Conventional wisdom in late April was that the Steelers crushed their first draft under general manager Omar Khan. Pundits both locally and nationally raved about their seven picks, from top to bottom, extracting value and hitting on positional needs left and right.
Their 2023 rookies haven’t proven a thing yet, but on the cusp of the regular season, they’ve already made history. It’s the first Steelers draft class to have each of its members survive cut-down day — and they’d all be on the 53-man roster if not for seventh-rounder Cory Trice Jr.’s season-ending knee surgery in camp that sent him to injured reserve, as sure a sign as any that he would’ve made the team.
But all six healthy members of the group are active and itching to play, some in a more significant manner than others. While their unprecedented preseason is partially due to a smaller class to begin with — and a higher number of picks concentrated in the first four rounds than usual — it’s also an encouraging sign for a bright future.
With that in mind, let’s go player by player for a progress report, of sorts, before they begin receiving Ray Fittipaldo’s report card grades in Week 1:
Broderick Jones (Georgia), first round, No. 14 overall, left tackle
Rookie’s take — On his overall development: “I feel like I had a solid performance throughout all three [preseason] games. There’s always something you can improve on, but for the most part, I feel like I took a step in the right direction. ... Footwork, hands, just being able to play within your game, learning your game, your style of play. ... I really won’t know until the real season starts when the ball gets to kicking and we get to playing week after week. It’s long. But I went through that at Georgia. It’s really not as bad as people think it is. The practices aren’t as bad as college, so that’s the plus of coming to the league from college. But it’s longer hours. You have more studying, more film. You want to take care of your body more. It’s a lot of different things you want to improve on that you think don’t matter that really play a big factor.”
Read More
Coach’s take — Offensive coordinator Matt Canada: “Man, I really like him. I think he plays super hard. I think he does everything you'd like a guy to do. He's trying to get better every day, and we're in a fortunate situation where we've got three really good tackles competing for those jobs. Chuks [Okorafor] and Dan [Moore Jr.] have played a lot of football for us, and Broderick is coming in and battling. So I credit him for coming to work every day, and he gets better every day. I think he'll continue to grow. And he's got a huge, huge ceiling as he evolves into an NFL player.”
Teammate’s take — Starting left tackle Dan Moore Jr.: “I think as young offensive linemen, man, one of the toughest things is just understanding the playbook, getting a grasp of defenses, what’s common in the NFL. There’s not as many tells as in college on defenses and defensive lines — what guys are gonna do pre-snap. It’s just a harder adjustment on the mental side. And just watching him grow more as a player, his understanding, I think that’s the biggest jump that I’ve seen from him.”
Joey Porter Jr. (Penn State), second round, No. 32 overall, outside cornerback
Rookie’s take — On if he could start Week 1: “I have no idea. I’m gonna leave that to the boss man and the people upstairs to make that decision. You always want that for yourself, but I just gotta keep coming in with the same attitude, try to get better every day. I’m happy with the way it’s gone. There’s alway still stuff to work on and improve, but I just got in here. I’m still trying to learn and everything like that. I’m happy where I’m at.”
Coach’s take — Defensive coordinator Teryl Austin: “I think the biggest place he's grown the most is just the technique of an NFL DB. But that's like every college guy coming in. That's the biggest area you have to grow because if you don't, you're going to get a ton of penalties and you're going to struggle. And he had one [pass-interference penalty against the Falcons]. It really was kind of a minor thing. When he's kind of bringing a guy in, he’s just got to know to keep his arm off of him, but everything else he did was pretty good. So it's working that way, and I think that's probably the biggest area is just the technique part of it — probably night and day from what he's used to.”
Teammate’s take — Wide receiver Gunner Olszewski: “I think he’s done a good job in training camp. He’s tall. He’s fast. He can run and he’s smart. And he’s got great guys to learn from in that room, so I think the sky’s the limit for him.”
Keeanu Benton (Wisconsin), second round, No. 49 overall, defensive tackle
Rookie’s take — On what he’s learned: “Game-wise, just kind of realizing it’s the same game as I played in college. Trusting the process and then trusting what coaches tell me is going to come. It just kind of comes with being with a new team, as well. But the coaches are very knowledgeable, and same with the players who are vets to me. It’s just trusting those guys and going out there and unleashing.”
Coach’s take — Defensive line coach Karl Dunbar: “He’s a big, athletic kid. He’s learning how to do things. He has great balance and body control, and you love that from a big man. He can use his hands. He can move his feet and he’s smart. He understands. He picks up things. When we got him in the second round, we were happy to have him, and he’s not disappointing us.”
Teammate’s take — Starting defensive tackle Montravius Adams: “I wouldn't say he’s not ready. I think he’s prepared for what we do and what he’s supposed to know. I think the learning curve comes with it. You’ve got to go out there and play, so I think there will be some mistakes, just like everybody. But at the end of the day, I think he’ll be a guy that will play a lot. We’re gonna need him in some key moments, and he’s taken every step to get better. Keeanu is way better than I was my rookie year at this point. I lacked a lot of fundamentals. He’s way, way more polished. He’s a guy who understands football, understands how to play the game.”
Darnell Washington (Georgia), third round, No. 93 overall, tight end
Rookie’s take — On how he’s adjusting: “What I’ve learned the most is probably just how much I have to rely on my fundamentals. Some things in college, I was doing just because I’m bigger or stronger than my opponent. Now that I get to this league, ... I’ve learned I’m going to really have to rely on my footwork, my hand placement, all that good stuff.”
Coach’s take — Canada: “You guys who have been here have seen it — he makes plays. I think we saw that on film. Obviously, I think we all knew what a good blocker he was and the way he could come in and help control the edge or do certain things at the point. I think those are what we expected, but he has made some plays through the spring that kind of brought that to our attention and continues to do that.”
Teammate’s take — Safety Minkah Fitzpatrick: “He’s tough, man. He’s tough. From a safety standpoint, no matter what you do, no matter how good of coverage you’re in, if the quarterback places a good ball, he’s gonna catch it. He’s a physical guy, a big-bodied guy, but he’s also an athlete. He knows how to move. He has great body control. I don't know if he played basketball or not, but he reminds me of a basketball player with the body control he has. And, obviously, he’s a monster in the run game, moving outside linebackers and D-ends like it’s nothing. He’s a guy who’s gonna help us out a lot.”
Nick Herbig (Wisconsin), fourth round, No. 132 overall, outside linebacker
Rookie’s take — On what more he can provide: “I want to make sure I’m good on my punt coverage. I need to be better on that. ... I would say I just bring life — I’m a younger guy with a lot of vets in our group, so I just bring that spark sometimes when the guys need it. Whether that’s yelling or giving T.J. [Watt] and Alex [Highsmith] some energy, whatever it is, whatever they ask of me, I feel like that’s kind of my role. I’ll be that plug-and-play guy, but if they need me to go get them a Gatorade or tie their shoes or go in for a play because they need a breather, I feel like that’s what I bring to this group, for sure.”
Coach’s take — Outside linebackers coach Denzel Martin: “He’s a real sponge. He asks so many questions, and whatever you tell him or you’re working on, he’ll put right into that practice that day. It’s been very encouraging. He’s got a natural mindset of that chip on his shoulder — he’s a little brother.”
Teammate’s take — Outside linebacker Alex Highsmith: “He’s got a cool little jump-through move that I’ve been trying to learn. It’s like a little stab and jump-through, so he’s got a good arsenal for him coming in as a rookie. It’s showing that he’s watched a lot of T.J.’s film, with them both being from Wisconsin. He’s definitely come in and learned a lot. I just love his willingness to learn and get better.”
Spencer Anderson (Maryland), seventh round, No. 251 overall, offensive lineman
Rookie’s take — On making the 53-man roster thanks to playing all five positions: “I expected myself to be here. I’ve worked all my life for this moment. It used to be ‘one day’ and now it’s ‘Day 1.’ That’s just how I look at it. I’ve prepared myself to be in this position. Obviously, it’s a good step toward my career in the long run, but work still has to be done. As we all know, the 53 is fluid.”
Coach’s take — Head coach Mike Tomlin: “He did all those things in college. If you show versatility, it helps his cause and ours. He appears to be a young guy, at least intellectually, that's capable of handling it. The more we give him reps, it’ll be revealed whether he's physically capable of handling. So far, so good.”
Teammate’s take — Left guard Isaac Seumalo: “The NFL’s all about value. Your value goes up when you can do more. It lengthens your career. Obviously, you'd like to specialize in one spot and get great at that because that’s where the money is. But I think as a young guy, as a late-round pick, he’s got a lot of skill, talent, good balance. He’s strong, athletic, so his ceiling’s high. It just takes time. It takes experience. When I was in Philly last year and here last year, that’s the exception of guys playing every game. At one point, everybody’s gonna play.”
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.