They weren’t stars. But for a few moments once upon a time they were bright enough to write themselves into Western Pennsylvania sports lore — cult heroes — only to as quickly fade into the mists of history. About and of them we will ask in this Sunday series: Where Yinz Now?
CHARLOTTE, N.C. — Seated outside on a front patio with his close friends, Corey Fenton twisted off the top of another IC Light while splitting his attention between a television hanging over the doorway and the parking lot to his left.
Like any other Sunday, Fenton, a Bellevue resident, was deeply invested in his Steelers, who were on the screen facing the Los Angeles Rams. But the Steelers game was only part of the reason that Fenton, along with most others, made their way to the Charlotte bar that afternoon. In addition to watching the game, those in attendance were also there to interact with one of the bar’s operating partners, Jeff Reed.
Since retiring from football in 2011, Reed, the Steelers’ starting kicker from 2002 to 2010, has tried his hand in many different areas of work. From selling cars to attempting to start his own podcast, Reed hasn’t been opposed to different career opportunities.
Last November, Reed was approached by a pair of financiers with a new idea — a sports bar with a theme focused on both North Carolina and Pittsburgh. After signing, Reed and his two business partners agreed to rebrand what was once a soccer pub into what is now known as “Carolina Steel,” which represents his connection to both the Tar Heels — his alma mater — and the NFL franchise he spent the bulk of his career with.

As over a hundred Steeler fans watched the Steelers battle for four quarters against the Rams, their servers bounced from table to table wearing Reed’s No. 3 jersey. The man who once donned that uniform on the North Shore, however, spent most of his time doing work behind the scenes.
“Hey, there he is,” exclaimed one fan as Reed appeared out of his white SUV, lugging a few large bags of ice from the parking lot to the bar’s kitchen.
“I wonder if he’ll have time for a selfie,” said another patron to her friend as they watched Reed hurry to the bar’s maintenance closet to grab a broom to fix up a spill.
Between tasks, Reed indeed found time to interact with Steeler fans. While he wasn’t around to celebrate the Steelers kneeling the clock out on their 24-17 road victory, the frequent customers knew if they stuck around long enough, they’d be able to interact with him once the game day crowd died down.
Since he signed on last year, Reed has worn many hats for the restaurant. Known as the “face of the place,” part of his job involves regular appearances on local television and radio stations, where he promotes his establishment.
On the weekends, Reed takes on, as one server described, a “Swiss Army knife” role. From cooking, cleaning and serving food and drinks to entertaining customers, Reed has shown up an hour before opening each day on the weekend, ready to assist in any area needed.
“There are times where I think, ‘What am I doing? Let me get out of here, please,’” Reed recalled to the Post-Gazette later that evening. “There have been times where we had cooks walk out, so I had to cook. I can cook, but I’m not a chef for a restaurant. But it seemed like everybody was happy during those 13 hours for three days that I cooked.”
Reed’s investment in the establishment can’t be overstated. In addition to his work at the bar, he’s also heavily involved in the customer experience. Reed reflected upon a four-hour meeting with his partners where they completely remodeled Carolina Steel’s menu.
“If my name is going to be on something or my face, we can’t have frozen chicken fingers, frozen burgers, a bunch of crap,” Reed said. “If I don’t want to eat it, why would I serve it — 90% of our menu is fresh, homemade stuff.”
While fans watched the MLB playoffs and the games remaining on the NFL slate, some sat and enjoyed food items modeled after some of Reed’s favorite dishes from when he lived and played in Pittsburgh. From long-time classics such as pepperoni rolls and fried bologna to tributes to specific Pittsburgh restaurants such as Peppi’s or Primanti Brothers, Reed said Carolina Steel’s goal is to give “yinzers a taste of home.”
During his nine seasons in the NFL, Reed faced plenty of challenges. There were games with poor weather conditions, injuries, and a few incidents off the field. And just like he worked through those obstacles as an athlete, Reed said he has learned to overcome all hurdles thrown his way in his new line of work.
“It’s an industry that I have a whole new appreciation for,” Reed said. “I have a new respect for cooks and bartenders and everyone else involved. This is hard work, but hopefully, it will be worth it.”
Reed expressed to the Post-Gazette numerous times that Carolina Steel’s success won’t come overnight. Unlike football, where big money comes when one signs on with a team, a payout in the restaurant industry takes years to come to fruition, if it is to take place at all.
But Reed explained the money is only part of his enjoyment with his new career. Although the tasks that come with running a bar are tedious, all are worth it during the short moments he has interacting with life-long Steeler fans who want nothing more than an ounce of his time.
“I appreciate their business,” Reed said. “I understand that, sure, they’re coming here to watch the Steelers, but another reason they’re coming here is because a former Steelers is an operating partner of the bar. That’s a pretty cool thing.
“Sometimes I butt heads with the organization over past things, but the fans make me want to run out of that tunnel one more time. I know that won’t ever happen again, which is hard to accept because you just love that feeling.”
Noah Hiles: nhiles@post-gazette.com and Twitter @_NoahHiles






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.