Welcome to Stars and Skulls, a weekly grading series that focuses on individual performances of Steelers players.
Each week, Christopher Carter gives his grades after watching the All-22 film of the Steelers’ most recent contest. These grades reflect the impact the players made on the game. While all players are considered for grades, players not named are considered to have neutral grades where they either didn’t make a major impact on the result of the game, or their combination of successes and mistakes evened each other out.
The Steelers’ 25-10 loss to the Chargers involved a mix of strong defensive play up front with catastrophic failures in critical parts of the offense, particularly in the passing game. Here are the Week 10 stars and skulls:
⭐⭐⭐ (Elite performance)
None.
⭐⭐ (Exceptionally good game — or multiple vital plays)
RB Jaylen Warren
Warren continues to be a consistent positive force for the offense. Though he only had 91 yards from scrimmage, his work to earn each of them was remarkable. His clean hurdle of a defender was one of the best plays on a bad day for the offense, and Warren’s 5.0 yards-per-carry average led all players on the night.
Read More
DL Keeanu Benton, Cam Heyward
Heyward led the Steelers with five quarterback pressures and added six tackles with another pass batted at the line of scrimmage. Heyward has five batted passes at the line of scrimmage, tied for second-most in the NFL. Between those and his gap control against the run, he remains one of the most consistent players on the team.
Benton followed up what might’ve been his best career game last week against the Colts with another strong performance, as he registered four pressures and had a sack while also being a force against the run. Pro Football Focus credited him with three run stuffs to lead the team Sunday night, and you could see him win his gaps more often than not. If he can be a consistent contributor, the defensive line might have lot going for it in the near future.
LBs Alex Highsmith, Nick Herbig
Highsmith now has back-to-back games with two sacks and registered four pressures while also being a good presence against the run. Herbig added a sack and four more pressures while also being a good presence against the run. While Highsmith is a physical presence against the run, Herbig has improved in how he uses his finesse moves to maneuver around linemen to maintain his gap.
The impact of the Steelers’ outside linebackers against the run can best be detailed in how the Chargers ran the ball outside the tackles 11 times and only gained 17 yards -— an average of 1.5 yards per carry.
⭐ (Solid performance — or made a big play without a costly play)
OL Zach Frazier
Frazier was the Steelers’ best presence on the offensive line. He only allowed a single pressure and was a good presence for the run game.
WR Roman Wilson
Wilson gets a star for his touchdown reception, but he needs to start producing when the game’s still in play. Both his touchdowns this season have come when the game is out of hand.
TEs Darnell Washington, Pat Freiermuth
Washington made an impressive catch in traffic for 15 yards and consistently won his spot in the run game. Not his best game, but he was a resource for the offense. Freiermuth caught all three of his targets for 33 yards — which suggests maybe Aaron Rodgers should’ve found a way to get him the ball more.
DL Derrick Harmon, Yahya Black
Harmon could be seen making a difference against the run with two run stuffs and kept the Steelers’ linebackers clean on several run plays. He’s still a growing rookie with flaws in his game, as he finished the game with zero pressures, but he’s on the right trajectory. Black has now been credited with a single pressure in three straight games. While that raw stat isn’t impressive, the fact he’s done that on just 31 snaps against the pass for a rate of 9.7% of his pass rushes is impressive for a fifth-round rookie. Add in a good day against the run, and Black was an asset.
LB T.J. Watt
Watt got his sixth sack in his last seven games and finished the contest with four pressures. He grades lower than his fellow outside linebackers this week, as his sack came when the game was practically decided and he did have a missed tackle against the run. Still, not a bad game.
CBs Joey Porter Jr., James Pierre
Porter finished the game with zero receptions allowed on two targets. Had he not dropped the pass he jumped in the first quarter, it would’ve meant back-to-back games with an interception for the first time in his career. Pierre filled in well for Darius Slay at cornerback, as he allowed just two receptions on five targets for 22 receiving yards and broke up two passes. On the season, Pierre has broken up six passes on 12 targets, which is a remarkable rate for him to get his hands on the ball.
S Jalen Ramsey, Kyle Dugger
Ramsey allowed just two receptions on three targets for just 11 yards and was consistently in proper position to help his teammates in coverage. Dugger wasn’t targeted once. And both were solid in run defense.
Notable neutrals
There are players who aren’t given a star or a skull because they either didn’t impact the game in a significantly good or bad way — or they did, but in a way that balanced out the good with the bad. Here, I’ll note players who classified for the latter category.
LB Payton Wilson
Wilson wasn’t as present against the run as he’d been in recent weeks, but he did help in coverage, as he only allowed two receptions on three targets for 14 yards.
RB Kenneth Gainwell
Can’t grade much on him, as he didn’t get a single carry and he only had two receptions for 4 yards on three targets. But when watching the All-22, you can see Gainwell gets open at a frequent pace and could’ve been an escape valve for Rodgers on a night in which the four-time MVP quarterback struggled.
💀 (Mildly poor performance — or made a key mistake without redemption)
WR DK Metcalf
Metcalf did lead the team with 35 receiving yards, but that’s just the problem. He was targeted seven times and only caught three passes — granted, several of those were more because of the ball placement by the quarterback. Still, Metcalf needs to either be able to get open more consistently or win more contested catches. This wasn’t a bad game overall, but the team needs more from their top receiver.
TE Jonnu Smith
This week’s drop by Smith was on a tough ball to catch. But if he came down with it, the Steelers might’ve been able to get a touchdown on the board before they were down multiple scores in the fourth quarter.
OL Troy Fautanu, Mason McCormick, Andrus Peat
Fautanu got tagged for a costly holding call and allowed the only sack of the game, while McCormick was not as good in the run game as he had been. Add in Peat’s early penalty and getting pulled, and it was not a good day for the offensive line.
LBs Patrick Queen, Jack Sawyer
Queen finished the game with a team-leading 12 tackles, but he also missed four tackles and was partially responsible on some of the explosive runs the Chargers had.
K Chris Boswell
Missed a makable field goal when the game was close. But he did make others and wasn’t the biggest detriment.
KR Ke’Shawn Williams
The game was practically over at this point, but the muffed punt was still a bad mistake.
💀💀 (Bad overall game, or multiple critical mistakes in costly moments)
OL Broderick Jones, Spencer Anderson
Jones got beat twice on third downs early in the game in a way that seemed to spook Rodgers out of his comfortability in the pocket. Though he didn’t give up a sack and did have a better day the rest of the way, the damage was done. Anderson had the most allowed pressures on the team with four and was not the asset in the way he had been.
💀💀💀 (Terrible performance, major hindrance to team/game plan)
QB Aaron Rodgers
One of the worst games of Rodgers’ career when you look at the film and see several guys open on plays during which he either turned the ball over or took a sack. He seemed to miss the open option on most plays, and even when he found them, he had multiple overthrows. He needs to get back to what he was doing in the first half of the season.
WR Calvin Austin III
Two drops on the night, one of which bounced into the arms of a defender on a play that ultimately sealed the game. If Austin wants to be part of the Steelers’ plan for their future, he needs to put games like this behind him and get back to producing at least like he did against the Colts.
CB Brandin Echols
Echols wasn’t out of sorts, miscommunicating or anything like that; he just got beat — a lot. PFF charges him with being targeted nine times and allowing eight receptions. Some of those were plays he had good coverage on, but Herbert and Ladd McConkey just made better plays. Still, Echols was the one the Chargers picked on. No other defender allowed more than 25 receiving yards on the night; Echols allowed 125 and a touchdown. No way around it, that’s a terrible night.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.