One of the first big moving-and-shaking events of the NFL pre-draft process took place last week with the college All-Star games.
The East-West Shrine Bowl and Senior Bowl were perhaps closer than ever in terms of their assembled talent this year, and the Steelers had prime representatives at both. The stats from the actual All-Star games themselves are less relevant than the takeaways for coaches and scouts observing practice, considering the growing trend of players “shutting it down” once they checked their evaluation boxes in person.
So with those anecdotes now in the bag, let’s take a spin through my first simulated mock draft of the season. As always, I use one of the industry leaders in fake drafting websites to do this exercise, and for this one, it was Pro Football Network’s. Their rankings looked pretty close to whatever consensus might be building among the draft media, and they have a huge slew of players to choose from. Here’s the class I assembled for the Steelers based on the Pro Football Network mock draft simulator, which does account for some randomness and attempts to assign predictiveness to these endeavors:
Round 1 (No. 21): Emeka Egbuka, Ohio State WR
The Steelers have more glaring holes at defensive line, cornerback and even running back — to say nothing of the “vacant” sign out front of the quarterback room. There are options at receiver, from George Pickens to Calvin Austin III to potentially the emergence of 2024 third-rounder Roman Wilson. Egbuka isn’t necessarily a perfect fit to join that trio, considering he mostly played in the slot for the Buckeyes, but he’s a smart player, a crafty route runner and has good size at 6-foot-1, 202 pounds. Those traits should allow him to play inside or outside in the NFL. Not only does he bring big production from his time in college, but it’d be a nice change of pace for the Steelers to build around a young wideout who doesn’t also bring a bunch of drama.
Emeka Egbuka is the PERFECT slot WR for the modern NFL.
— NFL Draft Files (@NFL_DF) January 14, 2025
He is a cerebral, technical route runner with reliable hands and savvy ball tracking in traffic.
He has a chance to solidify himself as a first round pick in the National Championship vs. Notre Dame. pic.twitter.com/SuF73xwwf9
Round 2 (No. 52): Deone Walker, Kentucky DL
Sure, the 20-year-old Walker might be a bit upright and wasn’t all that impactful last season when he dipped from 7½ sacks as a sophomore to just 1½ as a junior. But if I know Mike Tomlin, he can overlook concerns about hand usage or pad level if you just give him a 6-foot-7, 340-pound ball of clay to mold on his defensive line. Walker is humongous yet still nimble at that size. That should be just the kind of piece to fit between or next to Cam Heyward and Keeanu Benton as they continue to brace for physical battles in the AFC North. Mike Tomlin was spotted chatting him up on the sideline at the Senior Bowl:
Mike Tomlin sharing some words with Deone Walker (Kentucky DT) pic.twitter.com/ePQWq4Afb7
— Jacob Lintner (@lintnermedia) January 29, 2025
Round 3 (No. 83): Jack Nelson, Wisconsin OL
Isaac Seumalo turns 32 next season and certainly doesn't carry himself any younger than that. Broderick Jones has gone from promise to potential question, while Troy Fautanu was injured for almost his entire rookie season. Enter Nelson, a versatile veteran stalwart for the Badgers who has played left tackle for the last three years but started at right guard as a redshirt freshman. He’s 6-foot-7, 310 pounds and allowed just one sack last season, per Pro Football Focus. It doesn’t matter much whether he stays at tackle or becomes a guard in the pros as long as he becomes a starter at some point. It’s hard to go wrong with a Wisconsin offensive lineman.
Read More
#Wisconsin LT Jack Nelson is so underrated@JackNelson755 pic.twitter.com/9f8xkOQ8XB
— Hail Mary Sports (@hailmarysportss) January 18, 2025
Round 4 (No. 121): Trevor Etienne, Georgia RB
Four years ago, the Steelers picked Najee Harris in the first round one spot ahead of Clemson’s Travis Etienne, who arguably has been a better NFL running back when healthy. At the very least, he’s been more of a home run hitter, which is also what his younger brother has been both at Florida and Georgia. Now the Steelers can go to the same gene pool for a ball carrier who had the fastest recorded time at his position on the first day of Senior Bowl practices. A bigger back to pair with Jaylen Warren might be preferable, but Etienne has a quick first step and good long speed for an offense that needs more of it. Maybe Warren can become more of the grinder Harris was.
Trevor Etienne of @UGAAthletics puts in an exceptional move on @AuburnFootball’s @_JayRashaan in RB v LB 1v1’s. #TheDraftStartsInMOBILE pic.twitter.com/DMybqSveYN
— Jackson Gross (@JGrossBucks) January 28, 2025
Round 5 (No. 162): Jermari Harris, Iowa CB
Harris spent six years at a place now known for producing quality defensive backs in addition to defensive linemen and linebackers. He’s 6-foot-1, 190 pounds and has eight interceptions since 2021 — including three last year — so he has a nose for the ball, too. The idea would be to see if he can beat out Cory Trice Jr. and/or any outside cornerbacks added in free agency.
💥 JERMARI HARRIS 💥 #Hawkeyes pic.twitter.com/Ai5mShUQ5f
— Cody Hills (@ByCodyHills) October 26, 2024
Round 7a (No. 224): Tyler Shough, Louisville QB
Why not throw another dart at quarterback, particularly one who drew rave reviews in Mobile? He might end up going significantly higher because he’s 6-foot-5, 225 pounds and threw for 3,195 yards, 23 touchdowns and just six interceptions last year. But he’s also turning 26 in late September and spent six seasons across three schools (Oregon and Texas Tech, too).
Louisville’s Tyler Shough with some wicked ball placement on this throw to Virginia Tech’s Jaylin Lane. This might have been the best throw of Day 1 at the Senior Bowl. pic.twitter.com/sO2nlY0jLW
— Bobby Football (@Rob__Paul) January 29, 2025
Round 7b (No. 230): Rylie Mills, Notre Dame DL
Why not throw another dart at the front line? His 6-foot-5, 295-pound frame is the same as Cam Heyward’s, and he might slip because of a season-ending knee injury sustained in the first round of the playoffs. But he had 7½ sacks to that point in the year.
Huge play from veteran Rylie Mills pic.twitter.com/e2aWP0OQS1
— Kevin Sinclair (@KevinSinclair_) September 28, 2024
Round 7c (No. 246): Carson Bruener, Washington LB
The son of former Steelers tight end Mark Bruener, who’s now a scout for the team, this would be a fantastic moment for dad and kid. But it’s not just a sentimental pick. The younger Bruener can play. He was third-team All-Big Ten with 104 tackles, three interceptions and five pass breakups, career highs across the board. If nothing else, he should be a special teams ace.
Hit stick from Carson Bruener 😤pic.twitter.com/BGkVIADtwI
— Cam Mellor (@CamMellor) October 28, 2023




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.