The Steelers put one of their best defensive performances of the season in their 27-20 win over the Colts on Sunday at Acrisure Stadium. The raw box score statistics weren’t as impressive as the execution of their plan in dictating how the Colts offense would have to move the ball down the field if it wanted to succeed.
That Colts came into Week 9 of the 2025 NFL season on a historic pace of efficiency and production. Not only was it the highest-scoring offense in the NFL, but the Colts gained the most yards, most yards per play, and had the most red zone trips in the NFL with 38 in eight games — a rate of almost five red zone possessions per game.
The Steelers limited the Colts to just two red zone possessions Sunday, the fewest times any defense had allowed the Colts to get inside their own 20-yard line all season. For that to happen, the Steelers had to execute a well-coordinated plan from the defensive line to the linebackers to the secondary.
The chaos the Steelers defense created led to five sacks on Daniel Jones — the Colts had allowed just 1.1 sacks per game going into Sunday — and five of the Colts’ six turnovers. For those things to happen, the Steelers had to force the Colts out of their comfort zone and into situations that gave the Steelers’ defenders more chances to capitalize on mistakes and for pass-rushers have time to get in the backfield.
So how did the Steelers take the Colts out of their comfort zone and force them to commit almost five times the amount of giveaways they had averaged to allow all season? It started with better run defense.
‘First order of business’
The Colts ranked both sixth in passing yards and rushing yards per game going into Sunday while having the most total yards per game and yards per play in the NFL. That meant — on paper — it could be tough to predict what would be most important aspect of their offense the Steelers should take away.
Read More
Jones averages getting the ball out of his hands within 2.75 seconds from the snap of the ball. In recent weeks, Jordan Love of the Packers and Joe Flacco of the Bengals both shredded the Steelers defense for more than 30 points scored each game, while both quarterbacks threw the ball on average in less than three seconds on their passing attempts.
That meant the Steelers had to do a better job of taking away opposing quarterbacks’ first reads on passing plays so that they’d have to hold onto the ball longer, process the rest of the field, and give T.J. Watt and the Steelers’ pass-rushers more time to rush the pocket.
But when asked about the Steelers’ plan to limit those primary receiving options throughout the game in his Tuesday press conference, Mike Tomlin said the primary objective was to stop the NFL’s leading rusher.
“You know, his first option is to turn and hand the ball to Jonathan Taylor,” Tomlin said. “So that was the first order of business. It all went on from there.”
Taylor’s 45 rushing yards and 3.2 yards per carry were both the lowest numbers for him all season. That happened because of a physical approach to stopping the run where the Steelers’ defensive line overpowered the Colts’ offensive line, and the Steelers’ linebackers turned into playmakers to keep Taylor contained.
During the second quarter, rookie Derrick Harmon had a run stuff that limited Taylor to just a single yard. But he wasn’t the only player who did his job on the play. Harmon did a good job winning with his hands to control Tanor Bortolini — the Colts’ center — at the point of attack and eventually shed him to make the tackle.
But it was also noticeable how Nick Herbig came off the right edge, anticipated the pull block from guard Matt Goncalves and worked around the former Pitt standout to attack Taylor in the backfield.
Also on the play, Cam Heyward took on a double team that allowed Patrick Queen to flow between two gaps and eventually come in to help Harmon finish the play.
The Steelers’ first-round investment in Harmon continues to look like it could pay dividends as he grows and develops more tools in his arsenal. But the Steelers have also seen growth from third-year defensive lineman Keeanu Benton, who had struggled against the run several times early this season.
Benton chipped in with five combined tackles and a sack Sunday. But bigger than his stats was how he engaged with what had been known as perhaps the best offensive line in football. During the third quarter, he stuffed Taylor for no gain on a play where the Steelers crashed the opposite side of the line with Alex Highsmith, Heyward, and a downhill Payton Wilson.
Benton had to maintain a gap between Queen and Watt against Goncalves. If you watch closely, you can see Benton win the hand leverage battle against Goncalves by getting his hands inside on his chest and then the power Benton has to shove the guard out of the way so he could make a play.
Once Taylor was limited and the Steelers’ offense gave the defense a lead, the Colts had to check out of their run game to move the ball. That forced them into more predictable passing situations, which allowed the plan for the pass defense to have a good foundation and favorable situations.
A schematic shift
The Steelers’ defensive plan going into the season was to be a team that could line up in man coverage with single-high safety looks and win enough to allow an aggressive blitz and get after quarterbacks.
But that plan got shredded by the Jets in the season opener, as well as the Bengals and Packers in the two weeks leading up to the Colts game. That led the Steelers to change.
Pro Football Reference charts the Steelers with the third-highest blitz rate in the NFL at 32.9% — which took a dip from 37.3% headed into the Colts game. That’s because the Steelers only blitzed on 16 of 56 passing plays against the Colts — a rate of 28.6%. Sunday’s rate was much closer to where Teryl Austin’s defense had been over the past three years, as the team only blitzed 25.9% of plays last season.
In addition to that change, NFL’s Next Gen Stats charted the Steelers as going from using two-high safety defenses just 28.2% of the time — the second-lowest rate in the NFL coming into Sunday — to 46.4% of the Colts’ passing plays this week.
That’s two significant shifts in how the Steelers have played defense this season. Tomlin wouldn’t commit to that being the permanent plan for the Steelers, but he did acknowledge the change came from what they picked up from studying the Colts’ tape.
“Week in and week out, we make decisions based on the variables of that week,” Tomlin said. “Certainly, the things we did last week were relative to the Colts and our circumstances.”
The increase in two-high safety looks allowed for the Steelers to call more Cover 2 defenses, which allowed their underneath defenders to be more aggressive against the Colts’ passing attack — which made taking away Jones’ first option on passing plays a more accomplishable task.
Highsmith made a pass breakup on a play where he dropped into coverage and the Steelers sent Brandin Echols after Jones on the opposite side of the formation. The Steelers had Wilson drop into a zone to take away Tyler Warren over the middle, while the cornerback to the right of the defense — Joey Porter Jr. — jumped to the flat.
Seeing that, Jones quickly checked to the spot of the defense he didn’t think would have a defender, as Highsmith is a regular pass rusher for the Steelers. But with Highsmith in position, he was able to break up the pass for a third-down stop that would lead to a punt.
When the Steelers acquired Jalen Ramsey, their initial plan appeared to be using him as a rotational cornerback between covering slot and outside receivers. Out of his 539 defensive snaps, 41.4% of them have been at slot cornerback with 25.4% coming at outside cornerback.
Next Gen Stats charted Ramsey aligned at safety on 83.6% of his snaps — which was a career high, as he’d never lined up at safety more than 30% of his defensive snaps in a game in the NFL.
Paired with newly acquired safety Kyle Dugger, Ramsey was part of a plan for the Steelers’ safeties to allow their cornerbacks to be more aggressive and take away underneath options. On a 2nd-and-20 in the third quarter, the Steelers rushed just four four defenders while Porter and Darius Slay took away hook patterns on both sides of the field.
Once Queen and Wilson took away the middle of the field, pressure from the Steelers’ four-man rush forced Jones out of the pocket, where he eventually was met by Porter at the boundary, leading to the third-year cornerback’s first career sack.
The Steelers still used Cover 1 man defenses to send blitzes against the Colts, but the increase in two-high safety looks allowed them to pick their spots. On a 3rd-and-9 in the fourth quarter, the Steelers dialed up a blitz for Queen to come off the edge and match up with Taylor in the backfield.
Between Queen’s rush and Cam Heyward’s bull rush, Jones was pressured into an early throw that fell incomplete while Porter was in tight coverage. The stop led to a field goal.
The Steelers’ switching up of when and how they called their blitzes kept Jones guessing and out of ryhtm with his receivers. Wilson’s interception was a result of this, as Jones tried to cycle through his reads and made a quick decision that Wilson was able to jump.
The play began with the Steelers showing Cover 1 with Dugger as the single-high safety. In man coverage across the board, Jones looked to his first two reads to his left, but both were covered by Porter and Ramsey. The Cover 1 middle-of-the-field zone defenders were Dugger deep downfield and Queen underneath, which Jones thought left Josh Downs open over the middle.
But Jones committed to his third read on the play too quickly and didn’t see Wilson hovering close by as he kept watch on Taylor as a threat out of the backfield. Wilson did a good job to be in position to help against Taylor but keep his eyes on Jones to jump the pass when it came his way.
The Steelers won’t be able to roll out the same plan every week and expect success. As Tomlin noted, more changes will be required each week and will need to depend on what each opponent does well.
But Sunday’s performance could signal the Steelers are more open to branch out from what they initially planned to be the bedrock of the their defensive schematics. The goal should be to make quarterbacks guess which looks they’re going to use, when and where extra pressure might come, and where the coverage might shift and take away both primary and secondary reads.
If the Steelers can continue to switch things up for the rest of the season, they can improve from the 21st-ranked scoring defense back to being a top-10 scoring defense like they’ve been each of the last three seasons under Austin. And that can all be done while still keeping to the team’s philosophy of stopping the run, pressuring the quarterback and being an opportunistic defense to create turnovers.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.