Welcome to Brian Batko’s Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions for occasional offseason mailbags to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com.

Alan F: If you were the GM, how would you improve the QB room? Other than Mason, who would you bring in to really compete against Pickett for QB1?

Brian: This time two years ago, we were having a similar conversation about free agent options at quarterback. Much of it was centered around Mitch Trubisky, of course. But other names such as Marcus Mariota, Jameis Winston, Andy Dalton, Teddy Bridgewater and Jacoby Brissett were mentioned, too.

Now we’re talking about the quarterback market again, in large part because the Trubisky move didn't pan out and he can't even be trusted to be the backup here now. So, let’s take a look at who’s slated to be out there next month when the new year begins ...

Advertise with us

Russell Wilson technically isn’t available yet. Kirk Cousins and Baker Mayfield probably are too high-profile and high-priced. Ryan Tannehill has the obvious link to new offensive coordinator Arthur Smith from their days together in Tennessee. Tyrod Taylor has played for just about every city in the NFL, so why not Pittsburgh? Gardner Minshew could've been a yinzer. Sam Darnold would be like Trubisky 2.0. Tyler Huntley is a bit intriguing. Josh Dobbs is a familiar face. Joe Flacco and Carson Wentz would be weird. Drew Lock and Easton Stick don't do much for me. And Brissett and Winston are back out there, too.

It’s no wonder the Steelers have a stated interest in continuing to do business with Mason Rudolph. He doesn’t look like a bad candidate at all compared to the field of free agents.

Sean M: With all the Fields speculation I went back and watched his 2023 highlights. I was shocked to see most of his passes… including the successful ones were wobblers. A limited sample size for sure but when your highlight reel is loaded with wobblers, and tight spirals are the exception, it worries me. Of course, he looked great when he ran. I am concerned he is little more than a more athletic version of Kenny Pickett. It would be one thing if he was a free agent, but I would be reluctant to give up players or picks to roll the dice with another middling QB. Thoughts on why the JF hysteria?

Brian: We do the pipe dream QB thing every offseason now, don’t we? In years past, I seem to remember the likes of Kyler Murray, Russell Wilson, Aaron Rodgers, Deshaun Watson and surely several others I can’t think of at the moment.

That’s life with a team that doesn't have a clear-cut No. 1 quarterback. But it is a bit exhausting.

Advertise with us

This latest round of Justin Fields chatter has solid reasoning behind it. Pickett hasn’t been particularly good, Fields had the Steelers’ interest coming out of college, and the Bears appear poised to reset their rebuild and go in a different direction.

While I don’t see it happening, mainly because of the concerns you lay out — basically, if you’re going to detonate the Pickett era, do it for someone with more of a track record than Fields — I did step back and take notice of Louis Riddick’s comments Wednesday morning on ESPN. He’s as big of a Pickett believer as anyone I’ve spoken to in the national media, dating back to that 2022 draft, and even Riddick said he’d prefer Fields to his fellow Pitt product. Riddick is someone whose football opinion I value, and I think he tends to be more measured than hyperbolic.

Marc from Germany: I played o-line on an amateur level here in Germany for more than ten years. I know that even the division 1 and 2 teams I played on here couldn't realistically hold a candle to even a tiny college program in the USA.

But I think I understand the game and on almost all of the teams I played on with great chemistry from HC down to third stringers we severely played above our actual talent level. Does that still apply in the NFL? How do you build that? Do the Steelers have that?

Brian: It applies. But I would say it doesn't nearly matter as much as talent, coaching and injury luck.

Advertise with us

Just this season, the Chiefs had a significant distraction when star defensive lineman Chris Jones was holding out and actually hinted at retirement before missing Week 1. He didn’t give in and show up to camp in the name of team chemistry.

You generally don’t see a team overachieving at this level because they all get along well in the locker room. This past season, the Saints struck me as a team that had a lot of veteran leadership, buy-in to a longtime member of their coaching staff and a kumbaya kind of guy at quarterback in Derek Carr. They had their share of dysfunction and finished 9-8, missing the playoffs.

Maybe more often, you see stacked teams that lose focus and let individualism get in the way. I don’t think I’d say that about the current Steelers, but I do wonder how much the Antonio Brown, Le’Veon Bell and Ben Roethlisberger clashes may have held them back in what were supposed to be their prime years. And you hope that the big personalities on the offense now don’t lead to unfulfilled potential.

Ed B: It actually has nothing to do with the Steelers but, I've been seeing a lot of posts online about Patrick Mahomes being the top five quarterback all time. I think that's kind of crazy to say right now. What is your opinion on this? Thank you and have a great weekend

Brian: Full disclosure, Ed sent me this prior to the latest Super Bowl win for Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs. As with any subjective ranking, it sort of depends on your criteria, right? Longevity, height of powers and pure talent/eye test are factors to varying degrees.

Advertise with us

But if you go by rings, he’s already tied for fourth all time. If you go by passer rating, he’s second only to Aaron Rodgers by a tenth of a decimal point — and first in the postseason. Career passing yards per game, he’s ahead of No. 2 Drew Brees by 16 yards.

It’s not crazy to already put him with the class of Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, Joe Montana, John Elway, Dan Marino, Johnny Unitas and whomever else consistently populates top-five lists. For most of those guys, all they have on Mahomes is longer-term success, but even if he walked away right now for whatever reason, that wouldn’t take away from his greatness in my eyes.

Franky Z: By my cap reckoning there are 2-4 players that are probably on the list to be released, 2 of the big 3 will be reworked. Is that your take/feeling ?

Brian: If we take Ray Fittipaldo’s annual cut-or-keep analysis as our baseline, the Steelers have already released three of his seven projected cap casualties, the other four being Patrick Peterson, Allen Robinson, Damontae Kazee and Mason Cole. Robinson seems like a foregone conclusion, so I’m a bit surprised he wasn’t among the Monday round of moves.

I’m not as convinced on Peterson, Kazee or Cole. Larry Ogunjobi and Keanu Neal should be on shaky ground, too, in my view. Like Okorafor, Trubisky and Robinson, the likes of Peterson, Cole and Ogunjobi have roster bonuses in their contracts, so decisions must be made on them sooner than later.

When it comes to the safeties, both are in their late 20s/early 30s, so I expect at least one to be gone, if not both. Trenton Thompson is a younger, cheaper in-house replacement even before assessing the free agency and draft pools. All in all, I assume the first three cuts were just the most obvious and that there are more to come, with any of those six possible.