What the Steelers did last offseason with their inside linebackers was unusual. They made a clean sweep at the position, saying goodbye to Devin Bush and Robert Spillane in free agency and releasing Myles Jack with a year left on his contact.
For Steelers general manager Omar Khan, it was a bold move that had to be followed up with some shrewd signings, and he responded by rebuilding the unit with free agents Cole Holcomb, Elandon Roberts and Kwon Alexander.
For the first half of the 2023 season, it appeared the Steelers had finally solved their years-long struggles at the position. All three were playing well and creating turnovers, something Bush, Spillane and Jack infamously failed to do even once in 2022.
And then, in the span of 10 days, the good-time vibes were over.
Holcomb, who was the team’s leading tackler through the first eight games of the season, suffered a season-ending knee injury in the Nov. 2 victory against the Titans. On Nov. 12, Alexander suffered a season-ending Achilles injury in a victory against the Packers.
Roberts remained a catalyst, but losing Holcomb and Alexander proved to be challenging to say the least in the second half of the season.
Read More
The last thing Khan wanted to do this offseason was rebuild the inside linebacker room again, but there is a lot of uncertainty given the extent of the injuries.
“We were getting better production from that group — ball production, forced fumbles, turnovers, interceptions,” coach Mike Tomlin said. “But the attrition component was a treacherous thing to navigate. And so we’ve got some decisions to make around that position, particularly, but the health factor was significant.”
In a best-case scenario, Holcomb might be ready by September. That would be a 10-month recovery from a knee surgery that Tomlin described as “serious” in nature. Holcomb politely declined an interview request the day after the Steelers lost to the Bills in an AFC wild card game.
“He has a target date in terms of readiness there, but it's still probably early [to speculate],” Tomlin said. “I'll have a more definitive posture on that probably when we get closer to OTAs and we start speculating about some of those things then.”
Tomlin’s rather vague answer casts some doubt on Holcomb’s timetable. Even if the Steelers are confident Holcomb can return at some point in 2024, they need to find Roberts a partner until that happens, or in the event of a setback in his rehabilitation.
Holcomb is under contract, but Alexander is an unrestricted free agent. The Steelers have to determine if it’s worth re-signing him. He’ll turn 30 in August and has a long and varied injury history.
The only thing that seems certain at this point is the return of Roberts, who was stellar after signing a two-year, $7 million deal last March. He led the Steelers in tackles and became an instant leader in the locker room.
Roberts will count $4.6 million against the cap in 2024, but that’s well worth it considering the uncertainty surrounding Holcomb and Alexander.
Pressure on Leal
The defensive line doesn’t have the injury concerns of the inside linebackers, but the Steelers need some of their younger players to play better, most notably DeMarvin Leal.
Leal, a third-round draft pick in 2022, was a healthy scratch in six games after he started four times early in the season when Cam Heyward was on injured reserve. Eventually, Leal lost his spot in the rotation to Armon Watts and Isaiahh Loudermilk.
When the Steelers drafted Leal, they touted his versatility, but he’s had a hard time finding his niche in their defensive scheme. He’s athletic enough to play outside linebacker and did so as a rookie when T.J. Watt was on injured reserve. The Steelers had him play exclusively on the defensive line this season, and he did not impress.
Tomlin said there is a path for Leal to contribute in 2024.
“There certainly is, but he's got to be a component of that,” Tomlin said. “Obviously, we put helmets on guys that we think are best positioned to help us secure victory, and he hadn't been a component of that. And so he's got some work to do.”
Reporting for training camp in shape will be a good first step for Leal. The rest is up to Tomlin and his coaching staff as they try to identify which role suits him best.
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.