time to tell AR not to sign. With the addition of Allar, we now have 2 young QB’s we can sink or swim with. We need to see what we have. Best case, one of them actually plays well and we found our future QB. Worst case, they stink, we stink and get a high pick in the 2027 draft. Either way, it’s a win-win situation. I KNOW the new coaching staff doesn’t want to have a subpar first season but who cares? We don’t have Tomlin’s “non-losing” steak hanging over us. I’ve always been the eternal optimist but I’m sure most fans would agree. Nobody cares about a 9-8 or 10-7 season with an early playoff exit only to be sitting where we are next year for the umpteenth time. I was rooting for AR last season but I’ve done a complete 180 after the Allar pick. Do you and fellow colleagues feel the same? Hail the PPG squad. Thanks for all you do bud. Cheers!
Brian: Hey, Joe. For me, the Allar selection doesn’t change my thinking much one way or the other, considering I went into the draft fully expecting the Steelers to take a quarterback. They did so a little higher than I anticipated, but that doesn’t change the amount of development needed for Allar (and would’ve been needed for Taylen Green or Cole Payton, too, for that matter).
The “see what you have” strategy has always been directly at odds with the “run it back with Rodgers” approach. Keep in mind the Steelers’ streak of not having a losing season isn’t just Mike Tomlin’s. It predates him for the franchise, so I tend to think it means something to people in that organization independent of Tomlin.
I can’t disagree with anyone who views another Rodgers season as little more than spinning their wheels, much like the final two years with Ben Roethlisberger. But this organization badly wants to win a playoff game again for the first time in nearly a decade, and for all his faults, Rodgers almost certainly gives them a better chance to do that than Rudolph, Howard or Allar — long-term quarterback auditions be damned.
As for my colleagues, I can't speak for any of them, other than Tomlin. He’s my colleague now that he’s in the media and he says Rodgers still has the goods!
David K: What are the odds on the prediction sites of Mike Tomlin’s return to coaching?
Brian: I actually haven't seen any of those, which is shocking because those betting sites will send me odds on anything and everything.
My own personal odds are 65%. I think he was just burned out, particularly from a Steelers perspective, and needed a break. No one will ever be able to tell me the “Fire Tomlin” chant at the Bills game didn't hit home for him in some way.
Tampa Bay strikes me as the most logical landing spot. Todd Bowles is 62 and is coming off an 8-9 season. Tomlin began his NFL career there and has a longstanding rapport with ownership. I don’t think he’ll get back into coaching for just any situation, but that one stands out to me.
Mark from Cali: Hi Bats, I am confused as to why no one in the national media is blasting the Cowboys for switching with the Eagles to take Lemon. Evidently, they also did it with DeVonta Smith a few years ago. Am I missing something here? Omar is getting ripped for the phone call, but how could he have anticipated that level of stupidity? The Cowboys have always been dysfunctional, but this seems to be a whole new level? I can’t imagine the Steelers swapping with the Ravens so they could draft a WR that is going to potentially burn us twice a year! Thank you.
Brian: What if the Dallas Cowboys aren’t scared of Makai Lemon? Clearly, they weren’t scarred by the Smith trade in 2021 — at least not enough to avoid doing it again.
And clearly some teams are totally fine trading with divisional rivals. The Cowboys wanted to recoup a bit of draft capital after trading up earlier — only one spot, don’t you know — and Philadelphia was a means to an end.
Also, in this particular case, the Cowboys were targeting edge rusher Malachi Lawrence and there was a good chance he’d still be there a few spots later. He was, and they took him, picking up a couple more picks in the process.
Tony F: Bats – I’m a big fan of your columns and chats – love your brand of humor that you bring to the PG! My question: Will the Ginger Wookie be the starting LG to start the regular season?
Brian: At least someone does. Not sure it’s acceptable to call Gennings Dunker a Ginger Wookiee, but he is pretty follicularly talented.
And I’ll go ahead and predict he does start somewhere on the line, yes, whether that’s left guard or right guard (should Mason McCormick flip sides, for whatever reason). Dunker’s not exactly a developmental player as a redshirt senior who’s about to turn 23 and admittedly short on relative athleticism. But don’t count out Spencer Anderson being the initial starter.
Steven B: It seems strange to me to place so much on the "value" of a player at a given pick. The only thing we should worry about is how drafting a player helps or hurts OUR team. It doesn't affect Ws and Ls if he was a 3rd rounder instead of a 4th rounder. I can understand grading the selection in relation to who else was available that may have helped our team more. That seems like a better way to grade the pick. (Insert Prove Me Wrong meme)
Brian: Sure, but we all know the draft is an inexact science, so you do the best you can to project and then live with the choices. Evaluating a team’s ability to play the game within the game and manage their picks, relative to perceived value, is the more reasonable way to assess it immediately.
But I hear you. Get the guys you want and go from there. The only rule is it has to work. (Great read, by the way.)






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.