Broderick Jones will get at least one more chance to prove he can be Aaron Rodgers’ blindside protector. But his first start at left tackle in the NFL had to at least start the conversation inside the Steelers building for an alternative plan at the position if he doesn’t improve in the coming weeks.

Jones, the No. 14 overall pick in the 2023 draft, had a thoroughly forgettable debut, allowing three sacks in the 34-32 victory over the Jets. It was everything the Steelers were hoping to avoid when they decided to let Dan Moore walk in free agency and hand the job over to Jones.

The Steelers made the move despite Jones struggling at right tackle in his first two seasons. He allowed 23 sacks in 27 starts, an alarming number for any NFL lineman, much less a former first-round pick.

Some of Jones’ struggles, it was theorized, could be traced to him playing out of position at right tackle. He entered the league out of Georgia as a trained left tackle after all. Returning to his roots — where he felt most comfortable — raised expectations for his play.

Advertise with us

It was only one game, but Jones looked just as uncomfortable on the left side of the line as he did on the right side last season.

“It could be better,” Tomlin said of Jones’ performance against the Jets. “But all of our performances can be better. Our quarterback got hit too much, and he was a component of that.”

A rather big component.

Rodgers was excellent in his first game with the Steelers, but one has to wonder how long he’ll be healthy if he continues to absorb the punishment he did against the Jets. He’s 41 years old and a little more than two years removed from an Achilles injury.

When asked at his Tuesday news conference if he’s worried about Jones’ confidence, Tomlin didn’t hesitate when he answered.

Advertise with us

“You don’t get to the National Football League by being fragile emotionally,” Tomlin said. “There are a lot of confident guys I work with. You win some battles, you lose some battles and you come back fighting. That’s just the nature of the men who play the game at this level.”

That might be true, but some red flags are being raised by experienced former players when it comes to Jones and whether he can turn it around. Former Steelers offensive line Trai Essex said in an interview on 93.7 The Fan that there were a few plays in the Jets game where it looked like Jones “didn’t belong in the NFL.”

The Steelers do have some options if Jones continues to struggle, but one of them doesn’t appear to be moving right tackle Troy Fautanu.

Fautanu played left tackle at the University of Washington, but Tomlin said last month he wanted to keep Fautanu on the right side of the line because he missed almost all of his rookie season with an injury.

That would leave the Steelers with few options. Calvin Anderson dressed as the swing tackle against the Jets. Anderson has appeared in 50 NFL games and has started 14 times, but none since the 2023 season. Veteran Andrus Peat has 103 career starts, including some at left tackle. Most of his previous experience as a starter has been at guard, however.

Advertise with us

The truth of the matter is the Steelers can’t give up on a former No. 1 pick one week into the season. They’re going to give Jones some time to make adjustments. In the meantime, the Steelers can make some adjustments of their own and help Jones by keeping a tight end or a running back on his side when he’s in a tough matchup like he was on Sunday against Jets edge rusher Will McDonald.

It’s not just Jones. Another concerning issue for the Steelers is the play of the offensive line as a whole. Rodgers was sacked four times and pressured into hurried throws on other occasions. The running game was almost nonexistent.

It wasn’t supposed to be like this.

GM Omar Khan’s first goal after taking over the personnel department was to improve play in the trenches. Jones was his first-ever pick. Fautanu came in last year’s first round, and Zach Frazier and Mason McCormick came in the second and fourth rounds of last year’s draft.

Yet, despite investing so many premium draft resources into the position, the Steelers cannot play the physical brand of football they desire. The Jets front has some good players, including Quinnen Williams, but the Steelers shouldn’t have been bullied to the point they were. Pittsburgh’s running backs averaged just 2.6 yards per carry on Sunday

Advertise with us

Inexperience and youth can only be an excuse for so long.

Eventually, the young Steelers linemen have to start playing to their pedigree.