Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome and let's get started.
Dan: Hey Ray, thanks for the chat, always enjoy your insights. My question is about the QB situation. If Wilson has a solid year and we extend him, where does that leave Fields? Do you think he’ll be willing to re-sign if he knows he’s still backing up Wilson or will he be looking to go elsewhere? I’d love to be able to keep both QBs, but not sure how we can make that happen, thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: If Wilson plays well and the Steelers have success with him at QB then Fields likely will be elsewhere in 2025. However, if Fields wants some security beyond this season and believes he has a long-term opportunity here he can sign a short-term deal. Would he take the Trubisky contract? He played for $8 million a year or a little more.
Yogi in Jersey: What is the percentage of likelihood that Holcomb ever plays for the Steelers again? Such a shame. That is one snake-bitten position for this team.
Ray Fittipaldo: Hard to say right now. He's not doing anything on the field right now. But the Steelers made moves this offseason to play without Holcomb. They signed Patrick Queen and drafted Payton Wilson.
artie bridge: Ray, do you think our receiving corps is as weak as the buzz suggests?
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: After George Pickens there isn't a lot of recent success. So yes I'd say it's not a strong group at this point.
Steelbeav: Hi Ray, Nice work! The Steelers may actually have a top 3 defense if CAM bounces back and everyone stays healthy, especially if Cam Sutton avoids suspension and signs with Steelers. The pressure we will put on QBs without having to blitz (send 5 + guys) coupled with press coverage should cause carnage
Ray Fittipaldo: That's a lot of ifs. Obviously, Heyward's health is a big factor. How he comes back this year will be big because I have questions about the talent and depth behind Heyward.
Steelbeav: Which tackle do you think would be rated higher by the Steelers if both came out in the same draft? This years number 1 or last years first round pick.
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they were graded fairly close coming out. I think Jones is more of a prototypical left tackle while Fautanu played left tackle in college but can play pretty much anywhere on the line. Not that Jones isn't versatile. He played very well at right tackle for most of last season.
J D: Ray, if 1st round QBs are predominantly starting from day one, why shouldn’t first round tackles? Can they play any worse than Moore?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think Fautanu has a good chance to start early. He'll have to play well in camp once the pads come on and obviously in the preseason games, but I'm not convinced he'll have to sit as long as Jones did.
Polevetsian Dance No. 2 by Borodin: The Steelers seem obsessed with moving O-Lineman from their best/ natural position to another? More definition of insanity.It's one thing to love 'flexibility' but another to try to force it. In he 2023 National Championship, Penix' failure/ beat-down, especially late, wasn't on Fautanu, iirc, but I'd have to watch the whole game again. Now we have Jones telling rookies "you're going to get beat, you're going to lose" & that's leadership? He couldn't even secure the alleged position they drafted him to play. So... Sorry for the long way around the barn to ask; Why not have Fautanu play his natural position LT & keep Jones at Right where he seemed to learn at least one or two things, as he puts it. Is the fact that Penix was a lefty really that important? Heck, even the foul mouthed, fan hating, so called O-Line guru your colleague, Batko, interviewed pointed out the pathological trait of changing these guys positions of strength.
Ray Fittipaldo: Your entire premise is wrong. Jones playing on the right side was directly related to Dan Moore not being able to play on that side. Right or wrong, the Steelers coaches made the decision that Okorafor came out of the lineup rather than Moore. And you're reading way too much into what Jones said. His point was you have to have the mentality that you'll bounce back if you are beaten. Every player in the NFL loses reps during games. The idea is to win more than you lose and to learn from your mistakes.
Yogi in Jersey: What's your prediction on who will lead the team in tackles this year?
Ray Fittipaldo: My early guess is Patrick Queen.
SteelersSince72: Hi Ray, your thoughts on pros and cons of bringing back JuJu? TY
Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers need a legit No. 2 WR. If this was 2017 or 2018 I'd say OK. But this is 2024 and JuJu hasn't been that guy for quite some time.
KPD: I don’t understand Hayward’s stance? Hasn’t been healthy for 3 years and should be dancing a jig for the compensation he is getting. If he wants out, I say grant his wish and sign younger talent with the money saved!
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not sure what you're talking about. Heyward played all 17 games in 2021 and 2022 and was productive. I don't think the Steelers should give him any new guarantees in a new deal, but let's get the facts straight.
TVC15: Hi Ray, Will the Steelers ever contend for another Super Bowl under Tomlin?
Ray Fittipaldo: All depends on what you mean by contend? Does that mean getting to another conference championship game? Getting to another Super Bowl? Sure, I think that can happen, but with this core it better happen soon because this team's stars are aging. Heyward and Watt only have so many years left.
fredward: Hi Ray, how will Justin Jefferson's mega deal affect Pickens' future contract negotiations?
Ray Fittipaldo: Well, I don't view Pickens in the same light as Jefferson, but every mega contract has a ripple effect on the position.
Peavy: Hey Ray. What do you think the Steelers would have to give up in a trade for Aiyuk as opposed to Samuel? Thanks.
Ray Fittipaldo: A second-round pick maybe. But again -- and I always say this when I am asked about a potential trade -- the Steelers have to feel comfortable with the long-term deal with Aiyuk. I wouldn't be a big fan of renting him for one year and letting him go to free agency.
King Kahn Artist: Who snaps the ball opening day? Thank you, Sir.
Ray Fittipaldo: Zach Frazier as long as he plays well in camp and the preseason games.
Yogi in Jersey: It feels like just a matter of time before Peterson returns to the team They could certainly use his leadership if nothing else. Is the hold up on his end or the Steelers"?
Ray Fittipaldo: If the Steelers sign Cam Sutton I don't think Peterson comes back because he wouldn't have a big role. Your backups have to be able to play special teams. I think Peterson has a chance to come back if he's the starting slot/subpackage defender, but I think the Steelers have to decide on Sutton first.
DaquidoBazzini: Hi Ray- Any updates on who might be Bill Hillgrove’s replacement announcer wise?
Ray Fittipaldo: No but I would imagine they'll want someone in place by training camp.
TVC15: "All depends on what you mean by contend? Does that mean getting to another conference championship game?" --- I kind of mean at least not getting blown out by halftime in the first round. Even a close conference championship game loss would qualify.
Ray Fittipaldo: Then sure.
King Kahn Artist: Is everyone going to show up for mandatory Mini camp? And possible holdouts or hold-ins? Thanks.
Ray Fittipaldo: Most players are now advised to hold in rather than hold out. So a hold in is much more likely for someone like Heyward.
mrbig: why the resurgence of wr trade talks? WHat changed after June 1?
Ray Fittipaldo: You mean trade speculation among the fan base? The Steelers are evaluating guys like Van Jefferson and Scotty Miller and Quez Watkins and Roman Wilson now. They'll make a move if they believe they have to after minicamp or sometime during training camp/preseason.
Al from Bethel Park: I see a lot of talk complaining about the tough schedule toward the of the season. I see this differently. A lot of younger Steelers will be better by then, so the team will be a lot stronger. Those fearsome opponents should get ready for some fear of playing the Steelers.
Ray Fittipaldo: That's certainly another way to look at it. You might be right in terms of the young Steelers coming along, but unless all of those teams are dealing with major injuries to their stars it's going to be a demanding stretch for the Steelers.
Justin: While I feel we do need a second receiver, I believe cornerback is just as important. If you had to venture a guess, will the Steelers sign a cornerback and if so, will it be Sutton / Peterson or someone else like a Howard or Jackson?
Ray Fittipaldo: My guess is Sutton or Peterson. I think they'll sign Sutton if his legal issues are dealt with and the commissioner doesn't give him a long suspension.
Benson DuBois: D-Line depth is a more critical need than #2 receiver. Do you agree?
Ray Fittipaldo: How about good D-line play overall? I know that hinges on Heyward's ability to bounce back, but there wasn't much production without him last season.
Guest: Hey Ray. I’ve heard many fans and commentators remark on Najee Harris’s decent production (3 1000-yd seasons) and relative lack of big, explosive plays. My head acknowledges these points as valid, but then my heart weighs in with something not captured by the stats: Najee plays his heart out. He fights for extra yardage nearly every time he touches the ball. He’s a warrior who has time and again put his body on the line, and a sometimes-inspiration to his teammates. If you were Omar Kahn, what weight would you give factors like these when (and if) a contract extension becomes a live issue again?
Ray Fittipaldo: I just think it's a business decision. The Steelers didn't believe he was worth the $7 million option in 2025. If he plays well in Smith's offense maybe they'll value him at $12 million over two years or $18 million over three years. I don't know what number the Steelers would feel comfortable with, but it's obviously not anything at $7 million a year on average.
Ray Fittipaldo: Porter, Jackson on the outside, TBD in slot and Fitzpatrick and Elliott at safety.
Timmer: As of now, who do you see starting at cornerback and safety? Thanks Ray.
Ray Fittipaldo: Question to last answer.
Fuamatu Ma'afala: Hey Ray, are guys like Xavien Howard and Justin Simmons too expensive, or just not good fits for the Steelers defense?
Ray Fittipaldo: Too expensive. They signed Elliott and traded for Jackson. Jackson is making $6 million in salary this year. Elliott signed for $6 million over two years. Both are much cheaper than Howard or Simmons.
Joe: Ed Reed or Troy P. Who was the better safety?
Ray Fittipaldo: Troy Polamlau.
Zell: For RB's, 1,100 yards rushing in a 17 game season is 65 yards per game. I love Naj and he's a tough guy, team player, and so on. Just a comment
Ray Fittipaldo: Understood, but he has been durable. That's important.
Ray Fittipaldo: Ok thanks for all the questions this week. I have to get to practice. We'll do it again next Tuesday.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.