Welcome to Brian Batko’s Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com.
Bobby B: I know we can’t live paranoid, but it seems like [Harmon] is the only rookie that you might wanna sit in a chippy, battle-to-make-the team preseason game. It could happen at any time, but it sometimes seems like the Steelers tempt the fates.
Brian: No, I’m not going to second-guess Mike Tomlin playing Derrick Harmon too much in that final preseason game. First of all, it’s the dress rehearsal, the last chance for a rookie to acclimate to NFL game speed before the real thing when Justin Fields might sidestep his pass rush and escape for a first down along the right sideline. Second, it wasn’t even the second half yet.
But this is interesting to look at how coaches handled it around the league. Harmon was one of 12 first-round picks who played in the final week of the preseason, though several of those who didn’t are dealing with injuries.
His 16 snaps were fewer than Chiefs tackle Josh Simmons (21), Bears tight end Colston Loveland (20), Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart (20) and Titans quarterback Cam Ward (17), and the same as Saints tackle Kelvin Banks Jr. and Packers receiver Matthew Golden. Number 3 pick Abdul Carter played three snaps for the Giants, No. 5 pick Mason Graham logged only nine snaps, and No. 6 Ashton Jeanty got just four.
In addition to Harmon, Ward, Carter, Jeanty, No. 7 overall pick Armand Membou, Banks, Loveland, No. 20 Jahdae Barron, Dart and Simmons played in every preseason game. It’s fair to say Tomlin was not on an island playing a first-round draft pick well into the preseason. Injuries happen — and I can’t recall anyone telling me before the trip to Carolina that Tomlin better hold out Harmon as a precaution.
Read More
Sean M: Hello Brian. The Steelers rushing attack ranked 11th in the NFL last season at 2,166 total yards and 4.1 yards per rush. Those numbers were helped by 289 and 4.7 from Justin Fields. We keep hearing that a strong running game opens up the pass in Arthur Smith’s offense but the running game has been middling during the playoff victory drought. With a young offensive line and a running back by committee approach, how much can they improve, and what running ranking range is necessary to provide the balanced offensive attack needed to maximize Rodgers and spark a deep playoff run? And do you think that’s possible?
Brian: They were 20th in yards per carry and 29th (!) in the expected points contributed by rushing offense metric. What does that mean? I don’t really know, but it’s from Pro Football Reference, which I trust implicitly, and 29th is not very good.
As pessimistic as it sounds, I tend to agree with the tone of Sean’s question here expressing skepticism that this running game will be vastly improved. What could be the difference is if any of their trio of backs — whether it’s Jaylen Warren, Kaleb Johnson or even Kenneth Gainwell — can break the long one that always eluded Najee Harris, whose long rush last year was 36 yards.
Warren had that 74-yarder in his breakout sophomore campaign, Johnson is a complete unknown at the NFL level, and Gainwell has never had an NFL run longer than 35. While Johnson showed breakaway speed at Iowa, doing it as a pro is a different story, and I also think the coaching staff wants to see him maximize every touch he gets before he can eclipse Warren. Johnson left some yards out there in the preseason, no doubt.
Mike from Iowa: My friends and I out here in Iowa are pleasantly surprised with Yahya. Maybe the Hawkeyes coached him to be more concerned about containing the QB instead of rushing? Maybe it’s Karl Dunbar? Whatever it is, I haven’t seen consistent pass rush like this from him. Based off his scouting reports, I don’t think I’m alone. I know it’s early, but he looks like a future starter. With Cam’s age, that would be huge. Castro is always around the ball and has shown strong tackling. I hope that’s enough for him to make it on ST. I think he’s a PS guy at the worst.
Brian: Sebastian Castro did indeed make the practice squad, and he’ll work hard to contribute on special teams while he waits, but I’m not sure he’ll ever have the range or quickness to be an NFL contributor on defense.
As for Yahya Black, he’s been nothing short of a revelation. He wasn’t on my radar going into the draft other than me thinking “large man, very stout, low ceiling, maybe not a very high floor.” And clearly, I was wrong.
One thing you can’t measure in the draft — or even evaluate on video — is how a player will adapt to life in the NFL, apply himself to the job and adjust to the game. Black is checking all of those boxes thus far.
Jim K: Hi Brian, hoping all is well with you. I'm hearing you were possibly posterized by Dr. Starkey in Shaler. Too funny and hope you get some sort of revenge in the future if I'm reading his comment correctly. Care to elaborate?
Brian: This is a result of Joe Starkey’s mailbag this week. And yes, I must admit, I did not box out Joe when I should have. He sandbags so much about his age, conditioning and rust on the basketball court that I suppose I wasn’t too worried about getting a body on the old newshound.
My belated birthday gift to him will be giving him credit for that tip-in for a game-winner. You could make a poster out of it, but I don’t think anyone would want it on their wall. Here’s hoping Joe makes his way back to the same weekend pick-up crew I’ve been playing with for many years.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.