Gerry Dulac: Ok kids, we're going to start in just a few minutes....

Gerry Dulac: OK here we go....

Dwight: Good morning. It seems like signing Zac Gentry off of the Bengal’s practice squad is a no brainer given the injuries and the perceived “lack of physicality” with this team. Why do you think this hasn’t happened?

Gerry Dulac: You would think and, to be honest, not sure why it hasn't happened. They need a TE on the 53-man roster. Darnell Washington is the only one. Connor Heyward is not a TE

Advertise with us

Brendan: Do you think it is time to play Joey Porter Jr? If so who would you replace? Also is there a reason why our corners do not play more press coverage?

Gerry Dulac: Yeah, because they are not capable. But Porter is, which is why he should be playing and use Patrick Peterson the way you initially intended -- in nickel, in dime, at safety; some spot where he is playing with his eyes in the backfield.

Charlie from Sugartown: Good morning Gerry. Watched very little of the Houston game since it wasn't on locally in Phila. Only saw r

Charlie from Sugartown: Is it me or simply the steelers offense has no week to week strategy?

Gerry Dulac: I know it seems that way, but, believe it or not, they have a different strategy and game plan every week. Hard to think, huh?

Advertise with us

Yates: Hi Gerry- Do you think the following is what happened in off-season between AR and MT? MT remained steadfast in his support of Canada. AR had serious doubts. AR left decision up to MT but told him if repeat of prior year both of them would be gone?

Gerry Dulac: No I don't, but I will say this -- Art Rooney II lets his head coach make all staff decisions, almost without fail. I say 'almost' because at some point, probably after the season, there will be more than a discussion if this continues. And, don't worry, Mike Tomlin won't be the one who is gone

Indiana Fan: Is it possible that the downfall of our defense is related to the puked offense under MC? I’m assuming our defense isn’t being significantly challenged during practices.

Gerry Dulac: Of course it is. I'm not giving them a pass, but the defense is on the field A LOT because of all the three-and-outs by the offense. At some point, that is as demoralizing as it is fatiguing.

Tomlin the Politician: Tomlin said yesterday that we lost the game because we weren’t tough enough. We have been soft for years. We used to be a tough, physical team but not anymore. He never mentioned preparation, game plan, or play calling. Did he believe those were acceptable? Is it ego that won’t let him admit his faults or take accountability? Or is it just plain incompetence?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: He did mention preparation. He said the short weeks with prime time games kept him from putting the pads on in practice, something coaches at least like to do once a week early in the season. So they will put them on today

Substandard: Tomlin annually underachieves and his team is soft. This was never the Steelers Way but now it is. How is this acceptable to Art II? Does he not care about winning and is he just happy making a profit? He seems like Nutting but at least Nutting changes up his front office and staff. Not to mention the Pirates players show more heart, effort, and desire than Tomlin’s players.

Gerry Dulac: Congrats! That might be the first time someone compared the Steelers and Pirates and ranked the Pirates' approach, heart and effort ahead of the Steelers.

Alan: The worst thing a team can do with a new QB is to give him no protection. Shame on that and they had the whole off season to fix that problem. This appears to have sucked the life out Kenny Pickett's game. He's not the big guy like Ben, Terry or Josh Allen. He's competitive though. Would it be better to bench him and let him watch Trubisky fight for his job? Bty, Harris ran all over the field in Tuscaloosa b/c he had HOLES.

Gerry Dulac: And maybe sometimes that protection breaks down because the QB is not sure where to go with the ball. Or, as what happened on that fourth-and-1, he rolled right toward the pressure.

Advertise with us

Indiana Fan: Thank You for doing these chats & your insights regarding the Steelers - hope you’re mojo is high today!

Gerry Dulac: Haha. It's cooking

Indiana Fan: I think everyone agrees that our offense under MC is too predictable & lacks imagination. I would say that our defense is equally predictable following the departure of Dick L who orchestrated Blitz Burg with lots of intricate blitz packages. Just sitting back in a zone doesn’t work when we get no pressure on QB.

Gerry Dulac: I hear ya. They didn't get pressure on CJ Stroud, which I found amazing considering the patch-work offensive line the Texans were using. But they have been getting pressure. And I think they sit in zone a lot because they dont have press-man corners, though they do have one on the bench.

Yates: Gerry- IMO if the answer Tomlin gave to the 4th and one call was the real reason for the call that speaks volumes about MT’s fundamental cluelessness on offensive play calling which perhaps explains why he appears to be the only person on the planet who doesn’t think Canada should be fired. Some beat writer needs to press Canada on that call as well. I am sure his lip service response will be if the call worked no one would be second guessing it. He and MT are the laughingstocks of the NFL. Come AR/ do what any good businessman would do. Cut your losses.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Well, you have at least figured out what Canada's response will be tomorrow when we get a shot at him. Once again, the problem I have with the call is not having Pickett under center. Putting him in the shotgun reduces his options and makes it an easier read for the defense.

Tampa Too: Gerry What did you think of Canada's comment last week that the Steeler offense was not built to come from behind? Really? And whose fault is it that they can not do this in today's offense explosive NFL

Gerry Dulac: I'll say this -- as surprising as it was, it was 100 percent accurate. I know...really??

Chucky: Major changes are needed in the organization including replacing the entire coaching staff. The team has become unprepared, soft, predictable, undisciplined, and not physical. We need a hard nosed coach like Cowher, not one that wants to look cool and be friends with the players. I feel the perfect man to change the culture of this team is available - Jon Gruden. Do you think Gruden would be interested and would you pursue him?

Gerry Dulac: I thought Gruden -- Tomlin's friend -- would be the perfect choice for OC. But I think he might be a little toxic to hire.

Advertise with us

SteelerDayTrader: Everybody loves TJ Watt, but he came up small last week and rarely slams the door shut in big games. Most of his stats seems to be in blowouts. Will he ever become a Door Slammer?

Gerry Dulac: I was surprised how ineffective he was against the Texans, playing against backup tackles and in front of his brother. I was already counting three sacks before the game even started. He knows he didn't play well at all.

Tony: If the Steelers continue to perform at a high school level how long before some significant changes take place.

Gerry Dulac: Tony, I'd hold off on thinking significant changes will take place.

Tampa Too: Gerry I never played or coached football but I can tell (with this offense) whether they are going to run or pass. Is this offense too predictable for todays NFL?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Based on the way they played, it certainly seems that way, eh?

Jeemie: Mike Tomlin hasn’t won a playoff game in 7 years which I believe is the longest such streak by the Steelers since 1972. His time should be up in Pittsburgh. Are there even any Tomlin believers left?

Gerry Dulac: That is correct. Longest drought since they first made the playoffs in 72. Last playoff win was 2016. And in their last three playoff appearances, they have have allowed 42, 45 and 48 points. That's a 45-point average, in case you're bad at math.

AtlantaDan: Is there a realistic scenario where AJRII and, with the support of AJRII the front office, takes a more assertive role in the selection of a new OC from outside the organization for 2024, who may not be the preferred choice of Mike Tomlin, and Tomlin then getting ruffled by restrictions on his authority to hire assistants that potentially leads Tomlin to threaten to resign as was the case when Dan Rooney ordered Chuck Noll to fire assistant coach Jed Hughes at the end of the 1988 season

Gerry Dulac: Sure there is, though I don't expect that to happen. AR2 leaves coaching decisions up to Mike Tomlin, though he does have to sign off on the hire. That being said, I think there were some Rooney fingerprints on the hiring of Todd Haley.

Advertise with us

Hall of Shame: Any idea why Tomlin is called a future Hall of Famer? Many coaches can finish at .500 or above in the regular season. He has won a playoff game in only 4 of his 17 seasons. That's over a 75% failure rate. Is this the new standard for the Hall of Fame?? That's almost as low as the standard that Rooney and Tomlin have for the organization.

Gerry Dulac: I hear ya, but he is called that because he will get in -- two Super Bowl appearances, one SB win, 16th all-time in victories. He is viewed nationally in a much different light than what Steelers fans think of him

Sal: Happy Wednesday Gerry! Are we seeing a Marvin Lewis new version with Mike Tomlin? Seems like the same behaviors are seen in the most recent times. Ill prepared against teams (JAX and CLE on playoffs, but now is more occurrent in regular season), No coaches adjustments on half time and the newest low we are not prepared to recover from an early lead

Gerry Dulac: Never thought of that. At least Tomlin has won playoff games, though it's been a while

Misinformation: Finally, MT has an excuse to depart from MC. Could this burner phone scandal be what provides MT a reason other than 'I made a bad choice in hiring him' to send MC packing?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Did he need any??

Orangesteel: Did Mike Tomlin just say they lost because of physicality? They were badly outschemed by SF and Houston, everybody saw that. When will he be held accountable for badly getting outcoached?

Gerry Dulac: And those schemes are very similar, aren't they?? Good ones, too. Steelers had no answer

TBsteel: I hope Coach T coaches here another 15 years. Just an awesome man and a leader of men who finds a way to get everyone bought in. And he's gonna do it again this year. They will rally to 9-8 and miss the playoffs. Sure they never win anything, but his cliches make me all tingly inside. Is that how Mr Rooney feels too?

Gerry Dulac: Well, TBsteel, I commend you -- either that was heart-felt or sarcasm, and even I couldn't determine which.

Advertise with us

Outside the Box: Are Tomlin pressers kinda like the movie Groundhog Day? Different turns of phrase, different nonsensical occurrences/excuses, but largely the same day…over and over and over again…

Gerry Dulac: Bingo!!

Bill: Pay the man? I think the brutal travel schedule to different time zones in Las Vegas and Houston in one week that including the emergency landing and sleepless night in Kansas City, and then flying to Houston a few days later is what likely sucked the energy out of the Steelers in the Texans game, and there is really to worry about. Do you agree?

Gerry Dulac: I don't totally agree, but there is something to it, even if it's just a tiny little bit.

Bill: Let’s take Chase Claypool back from the Bears for a 7th Round Pick, it would be a pretty funny development, let’s give it a try, maybe he learned his lesson and can mostly used as a decoy on the Steelers again, why not?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Next.

Bill: Why are you the only Steelers PG writer who is never critical of Mike Tomlin? Are you in the tank because he talks to you in private?

Gerry Dulac: How did you know??

KillCowher: Why do all of Pickett’s receivers fall down and jump when trying to catch his perfect passes? Between Mason Rudolph and Kenny Pickett, we’ve got the best couple QBs here since Bradshaw, why won’t they get a better O line and receivers?

Gerry Dulac: Wow, you're revisionist history needs a little work

Advertise with us

Sal: Hey Gerry Are we seeing more usage of the rookies since this week or are we going to wait until after the bye?

Gerry Dulac: Well, they have to use Broderick Jones and Darnell Washington because of injuries, so yeah. Now if we can only see more of JPJ on the field...

Outside the Box: Just a note. On Earth B, where the goal is not championships, but rather stringing together as many non-losing seasons as possible, the Pittsburgh Steelers have achieved that world’s equivalent of the 70’s Steelers. How do we bring the franchise back?

Gerry Dulac: That's right....that would be the equivalent of many Lombardi trophies

Stillchest: If Tomlin and his staff believe so strongly in executing the called play as they seem to speak to, why even have a playbook or OC? Just have one run play and one pass play and execute it well. Is the real answer that they won’t admit the coaching is the problem so they blame players with the “execute better” line of crap?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Trust me, it's not all Matt Canada. And that's not a defense of him, just the reality

Swissvale72: Everyone knows the offense is bad, but the defense is a bottom 10 unit right now as well and they’ve allowed over 40 points per game in the playoffs over their last few trips there. What exactly does Tomlin do well, aside from having a well developed repertoire of BS

Gerry Dulac: 45 points to be exact. Hey, I'm not giving them a pass, not at all, but they spend way too much time on the field because of all the three-and-outs by the offense. But, for the 1,000th time, if you don't think they need to use a No. 1 pick on a defensive lineman, find another Cam Heyward, you don't know what you're looking at.

Barry: Gerry - do you think there's a growing sense of frustration amongst Steelers brass? Being out schemed almost weekly and the lack of player development over the years is jarring. Not a good look when a makeshift Texans o-line with K. Greene looks like the better line. The same issues plague this team year after year, but I guess the answer to all the problems is to have a padded practice on a Wednesday. That should fix it!

Gerry Dulac: Of course there is. Nobody likes what they're watching.

Advertise with us

AtlantaDan: Is Patrick Peterson playing more at outside cornerback with less than stellar results and less in the nickel/slot position than allegedly was the plan in preseason an indication of Joey Porter, Jr not progressing as quickly as anticipated or just a hesitation of Mike Tomlin & his assistants to give major playing time to first year players?

Gerry Dulac: He's playing more outside than he should be and he's supposed to be playing. That was not the intent when they signed him. They didn't want him on the edge, running with receivers, but there he is. It's not fair to Peterson to put him in positions where he is not the CB he used to be.

Joe: Does Khan have authority to fire Mike Tomlin, as most GMs would, or is that move something only ARII would be able to do? I’m asking because it’s clear Tomlin has no intention of making the necessary changes to try to have a successful season and the team won’t improve until he’s gone. Doesn’t anyone in the front office see this?

Gerry Dulac: No he does not. Only AR2. And how can you help not seeing it??

SP: Kenny Pickett is not an NFL QB and the very last pick from his draft class Brock Purdy is a far superior QB. Wasn’t there a rumor the Steelers liked Purdy in the draft process then took two other QBs over him?

Gerry Dulac: Some of their coaches liked Purdy as, say, a fifth-round pick, which is why it was so shocking when they drafted Chris Oladokun on the seventh round. Ugh

Jay: Morning Gerry. John Mitchell was a great DLine coach, often turning mid-low round picks into quality starters. Dunbar is underperformed. Tomlin defense has had many dominant showcases, but twice as many embarrassing performances. This Houston beat down felt like the Jaguar beat down years ago in the regular season before they realized they were good

Gerry Dulac: Yes he was. And before who realized they were good -- Steelers or Jaguars??

TummayLake: We all realize Mike Tomlin will never win another SB, but it’s more likely now he won’t ever win another playoff game, they can’t extend him after this season, right?

Gerry Dulac: That's really going out on a limb, don't you think?

MadChatter: I’ve never seen Steelers fans worked up into such a FURY as they are right now at Canada and Tomlin. Has Rooney got the message yet or is all this Steeler Fury being wasted?

Gerry Dulac: One bad series Sunday against the Ravens and they will be reminded again by the fans!

Jay: Morning Gerry. Why isn't Tomlin more aggressive/interested in finding established experienced coordinators and allow them to branch their assistants like many teams do?

Gerry Dulac: Pay the man!

Gerry Dulac: Ok kids, sorry have to end this session. It's a good one. Have to head to the locker room and hope I have a private conversation with Tomlin so I don't criticize him.