Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome and let's get started.
Tom: How realistic is it to have Super Bowl expectations every year? In the end the Steelers had the same or one less playoff victory than the best team in the league and their division winner. Playing devil's advocate, is 1 win worth potentially falling into the abyss of losing and the yearly coaching carousel change?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think it's a matter of getting on the coaching carousel or not. The Steelers have conviction on Mike Tomlin. I think it's more a matter keeping a core together and hoping you win and tearing it down and rebuilding with better draft assets. It's a worthy conversation to have even if the Rooneys never commit to a total rebuild. Any seasons with losing records tend to happen organically.
Tom: Would this roster (or as projected for next year) have the potential to win playoff games if a new coach was brought in?
Ray Fittipaldo: That's a tough question to answer. I'll say this: I don't think they would necessarily fall apart and go 3-14 if Tomlin left. I think the current roster is probably as bad as those teams in 2012 and 2013 when the Steelers went 8-8. Those were two tough seasons, but the Steelers came out of it well. They made the playoff four consecutive years from 2014-17. The one caveat: That turnaround happened when Ben Roethlisberger was in his prime. The Steelers don't have their franchise QB now. So their current situation might actually be worse when you factor in the QB.
William Wallace: Which Tomlin stubborness has hurt the Steelers more....believing NFL pedigree came from families and drafted accordingly (Bush, Edmunds etc), fierce loyalty to in-house promotions (Canada, Austin, etc), using only a bellcow back (with Blount, D. Williams, Warren mostly riding the pine), refusal to use FA/backups who then quit (Blount, Harrison, Ingram, etc), breeding ultra diva receivers (too many to list!)
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: Diva receivers are everywhere in the NFL so I won't hang that on Tomlin alone although he does have some major issues with how he's handled them. If I had to pick from the other choices I'd say the drafting or the in-house promotions. The Canada thing was pretty ridiculous. They pretty much wasted three years with him as the OC.
William Wallace: How crazy is it to believe we had Super Bowl caliber years with running backs duos of Bell and DeAngelo Williams and Bell and Blount, but Tomlin decided never to use them abd to only use Bell. But this year we have a 42 year old 3rd string Cordarelle Patterson and Tomlin uses him consistently in some of the most crucial 3rd down this season!?
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin actually used Williams more than you think. He was a good backup. He filled in really well when Bell was injured in 2015. Every team in the NFL uses two running backs now, but you're right about Patterson. The Steelers didn't need to use him as much as they did. I'm taking an educated guess that was an Arthur Smith decision more than Tomlin. Patterson was with Smith in Atlanta.
Linebacker Lounge: Any idea what assistant coaches contracts have expired?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'd be guessing, but we know Tom Arth and Zach Azzani have another year left. They just came onboard last year and it's standard for assistants to have at least two years on their deals when they sign them. Pat Meyer also has a year left as does Teryl Austin. Arthur Smith likely has two years left because coordinators usually get a standard three-year deal when they are hired. So that would leave positions like DL (Karl Dunbar), Denzel Martin (OLB), Aaron Curry (ILB), Eddie Faulkner (RB) and Alfredo Roberts (TE). And I'm not sure about Danny Smith either. The special teams had a good year so unless he retired I doubt Tomlin would want to make a change there.
Sam: Hi Ray...The QB history in the AFC this century is wild in terms of who actually has a shot. Ben vs. Sanchez in Jan. 2011 is the last time the conference championship has been played without Brady or Mahomes. So essentially the entire rest of the conference has been playing for 1 spot for a decade and a half. The only way you're going to elbow your way in is by either cracking some code inside of Fields (not likely) or trying to crack the code, stinking (more likely), and then finding a guy who can compete via the draft. Time to stop trying to be simply compete for a playoff spot with non-losing seasons and actually get a grip on the landscape of things.
Ray Fittipaldo: I tend to agree with you, but you don't want to tank. You want to build up your roster in other areas so when you do get your QB you hit the ground running and compete right way. In other words, the QB is the last piece to add. You don't want to get so bad that when you do get your QB you're wasting good years with a bad supporting cast.
Linebacker Lounge: MT mentioned soft tissue injuries in post game presser. But there was just a change in strength and conditions coaches last year. What’s your take on that comment?
Ray Fittipaldo: That that could be one of the coaching changes he makes. I also found it interesting that he mentioned that. The most prominent soft tissue injury, of course, came when his starting QB injured his calf in a conditioning test. That could get you fired.
Linebacker Lounge: How would you assess the job done by LB coaches Martin and Curry? Recently been thru Butler, Porter and Jerry-O. Are we any better today?
Ray Fittipaldo: The production is down for the OLBs, but I don't know if I pin that on Martin. Same goes for ILBs. Does a position coach really make that much of a difference? I think there are certain positions where it's really important such as offensive line, but other positions it's less important.
Linebacker Lounge: Is the team today better than one year ago coming off the loss to Buffalo with Rudolph? Better, Worse, Same or other? Thanks
Ray Fittipaldo: A little worse only because the defensive core is getting older.
ForWhomKordellTolls: If Pickens is traded for another WR who are the likely targets?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think it's more likely he's traded for a draft pick.
Brian: It now seems obvious that the Steelers won't be making any staff changes (unfortunately). Other than trading GP and cutting Larry O, what "big changes" might we expect.
Ray Fittipaldo: Some assistants will go. They just haven't been announced or leaked out yet. As far as major moves go, maybe Tomlin can get one of the coaches who doesn't land a head coaching job. The Browns added Mike Vrabel last year as a consultant. The Steelers should do that this year with some coaches who are currently out of a job.
Life's Work: Ray, thank you for the time and chat. Enjoyed your article about who to sign, cut, or trade. Agree with just about everyone you listed. Would you also consider Leal and Waitman on the cut/trade list? Either Waitman or Johnston will move on but are they going to give Leal another year? Will they shop either on the trade market to gauge interest? If they could get a pick for Leal, regardless of round, it’s better than keeping him in my opinion. Thanks.
Ray Fittipaldo: Leal is on a cheap rookie deal so I think they'll keep them. I don't think they could even get a late pick for him to be honest. As for Waitman, as long as Johnston comes back he'll be expendable. He did a pretty good job after Johnston was injured.
Life's Work: Hi Ray. I was listening to a sports talk show this morning talk about the positive changes the Commanders have gone through in 1 year. They said that Magic Johnson (minority owner) hired the right people and let them do their job and that’s a major reason for their success. Validity of a minority owner having that responsibility aside, made me think of how the Steelers have operated during my lifetime. Ownership hired a coach (Noll, Cowher, Tomlin) they believed in and let them do their job. In turn, Noll and Cowher hired coordinators they believed in and let them do their jobs. This seems to be the big issue with Tomlin. Will Art be asked at his press conference if he will tell Tomlin that if he believes he’s hired the right DC, he needs to stop meddling in the defense and let the DC do his job. If TA is not the right DC, he needs to hire the right one to run the defense, because that is how this franchise has built success? There’s nearly a decade of proof that the current set up does not work.
Ray Fittipaldo: Most of the time Art Rooney lets Tomlin choose his staff. A couple of outliers: when Bruce Arians "retired" and when Matt Canada was fired. It doesn't happen every year.
Brian: It has been floated by one of your colleagues that Tomlin wants Broderick Jones to take his job more seriously. Every game I've seen he seems to play with appropriate effort and intensity, always says the right things in the press, and I haven't heard of any knucklehead behavior. Could you elaborate on this issue?
Ray Fittipaldo: Jones is still young. He makes mental mistakes such as the one in the playoff game when he pulled on a play when he wasn't supposed to pull. You can't have that. I think overall it's just becoming a better pro, knowing how to train in the offseason, take care of yourself in-season, etc. It's a bunch of little things that add up.
Life's Work: Should we take the silence over the past week and a half as an indication that little is going to change?
Ray Fittipaldo: No there will be some changes. Just not the changes many are hoping for.
Commissioner: At 26 years old next season, I believe Justin Fields should be the starting quarterback to find out if he can be the player we all hope he is. If he isn’t and they have a disastrous season, the reward may be Arch Manning in the 2026 draft held in Pittsburgh. One terrible season for 15-20 years of having a franchise quarterback is a trade I’d make all day long.
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think that's a bad idea.
Life's Work: Most of the talk about this team has been negative. What are the positives that you see in this team. Thank you.
Ray Fittipaldo: Some young OL such as Frazier and Fautanu should be cornerstones to build on. Jayen Warren should get better with more opportunities. The OLBs are good and Payton Wilson makes the ILB room stronger. Other than that there's not a whole lot to be excited about.
Ray in Bradenton: Hi Ray. Wow, the teams that played this past weekend are so much better than our Stillers. They need help at DL, WR, CB, better play at TE, and assuming Fields is resigned, a young QB to groom like the guy we saw last night from OSU. Not to mention a reset of the coaching staff. Did I miss anything?
Ray Fittipaldo: Nope.
Mike from Erie,PA: Hi Ray, At what point do we consider that it might be the SCHEMES that CoachT uses for the Defense ?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think that should be studied over the offseason. And they'll do that. I do think they need some fresh ideas. And Tomlin said he was open to that.
Steeltown: I read that Moore (12) and Jones (11) were the only NFL O-lineman to give up double digit sacks. I hope we release Moore, and do you think that Jones moving back to the left side will help his numbers?
Ray Fittipaldo: Moore is a free agent. And yes, Jones is going to move to the left side. Be careful when people cite sacks for offensive linemen. Sometimes running backs are supposed to help, or a protection call is missed, and they're held responsible. Who is responsible for sacks is debatable and oftentimes linemen get blamed when they shouldn't.
Steeltown: Hi Ray, Why don't the Steelers (and every other team for that matter), do the tush push when we need a yard? Seems virtually unstoppable, yet we trot out Russ (not even Justin) to do a traditional qb sneak...makes no sense!
Ray Fittipaldo: If Justin Fields is the QB in 2025 I would have him take every snap this spring and summer from under center so he can get comfortable there. They don't do traditional sneaks with Fields all that often because he never took snaps from under center in college. It's a real problem across the NFL. He needs to learn how to do that and feel comfortable doing it if he's asked. I agree with your premise. Even if the Steelers have to get a TE to take a snap and get pushed forward, do it! The Ravens do it with Mark Andrews. To me it's like stealing, and the Steelers don't even try to mimic these other teams. It should be an offseason emphasis.
Stan P: Are we at the point of the offseason where it's safe to say that if any staff changes were going to happen, they'd have happened by now?
Ray Fittipaldo: No.
Hammering Hank: Even though Riley Leonard didn’t have a great game last night, like his athleticism, running ability, awareness, toughness, needs work on arm strength and pass footwork. I’m thinking good late round choice?
Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe, but arm strength and passing ability are prerequisites to play in the NFL. He's not going to line up under center and run 10 times like he did last night on the first drive of the game.
APK: Can we please cut out the talk of tanking to get better draft picks?? The fans who advocate that know nothing about the Steelers.
Beer_baron: Any inside scoop on a possible Dublin game?
Ray Fittipaldo: Gerry Dulac reported it's happening a few weeks ago. The NFL announced a game in Berlin last week so I'm guessing the Ireland game is announced in the next week or two.
Steeler Nut: Would you spend a 3rd rounder on a guy like Will Howard? Winner, great size, mobile and has played in many pressure situations. Some scouts compare him to Mason Rudolph, but I think he is far more dynamic as a play-maker
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think he's worth a third-round pick, but QBs are pushed up draft boards all the time so who knows where he'll go?
ATLsteelerFAN: good morning Ray. The way I see it, the Steelers have 2 “elite” players and one of them is Boswell. Would you agree, slightly agree, disagree or slightly disagree with my analysis? Thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: I'd add Watt as an elite player. I assume you were already counting Heyward. (And he's 36!). Some of their young players could develop into that type of player, but they're not there yet.
APK: Do you think Fields is capable of being a franchise QB?
Ray Fittipaldo: Probably not, but find out in 2025.
Ben: Hey Ray, after watching the Steelers lose to playoff teams 4 of their last 5 games and then watching this past weekend of football, I don’t think they’ve made very good decisions on the talent front. When you look at players not on a rookie contract, who among their roster would other teams want at the price the Steelers are paying? Watt, Bosworth, maybe queen, Elliot… Who else? Thanks -
Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe Frazier. Payton Wilson looks like a good young player. But you're right. They need more young talent. That's for sure.
Hi Ray -: What do you think about Minka's contract vs his play? For many, he is an iconic part of the team, but the business is what it is. Would they ever approach him to restructure - or is that off-limits?
Ray Fittipaldo: The way he's been deployed he's not worth the contract, but they'd have to eat $15 million in dead money if they cut him. They don't typically do that.
Hi Ray -: One thing I was thinking about during my ongoing depression of another season with our JV Coach, Mike Tomlin, was if a new staff was brought in and they were a 4-3 scheme, not a 3-4 scheme, how much upheaval would that cause to the roster? That seems like a multi-year transition and would raise fundamental questions about Watt and Highsmith.
Ray Fittipaldo: NFL teams are only in base defenses maybe 25-30% of the time. There would be a transition for sure, but a good coach could incorporate good players into any scheme.
Linebacker Lounge: Would like to see them bring back Skowronek. Feel he and Robinson are key ST’s players. 93 seems to be very good against the run, but assuming he struggles with past coverage? What say you
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree on both counts although Robinson just might be a special teams player only. And that's OK. He can make a living doing it if he excels at it.
Yinzer Stuck in Crabby MD: Ray, do you have any predictions on if the Steelers will get any compensatory picks? Would love to see them use a mid round pick on a qb that falls just to have some little glimmer of hope (for the future) while watching the offense move like a WWII Italian tank this fall. Wish they had taken Jordan Travis in 24.
Ray Fittipaldo: They are not projected to have one according to the sites that track that stuff.
Tampa Too: Ray. What is your best guess as to who the starting quarterback will be for the Pittsburgh Steelers next year?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think they've decided yet, but if I had to guess I'd say Fields.
Grahambo: Ray, the options for Steelers QB seem very limited. There isn’t any obvious choice that we should trade up to get. I think we go with Fields and focus on building out rest of the team. Appreciate your thoughts! Grahambo
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree. Build up other positions on the roster and get your QB when you can get a good one. Just don't get one for the sake of getting one.
Hi Ray -: Is Fautanu better suited for guard? Save some $ with Seumalo and play him at LG. Sign a true RT in FA?
Ray Fittipaldo: I won't rule that out, but he excelled at tackle until he got injured.
Jim: Would you keep Moore and cut Jones? Jones doesn't seem to be playing all out when you watch him.
Ray Fittipaldo: No. Jones is younger and has more upside.
Jim: Do we need a pounder to pair with Warren or a scat back? I think we need speed, couldn't believe Smith kept trying to run sweeps with the slow footed Najee. Didn't look good for him or the OC.
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think they need a pounder. I think you can add a back with speed and maybe another one for short-yardage situations.
Jay: Great job this year Ray. Not a question, just an observation. Every Ravens position group except maybe edge rusher are better than the Steelers. Thanks.
Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for reading Jay!
DaquidoBazzini: When looking at the tape from the Ravens playoff loss, what grade would you give the Steelers for overall effort?
Ray Fittipaldo: I try not to question the effort of professionals all that often, but there were a few plays in that game that opened my eyes.
Linebacker Lounge: Player that was biggest positive surprise this season ___. Player that you expected more from ___.
Ray Fittipaldo: Payton Wilson and Keeanu Benton.
Ray Fittipaldo: Benton is s good young player, but I was expecting a little more from him as a pass rusher.
Turk in MD: What do you think Omar can get in return for a Pickens trade? 2nd rounder?
Ray Fittipaldo: That's be great, but more likely a third-rounder.
Tim: To use a Tomlinism, is it absolutely necessary for the Steelers to make a few splash plays in free agency to improve this roster? What areas might that occur and in what order of urgency. Thx Ray for your continued excellent coverage and insight
Ray Fittipaldo: WR and DL. And they should draft at each position high too.
Pistol33: Ewers, Dart or Howard?? Think they take a swing at one of these guys in the draft day 2?
Ray Fittipaldo: If I had to choose among those three I'd probably lean Ewers, but whoever it is they have to be a threat in the running game as well.
The Robber: Dear Art Rooney II, Last year the Washington Commanders finished their season with 4 wins. There was only one NFL franchise with fewer wins. They hired a new General Manager. They hired a new Head Coach. They drafted then started a rookie Quarterback. This weekend the Commanders will play in the NFC Conference Championship game. All change is not progress. But there can be no progress without change.
Sincerely, Every Fan of Your Pittsburgh Steelers p.s. please re-establish your goal as a Lombardi Trophy; your goal can't simply be "stability" nor can your goal be "a non-losing record"
Ray Fittipaldo: You forgot to mention they had the No. 2 pick and got Jayden Daniels. QB is a big missing piece for the Steelers and yu don't usually get good ones at No. 21 in the draft.
TVC15: Since Big Ben threw the pick-6 in the Super Bowl loss to the Packers the Steelers have 3 playoff wins. Did Tomlin waste Big Ben's prime years?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, they underachieved from 2011-2018.
Eddie in Howey: Thoughts on Steelers drafting Tyler Warren if still available at #21? Big talented wr/TE, can be used as short yardage "push tush" person.
Ray Fittipaldo: I would do it in a heartbeat.
Bud: Hello Ray. Do you think Fields is a better fit for what OC Smith would like to do than Russell?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes.
Bones in Iowa: Did Jones right the ship later in the season or was Moore so bad we lost focus on Jones? And is McCormick quality depth or quality starter in year 2?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they're hoping McCormick is a quality starter, but I need to see more.
IL Steel: I've been a Steelers fan since 1971, and I've never seen the fan base so frustrated and angry. We just keep doing the same things on offense and defense every year, and there are no playoff wins. Does Rooney sense the outrage? If so, what's he willing to do?
Ray Fittipaldo: He has to sense it. I agree with you. This is as angry a fan base as I can ever remember. As far as what he's willing to do we'll see. He's expected to do his season-ending interview before the end of the month.
Bud: Hello Ray. Why is OG Daniels assumed to be gone? Would he be that expensive? McCormick isn’t much above average in my opinion, and should be a depth piece.
Ray Fittipaldo: If he's healthy, he'll get $15 million a year or thereabouts.
Gene: Do you think they bring back Cam Sutton ?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure yet, but I thought he was a disappointment.
Lou: Ray what’s your fav guy as potential top draft pick for Steelers?
Ray Fittipaldo: Mock draft No. 1 dropping on Sunday in print and online!
Ray Fittipaldo: And on that teaser we'll wrap up this week's chat. Let's do it again next Tuesday.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.