The Steelers’ third-down defense proved costly in key moments of their 31-17 loss at Acrisure Stadium on Sunday — and it’s an aspect of the game their defense was reliant on last year to pull them through tough moments.
In 2024, the Steelers allowed opponents to convert just 35.3% of their third downs, good for the second-best rate in the NFL. Just behind the Steelers’ defense last year were teams like the Eagles, Vikings and Chargers.
On Sunday, the Steelers allowed the Seahawks to complete 6 of 14 third downs for a rate of 42.9% to bring the Steelers’ rate through two games this season to 46.4% — 23rd-best in the NFL. If the Steelers defense is to be a good unit in 2025, this is a component of their game that must be fixed — and soon.
Out of the Seahawks; three touchdown drives, two of them featured multiple conversions of 3rd-and-4 or longer. That was something the Steelers only allowed to happen 50 times at a rate of 29.1% last year. The Seahawks were able to accomplish it five times Sunday at a rate of 41.7%.
Two of those plays came on the Seahawks’ opening drive that resulted in a touchdown. The first was a 3rd-and-6 play where Jaxon Smith-Njigba broke open on a slant against Jalen Ramsey for a 15-yard gain. The third-year receiver used a jab set to the outside to set up his move to get in front of Ramsey and open up the inside of his route to give Sam Darnold a good window to target.
The rest of the Steelers’ defense appeared to blitz or be in man coverage, save for Juan Thornhill’s deep safety role. Had Ramsey maintained inside leverage and forced Darnold to hold on to the ball for another second, T.J. Watt was a step away from a sack off his twist into the A-gap.
Read More
After the game, Cam Heyward attributed the Steelers’ shortcomings on third downs to players not understanding the full situation of certain moments.
“You’ve got to understand the situation, even if it’s 3rd-and 15,” Heyward said. “We’ve got to be more situationally aware. It’s not just ‘run up field and try to make plays.’ Have your eyes ready. Understand what they’re trying to do in these formations. Then, we have to have good communication that lends to that. Especially as a leadership, if we learn from these mistakes, they’ll go away quickly.”
After the opening drive, the Steelers’ defense appeared to get back into its groove with five consecutive third-down stops heading into the third quarter. The next time the Seahawks converted on third down came on a 3rd-and-4, when Cooper Kupp beat Ramsey to the inside again.
Ramsey had good moments with an interception and another pass broken up, but those were two third-down conversions that eventually led to touchdowns -— and he was beat on the opening touchdown of the game, as well.
“We were running man and guys were getting inside,” Patrick Queen said when asked how Darnold exploited the middle of the field against the Steelers. “When we did switch it up, they’d hit a check-down here and there. We just have to be better. When it’s our play to make, we just have to make it.”
The Steelers did have moments where they either applied pressure, won in coverage, or did both to create third-down stops. One stop on 3rd-and-8 came when Darnold’s initial reads were taken away and the pursuit of Nick Herbig and Brandin Echols didn’t give him the space or time to readjust and find anyone on a scramble drill.
The Steelers didn’t back off and hope for the Seahawks to just make mistakes. They did their best to force errors with several blitzes, stunts, twists and coverage mixups to confuse the Seahawks’ offensive line and Darnold.
“When you are able to play aggressive, it works in your favor,” Ramsey said Friday. “But obviously, you have to meet the aggression with the right execution.”
Another successful example of that aggression was on a 3rd-and-7 stop early in the fourth quarter that stalled a Seahawks drive to hold them to a field goal. On that play, the Steelers were in man coverage across the board. Watt rushed off the right edge to pressure Darnold into a throwaway. Ramsey, Echols and Darius Slay Jr. all stayed tight to their man assignments to not give Darnold a quick target to convert in the face of the pressure.
But in other key moments, the Steelers’ aggression backfired because of key mistakes by individuals who were in position to make plays. Queen missed on the bigger opportunities with a six-man rush on 3rd-and-9 where he was left unaccounted for as the Seahawks double-teamed Heyward and Watt’s twist held the attention of both the Seahawks’ left tackle and running back.
But Queen missed on his tackle, which allowed Darnold to spin out of the play and break contain. That put Payton Wilson on an island, where he had to choose between pressuring Darnold or covering A.J. Barner. The result was a third-down conversion.
For his part, Queen took full ownership of the lack of playmaking.
“We have to make the plays we’re supposed to make,” Queen said. “I could’ve got us off the field with that third down against Sam Darnold. I didn’t get him down, and it led to points. Those are plays that we’ve got to make that we didn’t make.”
The Steelers only sacked Darnold twice Sunday but did land eight quarterback hits throughout the game. There’s no one area to blame for the pass rush not getting home more, as missed opportunities by both rushers and defensive backs who were beat too quickly resulted in missed opportunities — especially on third down.
“We’ve just got keep beating on the door,” Heyward said. “A couple times, guys are just open when we couldn’t keep contain. I’ve never met a good rush without a good secondary, and I’ve never met a good secondary without a good rush. We’ve got to clean that up. We’ve got a lot of tape to watch.”
The Steelers’ final third-down failure might’ve been the biggest example of Queen’s “plays we’re supposed to make” when the Seahawks pitched the ball to Kenneth Walker for a wide run. The play stretched the Steelers’ defense, but allowed for Wilson to be one-on-one with Walker in space.
But the second-year linebacker took a bad pursuit angle, and that led to Walker’s game-sealing 19-yard touchdown.
There wasn’t a single player or position group to blame for Sunday’s shortcomings on third down. From rushers to tackles and coverage men, each had moments where they fell short in costly moments that allowed for the Seahawks’ 24 offensive points scored.
Even last week when the Steelers allowed 32 points to the Jets, they did a better job on 3rd-and-4 or longer with three stops on nine such attempts.
If the Steelers defense is to be a good unit, it has to win more of the money downs of football. As Heyward said, that’ll take better understanding of the moment to fall into mistakes that erode the concepts and schemes put into place. Each of the above examples where the Steelers came up short were not because of scheme, but because individual players came up short in matchups they could reasonably be expected to win.
Vital coaching decisions will come in the near future when Mike Tomlin and his staff have to base their game plans on whether players like Ramsey, Queen, Wilson and others can win more of those opportunities when provided. If those players do win more moments like those on a consistent basis, Tomlin and his staff’s patience will be rewarded.
But if losses in one-on-one matchups like these lead to continuous failures like what was put on tape Sunday, that patience will turn to stubbornness. And it could take wholesale changes in the defense’s structure to adjust to the shortcomings.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.