The 2025 NFL season is in the rearview mirror. I meant to predict the Seattle Seahawks would be the last team standing, Sam Darnold would become the seventh active NFL player to win a Super Bowl as a starting quarterback, and 38-year-old Mike Macdonald would hoist the Lombardi Trophy in his second year as a head coach ...
But I forgot.
What I’m not forgetting to do is pop the top on the annual Post-Gazette preseason predictions time capsule. It’s always fun, or humbling — or both — to look back at what we got right, what we got wrong and how we fared projecting the Steelers’ fortunes.
Steelers record
Fellow beat writer Ray Fittipaldo and I really went out on a limb guessing 10-7 for a team that had gone 10-7 two years running. Make it three in a row and make it a good start for me and Fittipaldo. Our postgame host and assistant sports editor for multimedia Adam Bittner was too low at 9-8, but Tyler Loop nearly made him correct.
Gerry Dulac, Christopher Carter, Jason Mackey and Paul Zeise were too high at 11-6. But none of them picked the Steelers to win the AFC North Division. In fact, our entire panel voted for the Baltimore Ravens, so we all whiffed on that one.
Even with Mike McCarthy replacing Mike Tomlin and this familiar feeling of Aaron Rodgers angst, it’s hard to not see 10-7 in the cards again for 2026, right? No team in the 17-game era that began in 2021 has had the same finish three consecutive years, let alone four if the Steelers pull that off. And to take that a step further, it actually has been 10-8 the past three seasons when you include the playoff results.
Read More
Steelers MVP
You would have to be a soothsayer to have chosen Kenneth Gainwell in early September when we filled out our ballots. Gainwell was supposed to be a role player, a third-down back with a bit of upside to be a slightly more significant contributor. Surely, he wouldn’t make a bigger impact than the likes of T.J. Watt, Jalen Ramsey, Cam Heyward or Rodgers.
Those were the Steelers who received votes from us to be voted team MVP by their peers. Watt actually was the only one who had more than one of us on his side, and yours truly also picked him for NFL Defensive Player of the Year.
Speaking of which, only Bittner had Myles Garrett taking home that crown again. Carter went Ramsey for both, as I did with Watt, while mostly everyone else placed their bets on Micah Parsons. As for NFL MVP, no one had Matthew Stafford — nor Drake Maye, for that matter. Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson were popular choices to win another one.
Steelers Rookie of the Year
First-rounder Derrick Harmon, third-rounder Kaleb Johnson and fifth-rounder Yahya Black were the only ones receiving votes. No Jack Sawyer and no Will Howard, so feel free to accuse us of anti-Buckeyes bias.
But Carter and Mackey were right on with Harmon, whose preseason knee injury delayed his NFL debut until Week 3. And those of us who picked Black were enamored with what we saw from him in training camp.
In the end, No. 21 overall was more dominant than No. 164 overall. And Johnson’s rookie campaign was a total bust despite Dulac’s and Zeise’s faith in him.
Steelers breakout player
The first category that lends itself to subjectivity, Wilsons ruled the day for our expectations. Payton and Roman were the only Steelers to appear on multiple ballots, with the latter getting the most love.
It’s probably fair to say the Steelers’ second-year inside linebacker didn’t break out the way Fittipaldo or Zeise envisioned. And the Steelers’ second-year wide receiver definitely didn’t get it done for Dulac and Mackey.
Me? I’m quite pleased with the season Joey Porter Jr. had, even if I did have more of a statistical leap in mind. There aren’t many stats to bolster the case for an offensive lineman, but Carter’s breakout guy was right tackle Troy Fautanu, who also played well for the most part.
Coach of the Year
We were all over the place here, but no one had New England’s Mike Vrabel taking home the honor for the second time in his career — in his first year leading the Patriots. Oddly enough, Tampa Bay’s Todd Bowles and Washington’s Dan Quinn were the only coaches who had more than one of us in their corners, and neither made the playoffs.
Riding with Ben Johnson makes Mackey the clear victor here, given how the Chicago Bears responded to his first season at the helm. Johnson finished fourth in the final Associated Press poll in an especially difficult year to win it.
First coach fired
Wait, why do we do this one every year? Are we truly that callous?
Sorry, but the hot seat is a major part of the NFL news cycle year in and year out. Brian Daboll and Mike McDaniel swept this ignominious prompt other than one Kevin Stefanski (Fittipaldo), and all three wound up fired after the season. Daboll was the only one in-season, so Dulac, Carter, Mackey and Bittner came closest. But none of us were dead-on because Brian Callahan got the axe on Oct. 13 in Tennessee.
Super Bowl champion
Well, nobody saw the Seahawks coming to this degree, but Bittner gets a golf clap. He was the only staffer to have them making the postseason, and even took them to win the NFC West.
The Patriots weren’t in anyone’s playoff field. We all saw Buffalo or Baltimore wearing the crown, other than Zeise, who backed Green Bay. If there were an award for worst call, it might have to go to Joe Starkey, who had Arizona not just in the postseason field but winning the NFC West. Instead, the Cardinals finished 3-14, the worst record in the conference and tied for the worst in the NFL.
Mackey had the most playoff teams correct with nine. Carter went 0 for 8 on division winners, which speaks to the parity that set in this season.
But in spite of that, allow me to offer a far-too-early shot in the dark for next year: Seahawks over Bills to go back-to-back, Josh Allen is the MVP and the first coach fired is — ah, never mind.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.