Matt Canada couldn’t remember whether Kenny Pickett had a penchant for fourth-quarter comebacks when he was a fresh-faced, floppy-haired high school recruit from the Jersey Shore. But Fred Stengel certainly can.
Stengel was recently unretired and in his first season as the offensive coordinator at Ocean Township High School in Oakhurst, N.J., when Pickett’s late-game legacy began. It was the second game of Pickett’s sophomore year, his first season as the starting quarterback, and his Spartans were tied at 14 with nearby Wall High School with 2:28 left. That’s when the kid looking for his first varsity victory connected with wide receiver Marcus Blackmon for a 64-yard touchdown pass that stood up as the winning score.
“We called for all vertical routes, and Marcus is a mismatch with his speed,” a 16-year-old Pickett told the Asbury Park Press. “He broke open and made the catch and made a great play.”
But for Stengel, it was a furious finish the following season that he remembers most vividly from his three years at Ocean Township — in case you haven’t noticed, the sustained success never comes right away for Kenny Pickett.
In true Pickett fashion, he completed his up-and-down sophomore campaign with a fourth-quarter rally in the finale to finish 5-6 but on a high note.
With that as a springboard, his team was 6-1 going into a late-October matchup with perennial power Red Bank Catholic. Stengel was still relatively new to the program but knew it hadn’t beaten “RBC” in quite a while.
“We’re a Group 3 public school, they’re a Group 4 Catholic school, and I don't think Ocean had beaten them in — I don't know, 10, 15 years, something like that,” Stengel recalled by phone Thursday. “We had worked all season long on 2-minute drill and all that kind of stuff.”
Sure enough, Pickett encountered just that situation on the road that week. He entered the fourth quarter trailing 35-27, tossed an 81-yard touchdown to tie it, then got the ball back with the chance to be the hero.
Pickett led an 81-yard drive sparked by a 46-yard screen pass and some damage he did on the ground himself, capped by a 1-yard sneak for the win with less than 30 seconds left.
“He went out there and ran the whole damn thing by himself,” Stengel remembered. “The only thing that upset me was we scored too fast.”
Eight years later, Mike Tomlin is raving about Pickett’s ability to “rise up” in those moments, while the Steelers fan base frets about whether the clutch gene is a real thing, and if so, can it be converted into a full 60 minutes of a complete performance. That remains to be seen, but what almost seems undeniable now is Pickett’s mystique as a closer.
Of his 12 NFL wins, half have featured comebacks in the fourth quarter. Whether that’s an innate skill or one that’s been developed since before he had a driver’s license, that’s tough to answer. But at this point, it’s probably not beginner’s luck.
“When we get to the fourth quarter, are things heightened?” asked Canada to no one in particular. “I don’t know. We just don't want to be in that position to have to come back and win, but we're going to do whatever we can to win.”
In that sense, it’s a good thing they have Pickett, whose numbers are that of a garden-variety mediocre quarterback — until you get to the final 15 minutes. Pickett’s completion percentage (72.7), passing yards (421), passer rating (108.2) and yards per attempt (9.6) in the fourth are markedly better than his numbers in every other quarter. For the season, he’s completing 61.3% of his passes with an 81.6 rating and 6.5 yards per attempt.
Consistency eludes him otherwise, especially in first halves, and he seems to be getting tired of discussing it. But whether it was his high school exploits or his roller-coaster of a career at Pitt, Pickett’s been living in this realm for a long time, which could help explain why he does thrive in the end — if he and his teammates play well enough to get there.
“Kenny’s just always been a resilient person,” said Steelers practice squad running back Qadree Ollison, Pickett’s teammate for two years in college. “He’s tough as nails, and I think one of his best abilities is being able to move on to the next play or the next drive, forget what happened before.”
Is an entire city also forgetting what happened before? Pickett finished his freshman year at Pitt with a bang, upsetting No. 2-ranked Miami as a consolation for a season that ended there at 5-7. He wasn’t entirely responsible for that losing record, but he provided hope for the future once he took the reins full-time.
That hope did not translate to immediate success throughout a rocky sophomore season that was decent enough to win the ACC Coastal title but fizzled with three consecutive losses. That slide, coupled with his own documented struggles, cast doubt on whether Pickett was the long-term solution under center.
“I think, honestly, his time at Pitt molded him for the NFL,” Ollison suggested. “Because at Pitt, we were always in close games, tight games, and a lot of times we’d kind of end up short. But in the league, the majority of those games tend to come down to those last-minute drives or those four-minute drives.”
Even as he skidded, Pickett’s head coach and teammates pounded the table for him anyway, which should sound fairly similar — right down to criticism of the offensive coordinator being inextricably linked to the performance of the quarterback. Back at Pitt, it was Shawn Watson. Ironically, it’s now the play-caller Watson was hired to replace for the Panthers: Matt Canada.
You likely know by now that once Watson was out and Mark Whipple came in, Pickett’s growth toward his fifth-year breakout took root. In 2019, he engineered three fourth-quarter comebacks, two more than the year prior. In 2020, he threw for 400-plus yards in two of his nine starts. And in 2021, he finished third in the Heisman Trophy race while cementing himself as a first-round prospect.
That’s not to say he’ll follow the same trajectory with the Steelers. The NFL is littered with quarterbacks who were prolific in college but not in the pros. The college ranks are filled with players who were the best in their high school, city or county but can’t make it at the next level.
But as Tomlin would surely assert, Pickett’s story is still being written.
The question is whether we’re now in the second act, with rising action and more to come, or in the third, with a main character whose limited arc simply can’t be drawn out much longer.
One person who has read each chapter along the way is Stengel, who laughed when he was asked if he and Pickett still keep in touch here and there.
“No,” Stengel said, “Not here and there. Every week during the football season I talk to him.”
They go back and forth via text, like any old ball coach and one of his favorite pupils would do. As Stengel follows the Pickett discourse and the weekly referendums on whether No. 8 is a franchise quarterback, he feels grateful that his former quarterback has such an even temperament and knows how to deal with the constant scrutiny.
Yes, he’s been through this. As for whether he comes through it again, Stengel of course believes that the phenomenon of “Comeback Kenny” is more foreshadowing than a red herring.
“That is just an example of who the kid is, how much he enjoys competition and how much he enjoys being in the position to help the team win,” Stengel said. “He never shirks away from that responsibility. Matter of fact, I just think he relishes it and enjoys it. That’s who he is. It’s just that simple.”
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.