Each week, Christopher Carter gives his grades after watching the All-22 film of the Steelers’ most recent contest. These grades reflect the impact the players made on the game. While all players are considered for grades, players not named are considered to have neutral grades, where they either didn’t make a major impact on the result of the game or their combination of successes and mistakes evened each other out.
These are the totals of those grades for the offense after a full season. Grades only reflect on-field play, and not whether a player did or didn’t play in a game.
Quarterbacks
Aaron Rodgers
Stars: 24
Skulls: 10
Grade B-
Read More
Rodgers brought the most competent quarterback play the Steelers have seen since Ben Roethlisberger in 2018. Most of his skulls came in three bad games, where he had three-skull grades against the Los Angeles Chargers, Buffalo Bills and on the road against the Cleveland Browns. Otherwise, he was a consistent asset to the Steelers with good decision-making, accurate throws and revived a downfield passing attack. He also had five games with three-star grades — the most on the team — each against the New York Jets, at home against the Browns, both games against the Baltimore Ravens and against the Miami Dolphins. Had he not been derailed by the top-level pass rushes, he might’ve had an elite season for the Steelers.
Mason Rudolph
Stars: 1
Skulls: 5
Grade: D
Rudolph filled in well during the Steelers’ home win against the Cincinnati Bengals when Rodgers was injured. But other than that, his fill-in efforts weren’t a net-positive. He’s still a good backup quarterback — and arguably one of the best backups in the NFL — but he didn’t have his best year coming off the bench.
Running backs
Jaylen Warren
Stars: 27
Skulls: 1
Grade: A+
Warren was arguably the most consistent player on the Steelers’ roster. He ranks in the top 10 among NFL running backs in missed tackles forced and yards after the catch. His ability as a runner, pass protector and receiving back made him one of the most reliable players each week for Rodgers, and he made the most out of an improved offensive line. He also improved his fumble issues, as he had just one fumble across 251 touches — he averaged a fumble for every 67.6 touches during his first three years with the Steelers.
Kenneth Gainwell
Stars: 22
Skulls: 2
Grade: A
Gainwell was the biggest surprise boost to the Steelers offense as a runner and a receiver out of the backfield. His ability to not only catch the ball, but also run a wider variety of routes made him dangerous for any defense the Steelers faced. His 512 receiving yards and 557 yards after the catch were each fourth most among NFL running backs this season. Out of the eight running backs who were targeted 68 times this season, Gainwell’s reception rate of 88.5% was the best.
Kaleb Johnson
Stars: 0
Skulls: 4
Grade: D
Johnson only played in 10 games but never had an overall positive impact on a game that registered a star performance. He also only had two games where he registered a skull, but the problem was his three-skull performance against the Seattle Seahawks. Had Johnson just not allowed a kickoff ball to sit in the end zone in that game, the Steelers would’ve had a better chance to beat the NFC champion, and Johnson might’ve just gone through this year largely being considered a player on a redshirt season.
Wide receivers
DK Metcalf
Stars: 19
Skulls: 5
Grade: B
Metcalf was one of the Steelers’ most consistent contributors for the majority of the season. Metcalf registered his only games with multiple skull grades in the final four games of the season. But like Gainwell, he also registered four games with three-star grades and was a major uplifting force for the offense. His consistent presence as a playmaker and a leader helped the Steelers win several close games and propped up an otherwise lacking receiver group in the playmaking department.
Ben Skowronek
Stars: 6
Skulls: 0
Grade: B-
Skowronek’s biggest contributions weren’t as a receiver, but as the team’s special teams ace as a gunner. He did also make plays when given opportunities in the passing offense, but he also doubled as a more-than-competent blocker for the run and in short passes. He’s one of the grinders on the team, and that got him his Pro Bowl honor this season.
Calvin Austin III
Stars: 7
Skulls: 6
Grade: C
Austin bookended the regular season with high-level performances, as he was a big playmaker in the season opener against the Jets and AFC North finale with his game-winning touchdown catch against the Ravens. But in between those performances, he only had three other games where he earned at least a single star, which matched the number of games he registered skulls during that stretch. In a contract year, Austin made plays, but not enough to be a consistent asset to the team.
Adam Thielen
Stars: 2
Skulls: 0
Grade: C+
With only a few games, Thielen made some important catches that kept drives alive. He wasn’t a game-changer, but he was a solid veteran who made a difference in the small ways he could before he retired.
Scotty Miller
Stars: 2
Skulls: 0
Grade: C+
Miller was on the field for 13 games but only registered a star performance in two games toward the end of the season. He also wasn’t given much of a chance to make many plays with limited targets on the season. But he was solid when called upon.
Marquez Valdes-Scantling
Stars: 2
Skulls: 2
Grade: C
Valdes-Scantling missed an opportunity or two, but he also made a couple of plays in tight pinches. He balanced out to being a neutral addition to the receivers, and that was just about as good as anyone else not named Metcalf.
Roman Wilson
Stars: 2
Skulls: 7
Grade: D
What served as Wilson’s first real year playing in the NFL didn’t go over well, as the only big plays he made came in garbage time of losses. As these grades only reflect his on-field performance, they could not count into the fact that he was a healthy scratch several times throughout the season. The Steelers will most likely replenish the receiver room this offseason, which could put Wilson to a final test next year — if he’s still around.
Tight ends
Pat Freiermuth
Stars: 11
Skulls: 2
Grade: B
The Steelers needed to use Freiermuth more this season because whenever they did, he was an ace for the offense. Had he gotten more targets, he would’ve had more chances to be a big playmaker in some of the Steelers’ tighter losses, and he would’ve had more chances to total up more stars. If anything, Freiermuth continued to show he’s an asset to the team and that whatever offense comes next year, he needs to have a bigger part in it.
Darnell Washington
Stars: 13
Skulls: 1
Grade: B+
The loss of Washington at the end of the season had a big impact on the offense, as he was an elite blocker on the edge. Like Freiermuth, he also needed to have more targets in the offense, as he was a playmaker when given the chance to catch passes downfield. But even in games when Washington wasn’t targeted — or even had letdowns — he almost always made up for it with his blocking.
Connor Heyward
Stars: 7
Skulls: 1
Grade: B-
Much of Heyward’s stars came from being the player who executed the Steelers’ “spartan” play, where he would push for a first down in the middle of a packed line. But he also helped as a blocker in some spots and rarely was a detriment to the team.
Jonnu Smith
Stars: 4
Skulls: 11
Grade: F
Smith had early positive contributions, but the more Arthur Smith focused on the tight end he brought from both their days together with the Tennessee Titans and the Atlanta Falcons, the worse things got. At one point, Smith had five consecutive games where he earned a skull grade or worse. Where the other tight ends made up for their lack of targets or shortcomings in the passing games as blockers, Smith rarely was an asset in that department.
Offensive line
Zach Frazier
Stars: 23
Skulls: 3
Grade: A
Frazier was the best of the offensive line and almost always an asset to the team. The only game he registered a skull was his three-skull performance against the Houston Texans in the Steelers’ playoff loss. That and the Steelers’ loss to the Bills were the only games Frazier didn’t register at least a star grade. He’s on the trajectory to be an All-Pro center soon.
Mason McCormick
Stars: 21
Skulls: 5
Grade: B
McCormick proved to be a consistent mauler in the run game and improved as a pass protector from his rookie season. If he continues on the trajectory he’s on, he could become one of the best guards in the NFL and make for a nasty one-two punch alongside Frazier.
Dylan Cook
Stars: 10
Skulls: 1
Grade: B+
Despite just playing in six games, Cook was an asset in all but one of them. That also included four consecutive games with multiple-star grades to end the regular season. If Cook sticks with the team next year, he will be in position to battle for a starting role based off the way he played at the end of the season.
Isaac Seumalo
Stars: 13
Skulls: 6
Grade: B-
The most experienced offensive lineman on the team was mostly an asset but only had two games where he registered multiple stars. He’s one of the team’s most consistent pass protectors, and his ability to be a communicator was an asset to the tackles. If he were to stick around another season, he could be a stabilizing presence among a group of rising youngsters.
Troy Fautanu
Stars: 17
Skulls: 9
Grade: B-
Fautanu’s first real year in the NFL had a great ground floor to start with four consecutive two-star grades and seven games when he registered multiple stars. Fautanu didn’t have a game with multiple skulls until the playoff loss to the Texans, where their pass rushers gave him the hardest time he had all season. But if this is the worst he plays in his career, the Steelers will have a great tackle on their hands.
Broderick Jones
Stars: 9
Skulls: 6
Grade: C
A bad break for Jones that he suffered a season-ending injury when he did, as he registered a star performance in five of his last seven games. As the season continued, Jones became more consistent as a left tackle in his first year in the position. But he also had a rough start to the season with a three-skull performance against the Jets. If he takes more steps forward, he could be the starting tackle the Steelers traded up to get in 2023.
Spencer Anderson
Stars: 4
Skulls: 3
Grade: C
The Steelers’ regular extra lineman did a good job in that specific role when called upon in their heavy formations. But when he had to fill in, he was less of an asset and an obvious backup. He’s a good extra hand in the room but isn’t a player that the team should plan to be a starter in the near future.
Andrus Peat
Stars: 3
Skulls: 1
Grade: C
In the limited games Peat played, he was a solid backup that held down his position without being a detriment. As an extra brought in to boost depth on the team, that’s exactly what an offensive line needs.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.