DK Metcalf faces some sort of discipline for swiping at a Lions fan Sunday in Detroit. That much is certain. The question seems to be whether he will escape with a fine or be suspended for one or more games.

Regardless, Metcalf is only the latest in a long line of Steelers wide receivers who have given the franchise headaches. Seattle dealt Metcalf, 28, reportedly in part because of his history of disciplinary problems. In seven seasons, he has been fined at least 15 times totaling more than $200,000.

He also has been ejected twice since 2021 and incurred a number of 15-yard penalties (15 since 2019), according to The Athletic.

So, the Steelers could have traded one headache – George Pickens to the Cowboys – and gotten another -- DK Metcalf from the Seahawks.

Advertise with us

Here’s a look at the Steelers’ checkered history with talented but troubled wide receivers:

George Pickens

Steelers coach Mike Tomlin repeatedly faced questions about Pickens’ effort and judgment. Pickens wore eye black in a game against Dallas in October 2024 that read “Always (expletive) Open.” In his three seasons with the Steelers (2022-24) he drew numerous 15-yard penalties, including one in that same game against the Cowboys when he grabbed a Cowboys cornerback by the facemask and yanked him to the ground. Pickens’ maturity issues dated back to his time at Georgia and reportedly were one reason why the uber-talented receiver dropped to the second round.

Antonio Brown

Perhaps the most talented name on this list, and the most troubled, the Steelers dealt Brown to the then-Los Angeles Raiders before the 2019 season. As the PG’s Gerry Dulac wrote: “The deal, which has dominated the attention of the NFL world, ends a turbulent 2½ month period in which the talented but petulant receiver walked out on his teammates for the final game of the regular season and displayed insubordinate behavior to his coach, general manager and team owner.” Brown was out of the NFL by the end of the 2021 season and currently faces an attempted murder charge stemming from his discharge of a firearm in June in Miami.

Diontae Johnson

The complaints against Johnson mounted as his productivity declined. The NFL fined him $25,000 for criticizing the officials after a loss to Jacksonville in October 2023. The next month, cameras caught him failing to go after a Jaylen Warren fumble against Cincinnati. That came one play after Johnson allowed a potential touchdown catch to be knocked out of his hands, leading Tomlin to say that Johnson needed to keep a better check on his emotions. The Steelers eventually traded Johnson to the Carolina Panthers before the 2024 season.

Martavis Bryant

Most of Bryant’s issues were related to substance-abuse problems though Tomlin did bench him for a game in 2017 for ripping rookie JuJu Smith-Schuster on Instagram. Bryant was suspended for the first four games of the 2015 season, his second in the league, for violating the substance-abuse policy. Then he missed the entire 2016 season for the same reason. Ultimately, the Steelers traded Bryant to the Raiders before the 2018 season.

Advertise with us

Mike Wallace

The speedy 2009 third-round pick exceeded all expectations and gave the Steelers a reliable deep threat. It also led to a contract stalemate before the 2012 season that saw Wallace skip offseason activities and training camp. Said Tomlin, "One thing that experience has taught me is that this is bigger than all of us. It's bigger than Mike, it's bigger than me, so I mean that when I say it's unfortunate for him that he's not here." Wallace eventually reported but left as a free agent for Miami after the season for five years and $60 million.

Plaxico Burress

Most of Burress’ problems came off the field and after he left the Steelers, but as Gerry Dulac pointed out recently, the 6-5 receiver does have a dubious place in team history. In 2000, the rookie got up after a 19-yard catch against the Jaguars and, without being touched, inexplicably spiked the ball on the Alltel Stadium turf. Jaguars linebacker Danny Clark picked up the live ball and ran 44 yards to the Steelers 27. Burress, of course, is best known for accidentally shooting himself in the leg in 2008 at a New York City nightclub.

Santonio Holmes

Steelers fans will remember Holmes most for his acrobatic touchdown catch in the corner of the end zone to beat the Arizona Cardinals in Super Bowl XLIII, but he also had more than his fair share of legal problems with Pittsburgh. They started less than a month after he was drafted, when he was arrested in Miami Beach, Fla., for disorderly conduct. The charge was dropped after he paid a fine. The next month he was charged with domestic violence and assault in Columbus, Ohio. The charges were later dropped. He was cited for marijuana possession in 2008. The Steelers traded Holmes to the Jets after he was suspended for the first four games of the 2010 season for violating the league’s substance-abuse policy.

Chase Claypool

Immaturity problems hounded this talented second-round pick after a stellar rookie season. Most notably, he drew league-wide criticism after celebrating a first-down catch late in a loss to the Vikings in 2022. The celebration cost the Steelers at least five seconds of time with 30 seconds left on the clock in a 36-28 defeat. Also that season, he suggested playing music at practice could help the Steelers rebound from a big loss to the Bengals. The Steelers cut ties with Claypool in a rare midseason trade, dealing him to the Bears in 2022. They sold high, getting a second-round pick for Claypool, who was last with the Bills in training camp in 2024.

JuJu Smith-Schuster

Like Claypool, Smith-Schuster’s immaturity drew unwanted attention. He became known for his viral TikTok videos, including dancing on opponents’ mid-field logo before road games. Left tackle Alejandro Villanueva appeared to take a shot at Smith-Schuster after leaving for the Ravens, saying a balanced offense isn’t as fun for the receivers: “They’re making the TikToks, and they’re having their fun on their social media.” Smith-Schuster also trash-talked Cleveland before the Steelers lost to the Browns in a January 2021 playoff game, calling them the same “nameless gray faces” he sees every season, adding “the Browns is the Browns.” After the game, he said he didn’t regret what he said.