Ray Fittipaldo: Good morning, let's get the chat started.

Mats: Hello Ray, how many Steelers should be traded, Moore?Pickens? Johnson? Okafour (sorry for the spelling)? Tomlin? and what would be their draft value, thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, there isn't going to be much of a market for Okorafor or Moore. I just think you'll see the Steelers walk away from Okorafor and absorb the dead cap hit for 2024. No one would take on that contact. I don't think Moore has much value either going into the final year of his rookie deal. He's cheap, but he only plays left tackle. Teams would just rather draft guys unless someone is really desperate. Now, the WRs are a different story. Johnson is making $7 million in salary next season and a $3 million roster bonus. So $10 for a good No. 2 receiver isn't bad. I'd say a third-round pick would be good return for Johnson. Pickens? That's more difficult to say. He comes with baggage, but some team might be willing to trade a third or a fourth to see if they can get more out of him. And by the way, you can't trade or cut the entire team! I know that's the knee-jerk reaction after a three-game losing streak, but they have to field a team in 2024.

Retire21: Ray...who's your most disappointing Steeler? Mine might be a surprise....Mitch Trubisky. Flacco comes off his New Jersey couch and lights it up. Dobbs was what they wanted for a while, an immediate infusion...I know he tailed off, The butcher, the BAKER, the candlestick maker.......

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: My how times have changed. In August, we were all saying the Steelers had the best backup situation in the league. I would agree Trubisky was disappointing in his two starts, but I think the entire offense from Pickett to Johnson and Pickens and Najee, all of them have been disappointing to me. The only player on offense who has been consistently good is Jaylen Warren.

Joe: Before all the good chat times ... thanks for the chats, Ray (& P-G staff) and happy holidays. :)

Now, my question. In Zeise's column today he said Najee doesn't want to be in Pittsburgh anymore. You can't speak for Zeise, so I'm not asking you to. But in your interactions with Najee, have you gotten that vibe?

Ray Fittipaldo: I see frustration in Najee, but I don't jump to the conclusion that he doesn't want to be here. By the way, the Steelers could make that call for him. I don't see how they pick up the fifth-year option on his rookie deal when he's not even the best running back on the team.

Joe: The OL had a string of games where they looked like bullies. Now they're the ones getting bodied. What happened?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: The coaches will tell you the running game hasn't gotten going the past few games because of the poor third-down conversion numbers. There is some truth to that, but there's much more to it. This group isn't good enough to impose their will on people and run whenever they want. And the pass pro has been fairly spotty too in that same time frame. You know what that means? Probably another pick in the first few rounds to help rebuild it. They got Broderick Jones this year. Now they need a center and probably a right tackle in either the draft or free agency this year. It's been a disappointing season in a lot of ways for the line. I think it's clear they need to add better players.

Retire21: Will it be a festive, almost Christmas Eve crowd with a lot of kids Saturday. Or will they be ready to cascade the boos?

Ray Fittipaldo: Probably a mix. Lots of people selling their tickets. I know that.

Ray Fittipaldo: Or giving them away.

Sal: Do you think a WR coach like Hines Ward can change the culture on those young WR's ?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I think it would help, but the culture is set and enforced by the players first and foremost. There's only so much assistant coaches can do. But I can tell you, I wouldn't be against it.

Guest: did you agree with the refs on JPJ's interference penalty before halftime? thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: I didn't have a big problem with the call.

Joe: Let's say that the Steelers don't want to throw in the towel for the season. What steps can they realistically take at this point to at least possibly salvage their pride?

Ray Fittipaldo: Changing the QB is the only move that might make an impact. And that's why Tomlin is making the move. Everything else is merely rearranging the deck furniture on the Titanic.

Advertise with us

zeisechris@yahoo.com: Ray, Miles Boykin plays well on ST and seems willing to do whatever it takes to succeed. Why not start him over Pickens, (for a quarter or even a half), tell Boykin to play receiver like he plays ST and make GP stand next to HCMT and watch how a PROFESSIONAL football player conducts himself.

Ray Fittipaldo: That's all well and good but Boykin wouldn't even line up correctly a couple of games ago. He was responsible for one of those illegal formation penalties. I'm not against sitting Pickens for a quarter. I think a lot of former players would applaud the move. Maybe even some in that locker room. But how about just playing Calvin Austin more? Or bring someone up from the practice squad? Reward someone who is working hard who wants to play in the NFL. That energy might be good for the team too.

Billiken Bill: Ray - Thanks for the chats. Unlikely to happen, but if MT is traded or goes by agreement or choice, wouldn't you as the owner or GM of a team interested in him be skeptical given his inability to assemble a NFL caliber staff? And his unwillingness to make adjustments to game plans in real time, his trending record of poor draft choices and his record of enabling?

Ray Fittipaldo: No they wouldn't be deterred by that. He has a good track record overall. Some of these teams that will be searching for head coaches would kill for a 9-8 season.

Youth Over Experience?: Has another head coach ever lost to three first year coaches in the same season? I can’t imagine that has happened before. That seems hard to do.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Let me call the Elias Sports Bureau on that. And I bet it has happened before.

Yates: Hi Ray- If 8 is unable to go on Saturday does he play in remaining games if healthy but Steelers out of contention?

Ray Fittipaldo: If Pickett is cleared by doctors he'll play in Seattle and/or Baltimore.

Team Divided: Tomlin said he had a good meeting with Pickens last week. Then he stood and didn’t block on one play, and he ran away from the defender and straight to the sideline after the interception. That’s two more strikes against a guy that already had 5-6 strikes. There has been no significant punishment yet. Don’t consequences usually follow actions? Why has Tomlin always let his skill players skate on infractions such as these?

Ray Fittipaldo: Likely because there is a big drop-off in talent from Pickens to whoever they'd decide to replace him with.

Advertise with us

Hall of Shame?: Tomlin gets lauded as a future Hall of Fame coach mostly because of his regular season winning percentage and the fact he won a Super Bowl. He has many obvious flaws (clock management, team discipline, fundamentals, postseason droughts, slow starts, poor game planning, weak coaching staffs, etc.), but the Super Bowl and never having a losing season seem to trump those. Tomlin’s career winning percentage is right around 0.63. You know who else has a career winning percentage around that? Barry Switzer and George Seifert. Both won Super Bowls and took over for Hall of Fame coaches. Tomlin is very comparable to both, but they are never talked about as future Hall of Famers. Why the big difference?

Ray Fittipaldo: Probably because Tomlin coached for much longer as an HC in one city than the other of those guys you mentioned. Switzer was an NFL coach for only four seasons. Seifert was the 49ers' HC for eight years and then four more in Carolina. That's the difference. Longevity.

Ron: Hey Ray...who has the best and worst chances of 'under contract individuals' on the offense being gone next year of: WR Johnson, WR Pickens, HC Tomlin, OC Cole, RT Chuks, RB Harris, QB Trubiski?

Ray Fittipaldo: Chucks is gone. Could definitely see them moving on from Trubisky too and probably Cole. Harris likely finishes out his Steelers career in 2024. You never know how a player will handle not being given the option, but I think he's back.

Colonel: I've always assumed that ARII isn't nearly as involved in the "nuts and bolts' of running the team as his father was. What is the likelihood of him actually stepping in and forcing drastic changes in the upcoming off season? I don't believe that Mike Tomlin would ever be fired but how extreme could the off-season changes be? Thanks for the chats.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I think you're going to see a lot of changes this offseason. They won't stand pat after another poor finish to the season.

Joe: Lost among all the terrible news (and there's plenty), I'd like to point out Elandon Roberts has been a man despite being beat up.

Ray Fittipaldo: Wholeheartedly agree. He's a keeper.

Joe: Pat P. and Allen Robinson would be almost $17m in cap savings against $4.8 in dead money. I can't see them back. But Cole would be a substantial cap savings, as would Diontae, Chucks and even James Daniels. Of those I mentioned ... any you would guess are no longer in the black and gold?

Ray Fittipaldo: Chuks won't be back and probably not Cole either.

Advertise with us

Steeltown: Hi Ray, we certainly may be having a different conversation if Alexander, Holcomb, Minkha, and Kenny not been injured. I suspect we would have won 1-2 of these recent losses. It is what it is, so what now. I do think wr, qb and ol should be the priorities in this upcoming draft, but feel for the most part that the other positions are in decent shape. Your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: They need to draft a WR high and an OL in the first few rounds for sure. They also need to use a high pick on a DL. It doesn't look like Leal is a future starter. They might have to draft two DL.

RJT: Ray I don’t think it’s very likely the Steelers make the playoffs but as a fan I’m always hopeful until they’re officially eliminated. Will they get in if they go 10-7 or are the tie breaking losses to the Texans and colts too much to overcome?

Ray Fittipaldo: Hard to say, but if they win their next three the New York Times postseason simulator puts their chances at over 90%.

Guest: Happy Holidays Ray. Did you see QB Drew Lock leading his running back Kenneth Walker with blocks 20+ yards downfield and giving his teammates 100% effort last night on MNF? We rarely, if ever, see this type of effort from DJ or GP on any running play, and more regularly on passing plays that they don't believe they will receive the pass on. Is this just a difference in cultures between teams or is their no accountability between the Steelers and their offensive teammates as it appears? It is so apparent that they have no fear of accountability from their coaches with their continual lack of effort..

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: It's definitely all about the culture in the locker room. I know for a fact former Steelers players hate what they are witnessing.

Guest: Hello Ray. I really enjoy your work. Seems like the Steelers have been exposed these last three weeks. Feels like we are nowhere near the top teams in the AFC. Considering all the offensive woes this year, do you feel the issues are due more to scheme/coaching or talent and can you explain your answer?

Ray Fittipaldo: The offensive scheme is terrible. That's a big part of it. But Tomlin mentioned yesterday they're not seeing the development they thought they would with some players. Want to speculate? Pickett and Pickens some readily to mind.

SteelersSLC: I know it's unlikely they're gonna draft QB in round one this year but if say a guy like Bo Nix happens to falls to them in the second do they pass on him? Or if they end up with a top 10-12 pick do they go for one of the top guys?

Ray Fittipaldo: If they have a chance to get a top guy in Round 1 they have to go for it. But I don't think they'll be in the top 10-12. They'll be somewhere from 13-18 I think. The Eagles got Jalen Hurts in the second round. The 49ers got Brock Purdy in the seventh round. You just have to find the right guy for your scheme. (Hopefully, the Steelers get an NFL scheme in 2024).

Advertise with us

Sunner in Orlando from Lebo from Lebo: I attribute most of the defensive problems on losing Holcomb and Alexander for the season as our run D and covering backs and tight ends in the past month has been terrible! Didn't help that Minkah and Cam have lost significant time as well. Agree?

Ray Fittipaldo: Sure, but every team has injuries. The Colts beat the Steelers with their backup QB. They lost their best WR in the first half. And they were down to their third- and fourth-string RBs by the second quarter. And they scored 30 unanswered points to blow out the Steelers. Good teams find ways to overcome injuries. Bad teams use them as an excuse.

DaquidoBazzini: Hi Ray- The Steelers DL really looked bad last weekend in Indy. What happened to Leal in his 2nd year, and do you think this is the end of the road for Cam Heyward?

Ray Fittipaldo: Heyward has a $22 million cap hit next season. That's a huge number for someone who hasn't produced after his injury this season. Unfortunately, Father Time gets everyone.

Jimmy: I believe it was Gerry who said that after Adrian Klemm quit the next O Line coach hire was very important for Tomlin to get right. Seeing Dotson have success with the Rams on the right side and the OL play the past few seasons, did he get the right coach for the job?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not convinced that he has.

Hi Ray -: All things considered, I think you need to give Kenny one more year with "varsity" coaching. Can that happen with Tomlin here? We've seen the results in Boston where an untouchable coach with a massive ego is given free reign - despite the outcomes. Simply said, time to clean house and start over?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think you'll see them clean house, but I'm not sure if Tomlin will be a part of the house cleaning.

Fishagain: If the team doesn't have inside linebackers who can do the job, doesn't it make sense to change what the inside linebackers do ? Or to change the defensive scheme so that only one is needed ?

Ray Fittipaldo: Ding, ding. You got it. They have to simplify what they're doing.

Advertise with us

Tom: Kazee - seems his suspension for rest of the season is a bit harsh? Yes very hard hit but didn't hit with helmet or launch. If anything QB put Pittman in a horrible spot with the bad throw\decision. Also Pittman launched himself into the defender technically. Alternative was to let Pittman catch it and touch him down conceding a reception.

Ray Fittipaldo: I agree. The NFL has to start reviewing rejections. The game moves too fast for the on-field officials. Kazze was suspended for his history. As far as this hit goes, he tried to do the right thing, but any time a defenseless player is struck in the head it's going to be a flag. We're in a time when letting the WR catch the ball and tagging him down is the play the league wants to see made. I think it's sad for the NFL that it's come to this. I understand it. They were sued and had to fork over nearly $1 billion to former players in the concussion settlement. They have lawyers advising them on these hits. Real people who know football aren't involved much in the process.

Tom: Any Chance the NFL will look into banning flops like the NBA has. Some of Big Name players are doing this more and more lately. its football you are going to get hit. Josh Allen who is a monster has been doing it along with Mahommes and Kelce - its a disgrace.

Ray Fittipaldo: Why can't the referee just tell them to get their butts up and play football?

Steve: Hi Ray, help me understand what Tomlin's reasoning is to not bench George Pickens to start the game? Last night Pete Carrol benches Riq Woolen for the first quarter, he's a far more productive NFL player than George Pickens.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know what Woolen did, but I can tell you a lot of former players would applaud Tomlin if he would do that.

Art: Ray, thank you for the time and the chat. This team seems like it has enough talent that it should be in the playoffs and fighting for a top seed given the state of the AFC this season. Am I overestimating the quality of this roster?

Ray Fittipaldo: If everyone stayed healthy? Sure. But we've seen their depth hasn't been good enough at a few spots. That's part of roster building too.

Mr Rooney: The tush push again reared its head on MNF for the Eagles. Still looks like dangerous and anti-player safety to me. Should the NFL let this play stand or is it gone come 2024 season?

Ray Fittipaldo: Roger Goodell said they're still looking at it. I want to know why other teams can't have the success the Eagles do. It's a copycat league and no one else can do it as well as they do. Maybe it's because Jason Kelce gains the first down he ever snaps the ball. Ha ha.

Advertise with us

Bill: Ray - thanks for your fantastic after game report cards. You are always right on the money and we really appreciate it. And love the new grade "Zzzzz" for coaching at the Indy game! Keep up the great work!

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks Bill!

James Ryan: Hey Ray. Thanks for the chats. I personally do not think ARII will move on from Tomlin yet (he should). However, do you foresee them finally stepping in and hiring the OC similar to Haley?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes. They won't let Tomlin make this hire. I think they'll give him the freedom to make the hire, but only through a list of their preferred candidates.

GM for the Day: I know Dulac says we need to draft a DL in 1st rd next year and I agree. But I’m seeing several mock drafts that only have one DL in the 1st rd. If that is the case, shouldn’t we go after a talented OT in the 1st rd to pair with Broderick Jones and then draft a Center if there is a good one in Rd 2 or 3?

Ray Fittipaldo: I wouldn't mind that, but they need to find DL somewhere. Maybe they'll spend big in free agency to do that if it's a weak draft class.

Dan: Hey Ray love the chats and the articles. I’m really hoping we don’t just bring in someone to compete with Pickett this offseason, but rather a franchise QB to replace him. Do you think free agency or the draft is our best bet? And are there any big names predicted to be available in free agency?

Ray Fittipaldo: Is Baker Mayfield a big name? You might be watching him in the playoffs. The only problem is he's going to want to cash in after the season he's had. So wherever he goes and gets paid he's going to be the starter.

Richard: Ray, There are 3 things that the FO did that will hurt this team for years. 1. Hiring Canada. 2. Picking Kenny. Sub par assistant coaches. Also MT’s stubbornness to control all aspects of the team. Mr Rooney seems to be aloof and living in yesterday’s success and not the present and future direction of the NFL. It is an offense driven league and you need to adjust to that. Would you agree? Thank you.

Ray Fittipaldo: I agree on the Canada thing. Good head coaches hire talented coaches who want to advance in their careers. We haven't seen that with Tomlin.

Mike: If they bring back Tomlin on a prove it year without a contract extension, doesn't the OC position become fairly unappealing?

Ray Fittipaldo: Of course. That's the problem with having a lame duck head coach.

Yates: Humor your chat followers. If offense had exact same players but every player had the “want to” of #30, how many more wins would we have?

Ray Fittipaldo: More than they have now.

Gregg from Shaler: Did MT explain his thought process on punting vs letting Boswell kick a 56 yarder indoors? It’s not like we have Ray Guy punting! Borderline territory but if you’re placing faith on a player it’s gotta be Boswell in that situation.

Ray Fittipaldo: He's tried, but in my opinion his explanations don't make any sense.

Beer_baron: Will Harvin be gone next year, or even before then?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think Harvin will be back.

Ray Fittipaldo: Ok thanks for taking part in the chat today. We'll do it again next Tuesday.