It was just 35 days ago the Steelers put up 44 points, 520 yards offense and 28 first downs in a victory in Cincinnati, their highest totals in six years.
But the formula that produced those totals was apparently not good enough to attempt to replicate when the same teams met just five games later.
On a cold Saturday night in January, the only thing more chilling than the Steelers’ 19-17 loss to the Bengals was the decision to scrap a game plan that was so successful last month in favor of the one that was miserably on display at Acrisure Stadium.
Now, after ending the regular season with four consecutive losses for the first time in 25 years, the Steelers will face the Ravens at Baltimore’s M&T Bank Stadium in a wild card playoff game.
In a span of five games, they went from having the most points, total yards and passing yards since 2018 to having the second-fewest total yards and rushing yards of the season.
“It didn’t work out the way we would like,” Tomlin said.
Read More
Puzzling?
It should be.
Coaches often like to compare preparing a game plan to a chess match, trying to out-think the opponent and stay one step ahead of whatever they have planned for you.
That being the case, label this “checkmate.”
The first indication this was going to be a different approach came early in the week when Tomlin, at his weekly news conference, said the Bengals defense was not the same defense the Steelers faced five weeks earlier.
He cited the 12 takeaways the Bengals had in the four games since that 44-38 defeat in Cincinnati, never mind that six came against the Tennessee Titans, who rank 31st in the league with 33 turnovers. Five others came against the Cleveland Browns (three), who rank last in giveaways, and the Dallas Cowboys (two), who are 25th.
Suddenly, it was as though he was comparing the Bengals defense, which ranked 29th in yards and 27th in points, to the 1976 Steelers.
“Those are some of the things that are going on on defense that really have our attention,” Tomlin said.
What should have had his attention is what happened Dec. 1 in Cincinnati — the most points, total yards and passing yards (414) they’ve had in six years. And they did it by throwing from the time they got off the team bus. Russell Wilson threw on the first five plays, six of the first seven and nine of the first 11, right up to throwing a 17-yard catch-and-run touchdown to receiver George Pickens.
He ended up with the second-most passing yards of his career (414) and three touchdowns. He even out-dueled Joe Burrow, who passed for 309 yards and three touchdowns.
Apparently, Tomlin didn’t think the Steelers could do that again.
Instead, they devised a game plan to run the ball. They were determined to flip the totals from the previous meeting when they dropped back to pass 40 times and ran 26 times. The idea was to keep the ball away from Burrow, even though it didn’t make a lot of sense when they won the coin flip and decided to give him the ball anyway to start the game.
In his postgame comments, Tomlin indicated the game plan was “appropriate for this environment,” which was believed to be referring to the 19-degree temperature at kickoff. The Bengals, obviously, didn’t think so.
Burrow attempted 46 passes, completing 37 for 277 yards. While the defense held the Pro Bowl quarterback under multiple touchdown throws for only the fourth time this season, it nonetheless showed the Bengals weren’t going to change from what they do well. Meanwhile backup running back Khalil Herbert, who was subbing for injured Chase Brown, rushed for 69 yards on 20 carries.
Which, by the way, was more than Najee Harris (36) and Jaylen Warren (21) combined to have against a Bengals run defense that ranked 24th in the league.
The Steelers were so intent on establishing their running game that, with the exception of the two-minute offense at the end of the half, they were 12 for 12 running on first down until they fell behind 19-7 in the fourth quarter. Up to that point, Wilson had attempted just 12 passes, completing five for 51 yards.
“We’ve got to be effective on first down, give ourselves a chance on third down, and whatever that is, I think we’ve got to be able to do that,” Wilson said. “That's a key part of the game is, obviously, being great on first and second down, getting ourselves a third down, and when we get our third downs, converting them.”
They seemed to have the right formula 35 days ago in Cincinnati. But, apparently, that wasn’t good enough Saturday night.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.